Dan, I do hope you're enjoying that frolicking around in warmer climes while the rest of us rot up here [:-mischievous]...
My son almost got into a fight with a kid at the park in Catskill, because the kid was picking on someone else and my son (then about 4 or 5), being raised in a boring middle class household, didnt know the etiquette of dealing with children from rough neighborhoods. The other kid was about twice his age and size. I watched from a distance so Jr could learn something then stepped in when it looked like it might get serious...
I agree with Dan in that Catskill makes me nervous compared to the other two creeks. But I'm still willing to go there because quite honestly the creek is beautiful, and I love that waterfront park at the end of the peninsula. They have a farmers market and a little food/ice cream stand into the Fall which makes it more user-friendly than Saugerties... The Rondout is the best, of course, with all the amenities and the longest creek for gunkholing, fishing and swimming, plus the anchoring in the area near Eddyville is the best around. Its all a matter of preference, and I frequent all 3 creeks (so long as I can afford the damn gas to go anywhere!)...
I'm dying to try that area near Houghtaling. I've always looked at that inviting and isolated stretch of water on the charts and thought it was neat. Plus, Junior can watch the trains go by, up close and personal...
Coeymans Landing is great too - an excellent place to stop, but no place to swim as far as I know. There is a nice little park where we BBQed last time we were there and Junior loved the swing sets, but thats a few years ago now...