3 blade or 4?

Brite Idea

Member
Member
Joined
Jan 28, 2004
RO Number
12714
Messages
615
I'm wondering if I'll get a better low end all around performance with 4 blades. I cruise at 3500rpm which is 29mph. When I pull a tube I have to run tabs down and 2200-2500rpms to go slow enough. This is where I burn lots of fuel and I wonder if a 4 blade will be better for me?
I never run above 3800rpms except for the once in a while WOT to give it some excercise. The boat also feels heavy before planning. The boat is a 270 Sundancer w/twin 4.3 counter rotating Alphas.
 
Why are you slowing down? When I was younger(and we used a real tube) the idea was to go fast and see if you could throw the rider off.
 
Most people get lower top end but better low and middle range. Not me though. What I like is the difference in how smoooother it is...no harmonic vibration. I think mine was $159 at BF. You usually drop pitch and/or diameter because of the added thrust and drag.
 
Thanks Charlie,
I'm on a fence because I've never had any experience with the 4 blades and don't know anyone around here who has one. My present props are stainless so it's a big expense if only for a little improvement. I'll probably go talk to the yard that worked on my boat last year.Thanks again!
Rob
 
rob, see if you can find a local prop shop that will loan you a 4 blade prop to try out. That is the only way you will know for sure.
 
My point was that the speed that you want to pull the tube is going to be that speed no matter what your rpm is and you are still going to have to run with your tabs down. If you change the pitch or cup you are either going to lug your engine or you are going to over rev. at higher speeds. All this is assuming that you are propped correctly right now.
 
CA,
The speed isn't the problem. The boat has get over the hump to plane and this puts it at 3200-3400rpms and about 28-30mph. We usually have a mix of older teens who I drag around. The guys like speed the girls don't. In order to run at a speed the girls are ok with, I'm running 2200-2500rpms with the tabs down and the bow up. This is when the boat runs the worst, it's lugging and gobbling fuel. The 4 blade question was because I read that this is where it performs the best. I always ask my questions here because I get lots of help and answers from people who have hands on experience. It's probably not a reasonable thing to ask a prop shop since I've got twin counter rotating props. Again, Thanks for your help.
Rob
 
In that case get a set of lower pitch aluminum props just for pulling. Whatcha got now?
 
Buy a smaller boat to use as a water sport toy.

27' is pushing the limit for pulling toys. Also there is no such thing as saving fuel when you drag something behind your boat.
 
Charlie,
I'm thinking about alum 4 blades. I'm presently running 17in pitch and from the prop sites I've looked 4 blade props come in even inch pitch so I'll buy 16 inch pitch. I'll be in the water in about two weeks and by Memorial Day I'll be ready to try them out. I'll let you know how they work out.
Rob
 
Brite Idea,

Not exactly the same application, but I used to have a Sea Ray 260 with a single 260HP Alpha I. I went from a 17P 3-blade to a 16P 4-blade (both aluminum) and noticed a much better hole shot without losing top end. I was also able to stay on plane at a lower RPM. Initially the shop at our marina let me test one before I purchased, so maybe you can find the same arrangement?
 
Rob, I'm not busting your chops. Climbing over your bow wave is a function of hull design, SPEED, weight and trim. If your girls like to be pulled at 15 mph and that is the SPEED that you are just about to climb out then it wont matter what rpm you are turning.
 
Mr. Gresham is correct. Until you exceed the particular displacement speed for your boat it doesn't really matter what size prop you are turning. New props may get you to that speed faster with a better "hole shot" but until you cross over your bow wake your engine is going to lug no matter what you do. Displacement speed, or hull speed, is different for every different hull shape. Form your description, for a boat that size, you are simply trying to operate in the most inefficient envelope for your particular boat.

quote:

Originally posted by CA Gresham

Rob, I'm not busting your chops. Climbing over your bow wave is a function of hull design, SPEED, weight and trim. If your girls like to be pulled at 15 mph and that is the SPEED that you are just about to climb out then it wont matter what rpm you are turning.




 
I think you are on the right track. You should get better low and mid range performance/acceleration, increased stern lift and smoother (less vibration) operation. You may lose 1 MPH on top end.
 
I changed 2 seasons ago from 3 blade to 4 blade to try to get better hole shot and it worked great. My power is twin VP 4.3 injected. Many times with a 8 person load I could not get to boat to plane easily with the 3 blade. The 4 blade puts it over the top even with a full load. I bought an inexpensive set of aluminum 4 blades first and I liked them so much I moved up to the stainless 4 blades. Boat stays on plane at slower speeds. Really works great on my boat. BTW, I dropped down 1.5" on the diameter.
 
Back
Top