A solution to Pirates ?

There are many ships passing through everyday. Several hundred, I believe. That makes for a gigantic convoy should you seek to assemble such a large and motly collection of ships. In all liklihood a dozen or more escort ships able to work in a closely coordinated fashion might be required....every day, all month long, etcc. What government or commercial outfit is prepared to shoulder the expense of "someone else's problem" ???
 
I agree with Vic. When I was in the 5th fleet we traveled the Suez escorted by two navy destroyers, in the front and brining up the rear.(BTW this is where the term "Rear Admiral” originated as he was the commander of the flotilla). Sure it was a longer transition, getting all the ships coordinated, but considering the amount of time it takes to regain a hijacked ship it is nothing. This is a sure way to insure no pirates will take a chance at a destroyer (aptly named)
 
Piracy was stopped once before. Seems to me the same strategy would work again. Question is, do we as a people have the stomach for it?
 
The american people have No stomach... We are becoming spineless.... kinda like the french... OK maybe not but close?

Rob
 
Here is an interesting article on the subject.

http://globalintel.net/wp/2008/11/2...in-maritime-counter-terrorism-counter-piracy/

The enemy looks like this: on sea, you have pirates on skiffs that make the capture. Mother boats or ships are also employed. The pirate ports are run by organized crime or terrorists, whatever you want to call them. Reports to the contrary, I believe satellite recon is there to pinpoint every one of these port operations.

Putting CIWS on every ship is costly and a serious security compromise. Deploying a huge naval force is needlessly expensive.

Do the international diplomacy and legal work first. Make use of multinational military resources. The more countries that are on the same page with us, the better. Make shippers pay the bills as much as possible. You need some adjustments to maritime law regarding weapons and the merchant marine and deployment of marines on merchant ships.

Next, stop active piracies. We don't want to add more ships and hostages to the pirate ports. Typical pirate attack skiffs are armed with AK-47s and RPGs. A marine squad on every merchant ship with portable or shoulder-fired missiles can identify and destroy any pirate skiff before they take the shot.

A couple of missile frigates with cruise missiles or predators can take out the mother ships.

The big bang. Once the active piracy is stopped, wait a year or two until captured ships and hostages are less of an issue. That will be the time for a larger military action to recapture remaining ships and hostages and destroy the pirate ports. Play it smart. Give civilians a warning and then flatten the ports.

That will be the end of the piracy problem.
 
Old news I recommended this over a week ago in NBR. Blackwater is one of my customers. Bill
 
"That will be the end of the piracy problem." -- yzer

Uh, no.

Piracy has been around nearly as long as women "offering comfort" for "favors". And you can expect both to remain a part of human society. You do have a point that it can possibly be reduced, but you won't get rid of it. Remember, they used to hang pirates, and it didn't stop them then. Blowing them up will "increase the cost of doing business" but it sure won't stop it, only slow it down.

( Sure. I would like to see it stopped. But I am mature enough to know that it simply is not going to happen. )
 
Watching the headlines over the past thirty years has shown me that piracy has taken a dramactic upswing since 9/11. I think you would be very hard pressed to show me comparable incidences of piracy in the Gulf of Aden or the Indian Ocean region during the 50 years prior to 2001.

I'm not talking about stopping piracy around the globe. Anyone who reads the cruising periodicals knows better that that. I'm talking about the piracy problem that exists now in the trade routes of the Gulf of Aden and Indian Ocean.

Maturity includes the ability to focus on the problem at hand without resorting to historical semantics.

Mercinaries like Blackwater are useful only when other military means are not available or affordable. The problem with mercinary organizations is that they have no vested interest in peace. When the fighting is over, mercinaries are out of a job.
 
I agree fully with your analysis of the upswing since the new century took hold. Some recent changes have exacerbated the problem. Failed States along the coast on both sides of the Horn of Africa have led to further hardships and marginal living of "the natives". Widespread ability to communicate with cell phhones. A growing unhappiness amongst area folk with the vast differences in wealth distribution. Better organization of dissident gangs who have recognized the wealth that passes by their litterol areas---something that might be plucked off the tree when no master was looking. This all is a fairly recent occurance as Yzer claims.

As for solution in the immediate timeframe: Whose interests are served by a cessation of the piracy? Obviously the mercantile interests who transport liquid energy and some lessor number of cruise ships loaded with wealthy, jewell-laden ladies. Few other people anywhere are truly bothered with the issue. There is little need for concern by 95% of the people who read the daily news throughout the educated world. IMHO Those who are directly at risk must drive the solution.
 
Back
Top