Generator for small cruiser

Ahem, "1 "ton of cooling", a common unit in North American refrigeration and air conditioning applications, is 12,000 BTU/h. It is the amount of power needed to melt one short ton of ice in 24 hours, and is approximately 3.51 kW.", from "Wikipedia"

I stand by my statement.
 
Thanks for standing by your statement. Your "canned definition" of Tons of A/C is in fact true. If A/C sizing requirements for marine applications is 10-12 BTU per cubic foot. Meaning for a cuddy cabin typical of 24 ft will be somewhere in the neighborhood of 5,000 BTU. What you fail to realize is the fact that once cooled to a certain temperature, maintaining that temperature requires less energy. This is due to the fact that the materials that make up the cabin surroundings have what is known as latent properties. This helps to drop the load required even farther down. Nightime temperatures will assist in this as well.

I stand by MY statement that this system does work. Does it work like the A/C on your 42 ft MY? maybe not. Would it help in his situation? I believe so.

The man wants cool. I merely suggested what works for me. My boat is a 22' cuddy. not a lot of difference in size, but it really does make a difference. The difference in having to get a motel room and being able to sleep on the boat.

For us...... it works. We sleep easy at night knowing that we haven't turned our cabin into a gas chamber. When we wake up the next morning, I WILL crank my generator long enough to make coffee. If ya anchor next to me I may even offer ya a cup. We can disagree all we like but it's still not getting this guys problem solved. Be it A/C or otherwise, this guy wants cool at night and wants to be safe about it. My suggestion stands speaking from experience. Yours is merely an opinion.
 
Whatever works for you and whatever you are comfortable with... We use the EU2000i and are very comfortable with it's operation. Two CO detectors and we never sleep with it running.. Come to think of it, we could easily sleep with it running as it would run out of gas half way through the night.. Neither detector has ever sounded running the honda but they HAVE gone off from station wagon effect running the boats engine.
 
I think you should buy a Honda 2000, not a bigger boat but a smaller one, a dinghy. Load the Honda on the dinghy, get a 100ft extension cord and row the dinghy away from your 24' cruiser and anchor it. Start up the Honda,swim back to your cruiser(the swim will cool you off)Plug the air cond in to the extension cord, start the A/C and go to sleep wet! I believe you will remain cool, the exhaust will disapate before it gets back to your sleeping berth and all will be well. Also the noise will be way over there where it will only effect the guy you anchored the dinghy next to!
 
Cool, Larry, I'll see you in the Abacos. Oh, wait, have you ever even left IA???? Even more so, on your boat???

How 'bout from now on only people who actually cruise answer this thread?
 
Maybe you will be able to match my cruising someday! Rock Creek MD. Nice spot!
 
Dude, Rock Creek is just where we keep the boat. We've been from MD to FL and to the Abacos for the last two years. And we'll most likely do the Exumas in Spring 2010. That's a good bit more than IA lake boating. Shucks. A Doral is a real nice lake boat. But please don't try and cross the Gulf Stream in it. Blub, blub, blub....
 
quote:

Originally posted by mlaymance

I am an HVAC Engineer, so I know about A/C ad it has no relation to tons of Ice. Ice can be below 32 degrees, It can be 22 degrees, or even 10 degrees for that matter. This device delivers a liquid (not a refrigerant) such as water through a coil which has a fan blowing on it. Effective? depends. will it bring a 42 ft MY down to 72 degrees for 8-10 hours? no. Will it cool the cabin in a 24 ft cuddy? yes. Will it bring that temp to 72 degrees? if you want it to, but for how long again depends on the temperature of the Ice, the insulation factor of the cabin, and the aiflow.

I needed something to keep the cabin cool on my cuddy because my wife has cancer, but refuses to let that stop her from enjoying the boat and cruising.

This device does work. Does it work as well as a 1/2 ton A/C unit (6,000 BTU) no. but in my cabin a 6000 BTU is still too large. If I want a place to get my bride out of the sun for a while, this device has worked more than once.

The trck is to use a very good cooler and plenty of Ice.




I worked for a company as a contract engineer in the early 80's. The old passive AC units in surveillance vans for the FBI. The dry ice untis work fantastic until 2 agnts did not follow the instructions and were found dead. The gas discharges from the unbolted lid had displaced all the oxygen and they expired from asphyxiating. The FBI came out with a new spec. to use standard ice. The device was a tub filled with coils and an outer chamber that had a blower motor. They worked fairly well but the dry ice units worked better, lasted longer and ran considerably longer. I found using block ice then a small layer of rock salt more ice another small layer of rock salt and finally ice and you could get 6 hours of cooling in the back of a Ford full sized van. The vans were foamed and had passive heat removal through the optical camera scope in the roof. I ended up working and using one of these vans for another agency and it did work. So the main problem with boating is where do you get 80lbs of ice? How do you keep it until you need it at until night when it would be needed and this would be a safe alternative but the unit was larger than a generator and heavier. The dry ice version was smaller, lasted longer but you had to deal with carbon dioxide or asphyxiating youself.
Bill
 
MixMan
You sure do read a lot into the fact that I presently own a Doral and I keep it in Iowa!
I'm impressed!
I'm also done with this nonsense!
 
I've been reading and keeping up with this entire thread and have found it quite interesting. Lot's of good, valid points on both sides of the table.

I do have a question though; I have been on more live-aboard SCUBA dive boats and live-aboard fishing boats than I can count. All of them, without exception, run their generators full time, none stop, under way, not under way, sleeping, awake, doesn't matter.

I am quite sure they have to carry some pretty hefty liability insurance so, considering the risk of running a gen at night, how do they handle this with their underwriters? If it poses a significant risk wouldn't the underwriters refuse to insure it?

I know that this question is outside the bounds of the OP but since built-in gens have been discussed several times I thought I'd ask the question.

Bob
 
I think you'll find most of those commercial boats have a dry stack out the top somewhere... so the exhaust is discharged high in the air. Also most of them are diesel, which I understand creates less CO in the first place.
 
Good points. They were all deffinitely diesel and probably had dry stacks now that I think about it. Especially the SCUBA dive boats. They're sucking in air to refill SCUBA tanks so the compressor intake would have to be FAR removed from the generator exhaust.

Bob

quote:

Originally posted by stmbtwle

I think you'll find most of those commercial boats have a dry stack out the top somewhere... so the exhaust is discharged high in the air. Also most of them are diesel, which I understand creates less CO in the first place.




 
I usually keep quiet on this topic, until I see arrogant commments about "bringing a furnished apartment to the water" or "if you want the comforts of home, stay home". If that is how you enjoy boating, great, just don't expect everyone to share that opinion. That being said, here is the setup we have enjoyed for the last 4 seasons. We have a Honda 3000i bolted to the original platform of our 270 (we added an extended platform, so space isn't an issue). I relocated the shore power outlet to the stern and connect via a 24" cable. We always swing freely from a bow anchor, so the exhaust is downwind. For further assurance, I fashioned a baffle that directs the exhaust straight out the back. We have 3 CO detectors, 2 with readouts. The only times they have shown elevated levels is with the boats engine running, with either a breeze from astern or while backing up. Sleeping w/o ac in the deep south is not an option for us, we tried when we bought the boat. Last Friday at 10pm when I cranked the genny, the cabin temp was 87 degrees. As far as noise, it is no louder inside than any boat with a built in thatI have been on, and if you are anchored at a safe distance, you won't hear it. These things are unbelievably quiet. I can go 2 nights w/ac and charger on one tank of fuel. We believe, with redundancy and attention to detail, that this is a safe setup or we wouldn't do it. But as I stated earlier, I don't expect everyone to share that opinion. There, my .02 worth.
 
Wow, Sea Ray owners (at least on that forum) think there's instant death from using a Honda generator. I have to be careful here as I've got some friends locally that have Sea Rays, and some more friends on this forum, but I wouldn't really take any sort of advice from a Sea Ray forum with those kind of comments. Well, maybe if it was about what bowling ball to buy....or what high-top tennis shoe.

Does Brunswick even make any ocean rated models? I guess they do considering they own Hatteras, Cabo, Trophy, etc. Wow, Brunswick owns a heck of a lot of brands!
 
And you thought healthcare reform got peoples dander up !! All it takes on here is the title, "Honda 2000" To each his own.
 
Back
Top