A question for our experts ...

AbsoLoot

exMember
Member
exMember
Joined
Mar 2, 2001
RO Number
3617
Messages
746
I'd like to receive responses from those knowledgeable of the actual laws rather than "it seems like .........."[/]

I was talking to a gentleman this weekend and wanted to find out what others think. This gentleman is not a USCG licensed captain but offers boat handling instruction on the customer's boat for which they must show proof of insurance. This seemed reasonable to me because the customer was still ultimately in charge of their vessel.

He has now begun offering Sea Trial service and boat deliveries. I was always under the impression that if one was making money from a boating transaction, one had to be licensed. He carries an insurance policy that covers whatever boat he is piloting at the time and says that the insurance company if fully aware of what his operation entails. He also has talked with the Coast Guard and claims that they agree there is no license that really covers what he is doing, so he doesn't need one.

Does this sound reasonable?
 
So he's getting paid to pilot a vessel and doesn't even have a 6 Pac?
 
If an individual wants to do deliveries then he can without a capt's license. There is no license for that. Even if there is compensation. If he wants to do a charter where he is bringing people out then he needs at least a 6 pack lic. As for instruction, I am not really sure. I have been thinking about working for a dealer in the same capacity part time and all of them require a license. I have my 50ton Masters for the same reasons.
 
Run away...run very fast! He is required to have at a minimum a business license and must be registered as a business with the IRS and have an EIN (employer identification number) He may be indicating he is covered by insurance just as you would be when you rent a car.
 
Just to be clear, I am not doing business with this gentleman, nor do I care about business licences, taxes, etc. I was simply curious about USCG licensing rules and requirements.
 
I just called the Mariners school where I received my license from: Here it is, you can legally deliver a boat with no license as long as the owner is not aboard. Anytime they are aboard then money has been transacted and they will need a license. The other issue with that is the CG does not require the license if the capt is alone however they will probably never get the insurance to do the delivery because all ins. Co's require at least the 6pack license.

As far as instruction: NO WAY, it can not be done legally There is money being transferred and they MUST have the lic.

I would not have anything to do with this so called Capt.
 
you dont' need a license for deliveries as long as no passengers (inlc. owner) are on board... Instruction either if the owner is in charge although that may be a little more iffy. Sea Trial without a license? I dont' think so... since passengers are on board.

From an insurance perspective, I don't think anyone would be able to do deliveries without at least a 6 pack (excpet maybe small boats)

as to an EIN... not needed

http://www.irs.gov/businesses/small/article/0,,id=97872,00.html
 
No insurance company I've ever dealt with would cover an unlicensed delivery captain.
 
I am not so sure about the owner having anything to do with needing a license. The point turns on whether there are "paying passengers" aboard. Until I stand corrected, that means paying for the ride, not paying the captain.

Where it gets really complicated is the definition of a paying passenger. Some have interpreted it to mean if your buddy brings the beer and you have one, he is a paying passenger. Others, of course, are more sane in their definition.

Someone needs to dig out the CFR on this one and show where the owner fits in. Could be...
 
Delivery Captains for hire should have there own liability insurance. You cant get it unless you have a uscg license. ALso, once you start to give instruction on how to handle a vessel, the insurance is null and void unless the teaching captain is at the helm. I know this because I just got my insurance and read the policy end to end. I would not hire him if he does not have a uscg license and insurance.
 
<<...."Sea Trial without a license? I dont' think so... since passengers are on board."...>>

I'm curous about this. Surveyors generally do sea trials with the potential buyers and often the owner is aboard. Do surveyors generally have Captain's licenses?
 
My surveyor did, but I never thought about the need for a license to do a sea trial. I don't know the answer, but I suspect that most surveyors aren't licensed captains. I might be wrong in this assumption though!
 
surveyors never drive the boat themselves, brokers *usually* dont' either although many brokers are captains and they make arrangements with the seller. typically the seller (or his captain) will drive the boat on ST... surveyors are too busy to drive anyway!!! and dont' forget that they are hired by the buyer, they can't work for the seller at the same time...
 
He is not "carrying passengers for hire" and does not need a license. If the owner is on board, he is not a passenger for hire.

The delivering captain should have liability insurance. The owner carries insurance on the vessel.

If you are normally engaged in transporting vessels, your insurance company may have additional requirements but its up to the insurance company and it is on a case by case basis.

A similar situation exists with aircraft where a private licenced pilot cannot carry passengers for hire but, with a simple instructors license, he can "give lessons". That is, he can carry a passenger under that guise of teaching.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Flutterby

Dave, you have mail........






Liz I never received any mail. Try dwitte at rhtinney dot com
 
rbmitcell,
I called the capt. school and they said if the owner is on board and he is paying a capt. to deliver his boat then funds have been transferred and the capt MUST have at least the 6pac license. No questions! the same holds true for any type of training. We are not flying planes so rules and regs may vary some.
Capt. Van
 
Private Yacht=Unispected Vessel. Unispected Vessel=No USCG Manning Requirements. No USCG Manning Requirements=No License required. P.S. Did you know that operators/captains of USCG Vessels are not required to hold a USCG License?.
 
L, by that reasoning, an uninspected passenger vessel such as a fishing charter boat would not require a licensed Operator. Same with uninspected towing vessels.

But, yes, you are correct on the second point. I had been a Motor Lifeboat Coxswain a few years before I sat for my license. Was surprised at how well prepared I was for it by what I had learned at work - breezed right through. Out of 5 tests, I got one question wrong. Of course it was NavRules... Reinforces the argument that lower-level tickets don't directly correlate to any level (high or low, good or bad) of skill or experience.
 
Back
Top