This can't be good...

quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

heard the PanPan cancel tonight... glad they found them i hope we hear why the EPIRB didn't work!

if i was routinely going that far offshore, I'd have a sat phone, in addition to the EPIRB!





After the dust settles I may call the Captain and donate my TracPhone 252. For a lousy $21.00 a month they could have placed a $1.00 call or received a $1.00 (approximate charge) call. I wonder how much the USCG search and rescue cost for this one? A C130 can't be cheap to up in the air I heard the C-130 in the air at 1AM on channel 83A getting it's air guard and search pattern. For all we know the EPIRB battery might not have had the routine service. Pascal weren't we just debating KVH satphones in another thread?
I also heard the boat had HF Marine SSB I listened to the emergency frequency and heard not a peep. If they lost power this might be another case of old school thinking when it comes to critical communications battery isolation and alternative charging. I guess it comes down to would have, should have and perhaps could have had a different outcome. Heck even a SPOT that they could send a message from would have worked.
I am really glad this turned out ok. I'm just not sure the USCG needs that kind of practice.
I really would like to find out what they could have done to avoid the communications breakdown.
Bill
 
Yeah... about 50 miles out; seasonal will get you on the Tuna here in WA state; but like PascalG I would not consider that here with my boat in it's current condition and equipment list. I've gone out 100 miles off the gulf coast but it's a different body of water. To each their own.

Again....Good outcome! cheers ot all...
 
Philadelpia channel 6 news interviewed a buddy of the fellow that owned the boat. He said he was out on the boat two weeks ago and lost an engine in the inlet and part of the electrical system
 
Well I still haven't heard what caused their failure to communicate other than a single VHF MayDay picked up from USCG Marthas Vinyard?
Bill
 
quote:

Originally posted by Billylll

Well I still haven't heard what caused their failure to communicate other than a single VHF MayDay picked up from USCG Marthas Vinyard?
Bill






I heard the broadcast for that uncorrelated Mayday on Monday morning - in 11 years in Search and Rescue, that's the only uncorrelated I can think of that turned out to be correlated. Shows why uncorrelateds are always acted on.
 
That's pretty cool Mike. I know we hear false calls all the time responded by USCG Delaware Bay and they always turn out to be unfounded.
I can actually understand why the signal reached your station there was a strong high pressure stationary front off the coast. The 2 meter ham band 144NHz had a nice tropo enhancement from Mass through Virgina that same night. I'm surprised sector Long Island didn't pick up the call as well (although it could have been local traffic blocking the signal at other USCG recieving stations). Still this begs the question why on a charter boat they didn't have their DSC hooked up? The DSC would have broadcast to any boats near them in addition to the USCG station that recieved the Mayday and if properly integrated passed on their MMSI. This would have made the radio identification much easier.
Bill
 
Back
Top