A Little Grinding...

Radiowaves

Active member
Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2004
RO Number
14642
Messages
2,612
I have noticed a slight intermittent grinding sound coming from I believe under the boat or within my engine compartment while at idle speed. I already had the boat hauled for paint and zincs and totally forgot to tell my mechanic.

I just called the yard owner and asked him to change the Transmission fluid in both engines. I don’t believe I have changed it since getting the boat in 03 because the mechanics all said it looks good on a visual check. They said that it most likely is not the transmission grinding, but maybe a cutlass bearing, or maybe a pump or maybe… Too many maybe’s from my Mechanic's boss…..

But any ideas from the RO’s ? Does a worn Cutlass bearing sound possible?.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Bill 2


Do you have Hurth transmissions?








Not sure, they are V-Drives attached to Merc 350 MPI's I was told that when a V drive goes south it just goes... But who know's I am hoping for something simple and not too expensive to fix.
 
If the engine idle is set to low, the gear sets in v-drives will rattle. Very normal. Try increasing your in gear idle to at least 700 RPM.
 
It could also be the damper plate. It is bolted to the flywheel and will rattle when worn or if idle is too low.
 
Is it a rattle (like marbles banging together) or grinding?
 
To locate the source of a noise you need a broom stick. Move the broom stick to various parts of the motor (transmission, V- drive, water pump, etc), put the other end of the broom stick to your ear. The broom stick acts like a stethoscope.

Walter
 
Cant you also use a gun?

One end to your temple the other in your hand.
 
quote:

Originally posted by walterv

Is it a rattle (like marbles banging together) or grinding?






Hard to tell not being a sound expert. Could be more like marbles. Starts and stops. I think port side. A broom to my ear ?!? The men in the white coats will come... Bad enough I catch myself talking to myself.
 
If it is a marble sound, then the above posts are correct, PS, nothing to fix. As posted, bump the rpm up a bit, if the noise goes away, the above is confirmed.

The broom stick think is old school and works like a charm.
 
"Hard to tell not being a sound expert."

And you worked in the "radio business" :)
 
quote:

Originally posted by walterv

"Hard to tell not being a sound expert."

And you worked in the "radio business" :)






Ok you got me... Touche'
 
"Marbles" does sound like it may be the very common too-low idle rpm in gear issue. I was going to mention the possiblitity of worn Spurs bearings if you happen to have those, but that loud metallic chafing noise does not go away at aboove idle rpm. FWIW, the too-low idle marbles-rattle sound happens just as easily on straight drives as well. Velvet Drive notes that it can damage transmissions if not corrected.

If the last shaft anodes had slipped down to the strut, particles of zinc could get imbedded in your cutlass and cause a grinding sound, and a very worn cutlass could allow the shaft to rub on the cutlass metal sleeve, but I wouldn't expect either of those to disappear a little above idle either.

What is your idle rpm in fwd.?
 
quote:

Originally posted by Sandy

"Marbles" does sound like it may be the very common too-low idle rpm in gear issue. I was going to mention the possiblitity of worn Spurs bearings if you happen to have those, but that loud metallic chafing noise does not go away at aboove idle rpm. FWIW, the too-low idle marbles-rattle sound happens just as easily on straight drives as well. Velvet Drive notes that it can damage transmissions if not corrected.

If the last shaft anodes had slipped down to the strut, particles of zinc could get imbedded in your cutlass and cause a grinding sound, and a very worn cutlass could allow the shaft to rub on the cutlass metal sleeve, but I wouldn't expect either of those to disappear a little above idle either.

What is your idle rpm in fwd.?






I need to look at this rpm thing.. You guys may be on to someting. But when moving up to plane speed, I don't hear anything but normal engine noise.
 
He is over 50, it could be the marbles in his head starting to rattle.
My body creaks and rattles more than it did when I was younger.
 
Back
Top