No discharge zone?

quote:

Originally posted by HOGAN

Is 'dropping a deuce' off the side of the boat in a NDZ illegal?






Watch it with the "deuce" comment, would you? The boat came with that name and I'm superstitious!

From a conversation I had with Vic a while back (I have to give credit where credit is due), you can do #1 into the water any way you like. If you need to do #2, you need to be in the water. The bucket is definitely a no-no. Then there's that indecent exposure issue for either function. Darn government will get you one way or another.
 
Thats what makes this whole arguement silly. If someone is going to dump untreated waste they are probably going to do it late a night when no one is around. Either way tell me how one could tell if the AC pumps were running or taking a shower how anyone could tell you were using your PuraSan? Mine makes no noise there are no visible solids as in -0- in brackish water you wouldn't even see the slight discolorization some report. I just think treated waste should be exempt from NDZs. I revise this to say in all but areas like the clear blue waters in Florida. This reminds me of the Global warming fight that has now been renamed "Climate Change" because we are in a cooling period!
Bill
 
A boat can legally transit an NDZ by locking the through hull valve. I have a Hold-N-Treat system with my own holding tank. I can hold up to 36 gallons before I need to either get a pump out or to get out of the NDZ and activate Hold-N-Treat PuraSan unit to release treated waste. Same thing Kurt has also using a low use water head like the Elegance or VacuFlush helps stretch dumping the holding tank futher.
Bill
 
seems to me that the most liberal areas have been the first to adopt NDZs.

Could it be that because they are so familiar with spewing crap they are the first people to suspect similar behavior from others??
 
quote:

Originally posted by pdecat

seems to me that the most liberal areas have been the first to adopt NDZs.

Could it be that because they are so familiar with spewing crap they are the first people to suspect similar behavior from others??





I believe for the most part you are correct Bruce. Aren't we heading towards NBR territory?
Bill
 
yes, unfortunately ir is difficult to seperate boating from the rocks and shoals set up by those who love to tell everyone else how to behave.
 
Florida? Great Lakes?? On the other hand there are very few in California. If the desire to not boat in a sewer is now a "liberal" thing, gosh I guess I've become one! But talk about a Not Boating Related comment... I suppose the definition of a modern American is someone who can't stand the thought of personal inconvenience for the sake of the greater good of future generations.

No Billy, not NDZ land around here yet.

George
Celebrating a gorgeous Thanksgiving, anchored in Ocracoke, NC.
 
George I don't think I was saying you are un American? The marinas are NDZ anyway just out of pure courtesy. If there is science backing up NDZs which I really believe NDZs were originally intended for large cruise ships and large party fishing boats. Again I never advocate raw dumping I didn't even like doing it at 3 miles that is why I installed the treatment system George. I think the real problem I will use my boating area as an example is this. There is 1 pumpout boat that works weekends only for Little Egg and very few working pumpouts. There is a fairly high differencial in tides which to me means waterflow from the Ocean in and out. The next Bay over Great Egg is not an NDZ. All that seperates them is a very wet marsh when the storms come they connect.
Bill
 
george: You seem to believe that boaters want to crap in the water; IMO that is not true.
What is true is that every single waterway could become a NDZ and nothing would change regarding water quality but if that makes you feel righteous so be it.
 
That is the mentallity I am worried about Bruce. I will concede you could make an arguement that every water system has its own unique ecosystem. The problem I have is I would love to see the science behind before NDZ and after. Once again I am talking "Treated waste".
Boats have been around for how long and NDZ's? What is the baseline other than truely poiltics?Bill
 
I disagree with you Bruce (and who seems to be self righteous here??): the Keys are a good example of when an effort is made to clean up all sources of pollution. Boats are just one element, in some places more important than others: compare Boot Key Harbor today to 10 or 15 years ago. Heck, Westport Harbor in Mass is noticeably cleaner and it has a natural flushing system with the river and strong tides. I have met all too many boaters in our far flung cruising who scoff at the three mile rule, not just NDZs. A big part of the clean up in both of the aforementioned places was due to rigorous enforcement of discharge laws and aggressive pump-out boat programs.

And, I have said about 15 times already in this thread that I agree many NDZ's are silly, but the self righteous amongst us chose to not read that.
 
I am personally in favor of the NDZs. I follow the rules and comply with the laws. When I'm in-shore I use a pump out. When offshore beyond the limit, I pump out and then zip tie the sea cock closed. I am 10 minutes from an inlet so I go offshore on a regular basis. I wouldn't pump out in the bay regardless of the NDZ or not.

My issue is that the pols turn a blind eye when a major source of water contamination continues to occur. They get the NDZs designated and don't provide the means to comply. In many areas, there are no pump out boats and if you find a land based station it is often not operational.

For many years the parks department has directly discharged the bathrooms from the beach into the waterways. Add to that these municipal systems that regularly dump waste.

I've read/heard about them wanting to control the discharge of grey water and even the water that is pumped through your engines raw water cooling system.

If they want to declare all inland waters inside of 3 miles NDZ, that would be fine with me. However, it would be appreciated if they gave boaters the means to comply and controlled the municipal systems that cause a far greater threat to the environment than we do.

My last .02
 
I agree grey water cant be far behind. Those politicians have nothing better to do.

George: I dont know why we got where we are but as I said I don’t discharge and dont want anyone else to do so.
If Boot key harbor is cleaner i doubt it has anything to do with NDZ just normal holding tank and pump out.
I understand you dont like NDZ but using the cleanup in Boot key or anywhere in the same context as NDZ does confuse the issue. Clean water does not IMO require NDZ. Nevertheless they are expanding and I guarantee the next step in the peoples republic of Richardson bay will be grey water control.
 
quote:

Originally posted by mintregila

I am personally in favor of the NDZs. I follow the rules and comply with the laws. When I'm in-shore I use a pump out. When offshore beyond the limit, I pump out and then zip tie the sea cock closed. I am 10 minutes from an inlet so I go offshore on a regular basis. I wouldn't pump out in the bay regardless of the NDZ or not.

My issue is that the pols turn a blind eye when a major source of water contamination continues to occur. They get the NDZs designated and don't provide the means to comply. In many areas, there are no pump out boats and if you find a land based station it is often not operational.

For many years the parks department has directly discharged the bathrooms from the beach into the waterways. Add to that these municipal systems that regularly dump waste.

I've read/heard about them wanting to control the discharge of grey water and even the water that is pumped through your engines raw water cooling system.

If they want to declare all inland waters inside of 3 miles NDZ, that would be fine with me. However, it would be appreciated if they gave boaters the means to comply and controlled the municipal systems that cause a far greater threat to the environment than we do.

My last .02




1. It was illegal to dump untreated sewage from your MSD Type III in inland or coastal waters prior to establishing any NDZ. The NDZ doesn't have any effect on boats equipped with a tank system only.

2. All an NDZ does is make it illegal to use a Type I or II MSD.

Why do you think my MSD Type I should be made illegal when the vast majority of untreated sewage spills from recreational boats are coming from tank systems?
 
quote:

Originally posted by mintregila

I am personally in favor of the NDZs. I follow the rules and comply with the laws. When I'm in-shore I use a pump out. When offshore beyond the limit, I pump out and then zip tie the sea cock closed. I am 10 minutes from an inlet so I go offshore on a regular basis. I wouldn't pump out in the bay regardless of the NDZ or not.

My issue is that the pols turn a blind eye when a major source of water contamination continues to occur. They get the NDZs designated and don't provide the means to comply. In many areas, there are no pump out boats and if you find a land based station it is often not operational.

For many years the parks department has directly discharged the bathrooms from the beach into the waterways. Add to that these municipal systems that regularly dump waste.

I've read/heard about them wanting to control the discharge of grey water and even the water that is pumped through your engines raw water cooling system.

If they want to declare all inland waters inside of 3 miles NDZ, that would be fine with me. However, it would be appreciated if they gave boaters the means to comply and controlled the municipal systems that cause a far greater threat to the environment than we do.

My last .02





So you only pump out at 3 miles? I see you have no USCG treatment system or don't mention one. I agree my example of our area is a prime example 1 boat operates friday through Sunday done by 2PM each day and most pumpout marinas play the pumpout isn't working if you are not a member. Even at 3 miles I can only discharge treated waste. Then there are the working machines that for some reason can not draw enough vacuum to pull any waste from my holding tank. I pressure tested it there is nothing wrong or clogged. I can draw waste with an old shop vac and special fitting so what is their problem?
Bill
 
Because you only defend your Type I system when boat pollution is miniscule compared to what those bay cities do “accidentally“.
Regardless of the boat dumps ,which I suspect are few and wont be fixed by any legislation, anyone that ignores the present laws will ignore everything anyway.
Next year your Type I wont be good enough for Sausalito because you will need to contain grey water.
 
This actually brings up a good point remember the US Boats write in campaign about the onerous EPA regulations that wanted even deck water to be contained on boats and grey water as well? This is where it truely gets dangerous at what point do we need to treat the water that cools our engines? I hoping everyone can see where this could evetually lead?

Bill
 
BillyIII

I didn't specify but it is actually either five plus miles or I call for the pump out boat at my marina. If he happens to be in the area, I get it done regardless of level.
 
We have ours pumped out when the pumpout boat when available. In fact the boat has a low volume pump that doesn't work on mine and others according to the operator. So this summer I took a 6" whole saw and installed a screw on sealed lid that can be removed made specifically for holding tanks. Now the pumpout boat hands my wife the wand she hands it to me down below then the hose I attach both put it in the tank and empty it. A few times I gave the guy a $20.00 and asked if he would let me take my pressure wand and totallly clean the sides of the tank. This worked out well. I then close the pumpout valve seperate the tube from the house hand the hose back out and the wand in a plastic bag. The pumpout boat gets rid of the bag. So I go out of my way to get pumped out even when the station or boat has an issue. There are a few pumpouts that work well with my deck fitting but they are rarely operational when I call them on the radio even when I try and tell them I need fuel as well.
Bill
 
Back
Top