Bilge pump size

In addition to installed pumps, I have an emergency independent pump with 12 feet of hose which connects to a cigar plug. 1t can be deployed within a few seconds.
 
Trick for that "toss-in" pump:

Make an adapter with one end being a cigar lighter socket, the other end fitted with medium size clothespin type clips. Then tape the adapter about a foot away from the plug.

In the event you pass the pump to a vessel in need, they can either plug directly into an available cigar lighter-type socket, or they can plug into the adapter and then clip onto the battery...

--

This type of pump can be useful in some situations. But be sure to TEST IT prior to an emergency. Common issues include a pump that "won't stay sunk", or a hose that is too stiff to allow proper placement. Done correctly, this is a useful tool.
 
You are missing my point here Billy. The industry did not even think up of the data sentences to address things like high bilge water, fuel vapor detection, etc in NMEA 2000. These are pretty common events on a boat that happen with some frequency..yet where are the protocols? Not there, because no one is thinking of them. That demonstrates a gross lack of attention in the industry to the man machine interface and the human factors involved in operating that machinery.

Yes AIS is great, but its incorporation as a NMEA 2000 device was a matter of neccesity, to make it operate with your chart plotters and radios, not because of vision by the boat building industry. Hells bells, they did'nt invent AIS in the first place, the shipping industry did. It is trickle down tech.

I would note that new cars for instance have "blind spot detectors", lane drift detection, vehicle ahead stop detection, and driver doze alerting. The industry saw a hole in the man machine interface and has taken action to rememdy and close that hole. They did not get these from the trucking industry, they worked on the problem themselves. Where is that in boating on the most minute scale in the boating industry? Nope they just keep turning out Airstreams that float and call them boats and yachts.

The very fact that they failed to put the most common safety related detections into the NMEA 2000 protocols speaks volumes about where their head is at and it is not making the helmsman a better and more efficient operator of the vehicle.
 
I am very late to this discussion and too lazy to read everything so if I repeat what already has been discussed, please excuse it.

We went over something like this quite some years ago and back then it was pretty much concluded that a 1 1/2" hole 12" below the water line would fill a hull faster then most pumps could remove.

I'm sure someone must have some kind of link to those numbers. I'd like to see what they were.
 
Charlie, KinCal posted the chart. It is on page two, near the bottom...

And we are back at the point of the discussion: In most cases, especially in a smaller boat, you will -not- save the boat. It will sink unless you plug the hole. The purpose of increasing the pump capacity is to increase the time you have to either plug the hole, or make preparation to abandon.

Most "standard equipment" pumps are fairly useless. But you can make them useful by increasing the capacity.
 
Another argument for a good bilge alarm system; early warning means more time.

Ultimately the only other things that will save the boat are stopping the leak, positive flotation (required in small boats) and compartmentation (not a strong point with pleasure boats but standard on ships). Even then, those approaches also have their limits.

Re the chart... it's in gallons per MINUTE. A little misleading as most bilge pumps are rated in gallons per HOUR. Convert the chart to Gallons/Hour and it gets really scary.
 
Back
Top