Signaling when passing

I voted very rarely because I boat on a lake and keep a wide space between my boat and any others that are moving. Also always stay in the channels. Very low risk boater.
 
Rommer I do not make up Florida law or boating rules, I live in Ohio. Blame the people in Florida.
 
MyFWC.COM That is where I copied from. I can't find the site where they use the term right of way but I read it today and it was an offical FLA. site. I'll keep looking.
 
Not yet a powerboater, but this is what I remember from my sailing days. The poster's rules may be somewhat oversimplified. For instance: The one about boat under sail has right of way. Not necessarily. It's mostly common sense. The less maneuverable craft, in general, has the right of way, I believe. A tug with a string of barges? He wins. Sailboat crossing ship channel with freighter bearing down? Again, freighter trumps sailboat. Sailboats are also expected to keep clear of trawlers with nets out, or other encumbered vessels. A sailboat under sail does generally have right of way over, say, a cabin cruiser, if no other more urgent rule applies. But there's the old saw: Here lies poor old Michael O'Day. He died maintaining the right of way. He was right. Dead right. Right as the day is long. But he's just as dead as if he were wrong.
 
amelia I the Poster did not make this up I copied pasted erom an offical Fla. site. Leave the messenger out of this one. thank you.
 
Ohhhkay. Excuse me, Rusty! I stand corrected. Allow me to restate, if it makes anybody feel better. 'The rules as copied and pasted. (citation not given)' And of course, as Les pointed out, 'right of way' is not the correct terminology. 'Burdened vessel' is.
 
Amelia you just don't get it.The State of FLORDIA used the term "right of way". I know the proper terminology,but thank you for enlightening those that do not. And Rusty?
 
Rule 18 - Responsibility Between Vessels

Except where rules 9, 10, and 13 otherwise require:
a) A power-driven vessel underway shall keep out of the way of:
1) a vessel not under command
2) a vessel restricted in her ability to move
3) a vessel engaged in fishing
4) a sailing vessel
b) A sailing vessel underway shall keep out of the way of:
1) a vessel not under command
2) a vessel restricted in her ability to move
3) a vessel engaged in fishing
 
And those are big exceptions. Rule 9 is the narrow channel rule - we spend a good deal of our boating life in narrow channels. Rule 13, of course, is the overtaking rule. A sailboat being overtaken must behave like any other boat - maintain course and speed.

And, of course, a sailboat under power and under sail is a powerboat.
 
quote:

Originally posted by amelia

Not yet a powerboater, but this is what I remember from my sailing days. The poster's rules may be somewhat oversimplified. For instance: The one about boat under sail has right of way. Not necessarily. It's mostly common sense. The less maneuverable craft, in general, has the right of way, I believe. A tug with a string of barges? He wins. Sailboat crossing ship channel with freighter bearing down? Again, freighter trumps sailboat. Sailboats are also expected to keep clear of trawlers with nets out, or other encumbered vessels. A sailboat under sail does generally have right of way over, say, a cabin cruiser, if no other more urgent rule applies. But there's the old saw: Here lies poor old Michael O'Day. He died maintaining the right of way. He was right. Dead right. Right as the day is long. But he's just as dead as if he were wrong.






I think that summed it up !

I NEVER in all the years boating respected anyone who knew all the rules but was to stupid to use common sense and no natural ability on the water !! That type can stay on the dock and talk about that crap and wonder why no one wants to talk to you !!
I'll be on the water relaxing and avoiding YOU !!!

I have met many boaters who had common sense and enough knowledge and understanding of the water to keep themselves and others safe.

Why can some guys/gals dock single handed all the time and others need everyone from the marina to help and they still bounce of everything in sight...it's the same thing common sense and time on the water,,,, no book can help you if your just DUMB... most of the time you can spot a DUMB captain so rule number one for boating safety is stay away from them at all cost.

I feel better now. carry on
 
Thanks for the link Pascal.

Seems like they should stick to their mission statement; "Our mission: Managing fish and wildlife resources for their long-term well-being and the benefit of people."

They sure don't know the NAV rules! Reminds me of a boating magazine promoting violating the rules when being overtaken in a narrow channel. Better not reopen THAT can of worms.

My apologies to Ironworks but I still say if you know that the site in question is wrong then why would you put forth the information as fact on a boating education site?
 
The sailboat part is not the only part that is inaccurate. It's time for me to write them a little note.
 
Thank for the apology rommer.Les posted in this thread that the words "right of way" were not in any rule other than the rule about descending vessels.That was the gist of his post.I new that Florduh used it in their rules hence the post to further educate.When Les enlightens them they might correct there version. Lets hope so. Jim
 
Actually, Jim, it's not in Florida rules. This is from the actual statutes

(25) "Navigation rules" means the International Navigational Rules Act of 1977, 33 U.S.C. appendix following s. 1602, as amended, including the annexes thereto, for vessels on waters outside of established navigational lines of demarcation as specified in 33 C.F.R. part 80 or the Inland Navigational Rules Act of 1980, 33 U.S.C. ss. 2001 et seq., as amended, including the annexes thereto, for vessels on all waters not outside of such lines of demarcation.

That is from some bureaucrat who fancies himself a knowledgeable boater.
 
Thanks Les,now to my answer to the thread.I operate in the great lakes and always whistle my intentions as required by law.Some of you operate elsewhere and there are rules that apply to you that are slightly different.I will not go into that on this thread or post a link at this time. Jim
 
Back
Top