Amsoil synthetic??

dumy

Member
Member
Joined
May 4, 2004
RO Number
13515
Messages
158
Anyone have experience and or recommendations, with Amsoil synthetic oil in their newer 4 stroke outboards? Thinking of useing it in my 2007 115 hp Yamahas.
Thanks,
Ron
 
the eternal debate will now resume. But since you ask; IMO no boat engine has ever failed from the use of the cheapest dino oil. They all die from neglect, corrosion, or water intrusion which are all really neglect.
 
The engine doesn't care. Go ahead and use it if it makes you feel warm and fuzzy.
 
quote:

Originally posted by pdecat

the eternal debate will now resume. But since you ask; IMO no boat engine has ever failed from the use of the cheapest dino oil. They all die from neglect, corrosion, or water intrusion which are all really neglect.






I had a 454 that developed a nice knock due to a spun bearing around 175 hours. No determination was made as to why this occurred, but the motor was full of fresh dino at the time. I am not saying that syn would have prevented this, but boat motors do get a good work out, especially the bottom end.
 
Synthetics are by far better for your motor then regular petroleum lubricants.I use Amsoil in both of my boats, injector oil and lower unit, all 4 of my vehicles (gas and diesel) front to back. Better gas mileage in the vehicles, longer drain intervals = cheaper in the long run, smoother running = less wear and tear on your motor, less smoke (2 stroke motors), easier startup in the cold in boat motors and vehicles, feel free to contact me if you have any other questions.
 
Amzoil....Snakeoil.....same same....

Amzoil has not gone through a certification process. Maybe...big maybe...if they did, the populous would find it is no different than Mobil 1 or any other synthetic.

FWIW, a fellow club member used the Amzoil system for years. He just replaced his Hino's with new Cats to the tune of 60K.

The fact of the matter is oil changes at the specified intervals is far cheaper and greater insurance than any marketing scheme.
 
Synthetics are better than dino oil. That has been known for some time.
They do not break down like dino oils, but dirt will still hurt your engine.
You still have to change the oil or filter it a lot cleaner than a regular
oil filter can.
Car makers are now saying that you can run longer than 3K miles on an oil
change. I know that some GM cars and trucks tell you when to change the
oil based on how you drive. My brother in laws truck and Tahoe can go to
around 7K miles before the oil change light comes on.
Oil change commercials will tell you to change it every 3K miles cause they
won't make as much money if you don't.
Get a good oil that fights corrosion, oxidation and moisture. Synthetics also
have higher resistance to thermal breakdown.
There are lots of reasons to use it if you put a lot of hours on a boat.
If you only boat 100 hours or so a year, it might not be advantageous to use.
 
Not boating related....but an interesting story for what it is worth. I know a guy through work that runs amsoil in his cars and swears by it. He buys the cars new and immediately changes the oil-replacing it with amsoil synthetic. He does nothing until 20,000 miles when he replaces the filter and tops off the oil. At 35,000 he replaces oil and filter. He repeats this process at 55,000/70,000 miles and 90,000/105,000 miles. He normally trades them in just after the third oil change. He regularly checks the oil but typically does nothing until these service intervals. I think he's had 3 vehicles "survive" using this practice. Even though he seems to have success with this method, no, I have not and will not try it. Nor will I ever purchase one of his trade ins!
 
Kindresspirits:

Not such a big deal. Vette, BMW, and many others come factory direct with synthetic. After 50K miles and 3 oil changes, you can still see the hash marks in the cylinder walls.

Things have changed.
 
quote:

Originally posted by KiDa

Amzoil....Snakeoil.....same same....

Amzoil has not gone through a certification process. Maybe...big maybe...if they did, the populous would find it is no different than Mobil 1 or any other synthetic.

FWIW, a fellow club member used the Amzoil system for years. He just replaced his Hino's with new Cats to the tune of 60K.

The fact of the matter is oil changes at the specified intervals is far cheaper and greater insurance than any marketing scheme.






What certification process are you referring to?

Amsoil is First to develop an API rated 100% synthetic motor oil, First to produce synthetic motor oils for diesel engines, racing engines, turbo engines, and marine engines.

I have printed literature that shows Amsoil outperforms Mobil 1 in a number of test including the High Temperature/High Shear Test, Four Ball Wear Test, NOACK Volatility Test, Thin Film Oxygen Uptake Test, High temperature evaporation/Volatility test.
I am pretty sure you would have a hard time proving "the populous would find it is no different than Mobil 1 or any other synthetic."

And also,
No, as a matter of fact "oil changes at the specified intervals" is not cheaper or "greater insurance" than any marketing scheme". If Amsoil was just a "marketing scheme" it would not still be around 37 years later. Just as an example, with Amsoil, it would cost you (retail) for 10W-30 6qts. X 8.90 = 53.40 plus filter ~ $17.00 Total $70.40 to drive for 25,000 miles or one year which ever comes first. 25,000 miles is 8 regular oil changes (3000 mile changes)that cost $20 at the local quik lube. Obviously 8 X $20 is $160. You can do it yourself for $10 a change with really cheap stuff for $80 a year?

If your fellow club member was concerned that the oil caused his Hino's to fail costing him 60k then he should have the oil in his Hino's analyzed($20) to determine if that was the root cause of the failure. Amsoil states "AMSOIL offers a warranty that covers the cost of repair or replacement of a proven mechanically sound engine damaged as a result of using AMSOIL synthetic motor oil. However, it has never happened. Thirty years of experience proves AMSOIL can be installed in any vehicle with complete confidence"

Edit- Amsoils filters definately aid in the extended drain intervals
 
The best way to determine whether your lubricant is performing the way it should is to take a sample and send it in to an oil analysis company and they will tell you what amount of what metals they find. The metals they find in your oil are the metals that once belonged to the inside of your motor.
Do this for two different oil Brands over two seasons or two oil change intervals and you will see which one protected your motor best!
 
Synthetic oil is superior. In the long haul it is also cheaper. 1/2 to 1/3 the oil changes. It's still a good idea to change the filters at regualr intervals. I'm old school so I thinks its best to break in with dino oil. So after the first hour of use/break in, you should be set to change over to synthetic. Breaking in the engine on a car takes less than an hour.
 
KiDa - Are you speaking out against all synthetic oil, or just Amsoil?
 
quote:

Originally posted by dumy






Not exactly an answer to your question, but I enjoy oil conversations. Maybe I need to get a life.

My oil selection always comes from the top of the list on the manufacturer chart.

I have 2 Merc 7.4s, and the new chart now shows Quicksilver Synthetic FWA so that's what I use. I change the oil once per year with OEM filters, and I'm done. The difference in money is insignificant when spread out over a year.

I have found in my years of boating that trying different oils just creates confusion and wonder.

Now if your manufacturer has not made a recommendation update with the new oils, then I would contact them for an updated oil chart.

Nobody can really answer oil question as to how it has worked out, because they never know.

Just my opinion.

I'm sure Mercruiser's choice of Quicksilver as #1 on the chart is a combination of being a good oil AND wanting to sell me their oil, but never the less, that's what I use and I never wonder if I made the correct choice.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Nibbs

KiDa - Are you speaking out against all synthetic oil, or just Amsoil?






Just Amsoil. No API Certification. Amsoil claims that by subscribing to the API cert program they will be required to add phosphorous additives to their oil that will detract from the superiority of their product.

If that is the case, give me hard data from an independent source. I have yet to see it.

Perhaps the Amsoil theory/claim is correct. Perhaps it is not. The economy is in the tank. There is the need for freedom from foreign oil. The current administration is green minded and not associated with big oil. would think that if Amsoil is oll it says it is, they could get an audience with the President to make their case.

Time will tell.
 
Not boating related:
I put Amsoil in my truck in 2004 with the bypass system. It cleans the oil to
1 micron. I sample the oil yearly at an independent lab and all test come back
great. I change the full flow oil filter every 6 months and the bypass filter
every year.
I started when the truck had 125K miles on it and it now has ~200K miles on it.
The sample report trends different metals, additives, TBN and also looks for
fuel, dirt, silicon and glycol(from anti-freeze). All the trends run almost steady.
My cost is the 3 filters, 1 sample and a couple quarts of oil to replace what I
lost when I changed the filters, per year.
This is the reason I use Amsoil in 2 diesel trucks, my wifes Murano(change every
7500 miles) and my boat.

Boating related:
I change the boat oil once a year, the engines are original, 28 years old, and
don't burn or use any oil.
We sampled the oil just before each oil change to see how it held up and the
samples showed the oil was still good, but I don't have a bypass system on these, so
I don't want to chance messing up the motor.
If I can run her without having to change the oil every 100 hours, then I will
continue to run synthetics.
 
the synthetic oil debate in recreational boating is about as usefull as debating the use of Z rated tires on your car. unless you run your boat 24/7 like a commercial operator for years on end there is no way a slightly better quality oil could ever benifit anyone. since not many of us will ever approach 175 mph under any circumstance or run our boat much more than we can find the time to now, its really just about feeling warm and fuzzy about what we buy for our toys.
 
Amsoil actually introduced the world's first API rated synthetic motor oil.

Rduhon, the bypass filter system is tremendous, I have a dump truck with well over 60k miles on the same oil, oil analysis shows everything is still good
 
quote:

Originally posted by reelts

Amsoil actually introduced the world's first API rated synthetic motor oil.

Rduhon, the bypass filter system is tremendous, I have a dump truck with well over 60k miles on the same oil, oil analysis shows everything is still good






You sure about that API thing?
 
Back
Top