Another Wake Discussion

As Pascal says...

"i don't care about who is responsible or liable... it's about courtesy."

"Courtesy," is like a dinosaur - dead, gone, a thing of the past. You don't find in very often in life, on the street or on the water. Life's too short to be a jerk.

But sometimes you can get your point across.

"I had seen it coming and had already squeezed to stbd near the red marker forcing him to slow down..."

Right on, Pascal!
 
quote:

Originally posted by dominic

I'll try to answer that.....

Third, my destination is quite typically a run down to a restaurant along, or just off of, the ICW.






I think they may want you to stay at your dock and eat in. :) lol
 
quote:

Originally posted by Robski97

I guess no other boats plow but Searays ?

Rob






A few. But sadly, at least in FL, the majority seem to be Searays. They also seem to be the last to slow down.
 
Walter, sometimes that stupid person is in that position because of a mechanical issue. Does that still make them "deserving"?
But even if they are just stupid or inconsiderate, should we consciously take the roles of cop, judge and executioner and intentionally punish them with our wake? Believe me, these behaviors are some of my biggest pet peeves, and the little thought cloud above my head usually entails cannon fire, but I think we can make our displeasure known via the horns and loud hailer, with a little "lecture" delivered from the side deck by my wife. We have actually had people apologize after receiving the latter. I also radio a securite if someone is anchored in the channel, in the usually vain hope that the CG or an LEO is in the area.

Again, I don't in any way excuse the operators of small boats from knowing the rules, being considerate and having the proper seamanship skills, but if I can do something to make a situation safer for everyone at the scene, I feel obliged to do it.

George
Hatteras 56MY
Boston Whaler 130 Sport
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

it's a sportfish thing... every obnoxious wake i've encountered on the ICW has come from a SF!





My ICW experience (much less than yours) has been similar. This spring near St. Lucie, while we didn't have to deal with it, I heard over 16: "50-foot Viking, did you just get your captain's license yesterday?"

Here at home on the Chesapeake it's usually the 30-50 foot express cruisers and aft-cabins that cause most of the wake issues, the latter being the worse. Bow up seems to be the norm for operation, and the rest of us better stay out of their way. However, my last encounter with a SF was rather amazing. We were trying out some new props that were totally wrong for the boat and suffering along at 12 knots. I see this 40-ish footer coming up behind me and I'm preparing to be waked. Next thing I know he veers off to my port a good 1/2 mile behind me. Continues to pass at least 1/2 mile away and then eventually comes back to my same course to end up at my same destination. I was amazed. I thought about looking him up and thanking him, but couldn't find him later that day. What does it say when you actually have to thank people for doing the right/courteous thing? I could bore you with a 20:1 ratio of stories where the opposite happened (like the time two express cruisers passed me, one on each side, 20 yards away in a wide open bay).
 
quote:

Originally posted by walterv

If you’re stupid enough to tie to a bridge, block a bridge entrance, anchor in or right outside a channel or impede navigation in a channel, then you are at fault and deserve all that happens when the big boat comes by. It's all about "respect" if you want it, than give it!!!, otherwise go pound wood.






"NO ONE HERE is saying "screw you.""

Want to run that by me again Les? :-)
 
quote:

Originally posted by Capt. Bill1

So it's more realistic to expect every small boat to know how to handle a large wake?






Damn straight!

Notice how the following statement applies to ALL types of boats, not just large or small.

If you can't handle the conditions you encounter while boating you can die.
 
Based on this thread and "the other thread", my conclusion is that we boaters are on our own to deal with what happens on the water. Law enforcement is essentially non-existent, even in the face of documented reports.
I agree with the concept of at least making an attempt to contact other vessels that aren't showing consideration, but, like Mixman, I plan to be disappointed with their lack of reaction in most cases. On the other hand, if you don't at least TRY, they'll never respond. We were rafted up last weekend in a designated and patrolled no-wake zone when a 23' bowrider came by, nose up, at about 10 mph. We shouted and waved, but they merrily waved back. We broke out the airhorn and gave them a good blast, at which point they promptly fell to idle speed. It turned out that they were brand-new boaters, and had no idea what was proper. They even apologized. At least now they know....

To paraphrase: "All that is necessary for the triumph of bad boaters is for knowledgable boaters to say nothing."
 
In the good ole USA you have the right to do what you will even if it kills you; just try not to kill anyone else. Freedom is not free, it requires choices, responsibiity, and accounatbility, one way or another. Boating is fun and dangerous.

You can choose to take the freedom or stay safely at home.

I choose freedom.
 
I promise, I wasn't searching for this for this thread (I was trying to figure out why the 6mph limit right outside my marina and our fuel dock was just removed!). However, I found this statement:

" A vessel creating wake is presumed at fault for damage caused by wave wash"

Here: http://www.boatinglaw.com/document.cfm/collision
 
quote:

Originally posted by mixman

I promise, I wasn't searching for this for this thread (I was trying to figure out why the 6mph limit right outside my marina and our fuel dock was just removed!). However, I found this statement:

" A vessel creating wake is presumed at fault for damage caused by wave wash"

Here: http://www.boatinglaw.com/document.cfm/collision






"A vessel creating a wake is presumed at fault for damage caused by wave wash."

Kurt, do you know if they are basing this in actual statutory law, General Maritime Law or case law? It sure seems to be a broad stroke statement and I was wondering what they base it on. I know that, in the state of Florida, that's pretty much the situation for tort cases but the statement, as contained in th elink, seems to be much more far reaching.

Bob
 
Bob,

I honestly don't know. I just stumbled upon it searching for something else and figured I'd post it. You would have to contact them and ask. They appear to be a rather accomplished Maritime law firm in Annapolis.
 
It appears to be nothing more than an opinion or puff talk on their website. That statement is no where in the CFR.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Maycpa

It appears to be nothing more than an opinion or puff talk on their website. That statement is no where in the CFR.






If it is a matter of statute, general maritime law or civil case law it will not be in the CFR. That's why I asked the question.

I did, however, send an email to the firm asking the question. If they reply I will gladly post it here.

Bob
 
Back
Top