another boating tragedy

Bill-

if only it were that easy. The problem is complex and exacerbated by the current state of our fisheries (once the most plentiful in the world). The regulatory process has failed these guys AND the fisheries to point that we are now in a no win situation. It would be great if we could fix this through regulation but most fear it's too late for that. I wish I had the answers, I really do - but I'm just not that smart.

All I can say is that I understand and won't make judgements since I'm not in their shoes. I trust these were decent working men, just trying to earn a living like the rest of us. I don't think any of them thought they were on their final voyage and my heart goes out to thier families- It's a tough life.
 
Bill, apparently you have an "inquiring mind", not knocking that.
However, I take posts/threads such as this for what they are:obituaries-of lives lost at sea.
I don't think it's fair to those floating around in the cold and unforgiving Atlantic, or to their familes, to immediately start posting "alcohol was involved"- a radio station told me so, implying "poor seamanship" was a factor, that they "should have" practiced their de-icing procedures. Thus my "armchair quarterback" retort.
I realize this is the internet, and some may "own" this forum more than others, but there's this thing called respect that should be adhered to no matter the case. If a co-worker or a family member died would it be proper for someone to start the accusations so soon? I think not. Let the guys get a decent burial (if they're lucky) before the speculation begins.
Plenty of room out there for a new thread if anyone wants to discuss the fishing industry. The boat that was fishing nearby was from Virginia by the way. And let's not forget the King Crab fishery that runs through this type of weather in the Bering Sea.
Done with my vent, but I'm having flashbacks of that thread where the girl got swept of the tall ship a few months back, and I read on here "Serves her right for not wearing a safety harness"
What comes around goes around, so let's stick with the "prayers go out to the families" comments.
 
GW

I understand your feeling, and I leave this thread for your other comments.
 
Grady, Jav, Capt Q - you are so right on. You have a grasp of the sea. These guys go out in the worst of conditions to feed their families, to pay their mortguages, to pay their fuel bills and yes, to fill the tables at Legal Seafoods, The Four Seasons, La Maison and any number of other restaurants throughout the world. They're being regulated to death as to when, where and for how many days they can fish. They are among the best boaters in the world in the worst of conditions. In the last year, we've lost 4 accomplished fishermen in this area alone. And they're just trying to make a living for their families. They know what they're doing. They're professionals. They've studied their art - and some survive, God bless 'em. I'm not great at this boating thing but I guess that's why I get PO'ed when I see someone type, "I wanna take the family off shore but what's that green thing with the numbers on it?" Ya gotta know and respect your environment, hope for the best - and praying probably doesn't hurt.
 
"If that is the case, then the rules need to be modified."

Oh boy. Just ask ANY fisherman, commercial or not about that one. Those with the gold make the rules, even if they are foreign fisherman. Sad but true.

When my grandad was not running rum in the 1920s, he was a fisherman based in Lunenburg, N.S. The town square has a tall monument with hundreds of names of those lost at sea. Most northeast towns have similar monuments.

...pray for those that go down to the sea in ships, and see the works of God upon the oceans...
 
And sometimes the rules do get changed. The crab fishing in the Bering Sea used to be a derby style - set a limit, fish like heck and when the limit is reached it's done. That encouraged every boat to go out and catch as many as quickly as they could.

The rules were changed to assign a limit for each boat in an attempt to create a situation where boats weren't encouraged to take as much risk. Of course, it also forced a few of the smaller operations to get out of the business and sell their quotas so there were fewer jobs available for deckhands. And you can't eliminate the risk altogether because you have to fish when the crab are there which is in some ungodly conditions at best.
 
"Argh! Another armchair monday morning quarterback heard from........."

Count me in, guilty as charged. Last time I checked this was BoaterEd, short for Boater Education, not the Obituary column...

I noticed in the linked article that there was film of the US Coast Guard towing these people in last month because they had trouble with the boat. Am I the only one here (other than Bill) who wonders if these folks were venturing out unprepared???

Just because they're commercial fishermen doesn't give them a free pass to do stupid things. What if a USCG helo had gone down looking for them, either this time or last month??? Are we supposed to just whine that the fishing regulations are too tough???

IMHO its perfectly acceptable to question what the hell happened in this case, ESPECIALLY on the Boater Education Forum...
 
Any way you look at it is still tragic loss. The boat that went down to day both guys were just kids, One just had a child 6 months ago and the capt 24 years old was getting married this summer.
 
I've been out there in winter towing those vessels. NAS-TEE! It's bad enough when everything's working well... I wonder about that previous CG assist incident also. Unless they raise the boat, which I doubt, it won't get "autopsied" and of course if it WAS ice, that evidence is gone too.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PBardunias

"Argh! Another armchair monday morning quarterback heard from........."

Count me in, guilty as charged. Last time I checked this was BoaterEd, short for Boater Education, not the Obituary column...

I noticed in the linked article that there was film of the US Coast Guard towing these people in last month because they had trouble with the boat. Am I the only one here (other than Bill) who wonders if these folks were venturing out unprepared???

Just because they're commercial fishermen doesn't give them a free pass to do stupid things. What if a USCG helo had gone down looking for them, either this time or last month??? Are we supposed to just whine that the fishing regulations are too tough???

IMHO its perfectly acceptable to question what the hell happened in this case, ESPECIALLY on the Boater Education Forum...






Ya, OK PTBarnum, while we're defining things: BOATER-"One that drives or rides in a boat, especially a pleasure craft."
I was not aware commercial fishermen were referred to as "boaters". Nor was I aware commercial FV's were considered "boats" or "pleasure craft". They follow much tougher safety standards than recreational boaters like yourself. 4 guys with over 100 years combined experience in the industry die at sea, ok so the generator failed a month ago, and you chime in with "Just because they're commercial fishermen doesn't give them a free pass to do stupid things". I post another link about 2 more lives lost at sea last night and this is your response? That's two class act's heard from....

PS Big difference between questioning what happened and irresponsibly chiming in with things like "I heard alcohol was involved", implying "poor seamanship" and what you're now implying. One can question something and show some respect at the same time. Just not here I guess...

PSS "Educational" comments rarely come in "tabloid" form.
 
Armchair quarterbacking notwithstanding, and since this is BoaterEd, stories like this point out that the forces of nature tugging on your boat should not be taken lightly. All too many times in the last two years I've awakened to the sound of grey and orange rescue helicopters buzzing over the house and yesterday - today too, was no exception. My neighbors make their living from the sea - some families have been in the business since the 1700's so there's a heritage - a lifetime of "on-the-job" training if you will, and not knowing the full story of a captain and crew, it's difficult to arrive at an accurate conclusion. Sure a 25-year-old captain may sound young but perhaps he's been working the sea on his dad's boat since he's been 10. That gives him 15 years of extreme boating under his belt and I'd rather be with him in snotty weather than with a 50-year-old who's been plying the waters of inland ponds in his 18 foot bow rider for 15 years. You just don't know...
http://www.wcsh6.com/news/article.a...=ald3Dj4QB3JmcIeSXyhoz22EmB79ECJh1ndqThdiENE=
 
quote:

Originally posted by PBardunias

"Argh! Another armchair monday morning quarterback heard from........."

Count me in, guilty as charged. Last time I checked this was BoaterEd, short for Boater Education, not the Obituary column...

I noticed in the linked article that there was film of the US Coast Guard towing these people in last month because they had trouble with the boat. Am I the only one here (other than Bill) who wonders if these folks were venturing out unprepared???

Just because they're commercial fishermen doesn't give them a free pass to do stupid things. What if a USCG helo had gone down looking for them, either this time or last month??? Are we supposed to just whine that the fishing regulations are too tough???

IMHO its perfectly acceptable to question what the hell happened in this case, ESPECIALLY on the Boater Education Forum...






Yes, they had been towed in about a month earlier due to an engine failure. To correlate that earlier incident to the current one is simply not relevent. Do you have any evidence that they were at sea "unprepared"?

Do you have any evidence that they were doing "stupid things" on this trip?

What if a USCG Helo had gone down looking for them? Would you be making accusations that the Helo crew was "unprepared", or "doing stupid things" on the SAR mission?

Yes, there are things to be learned from this tragedy - for example - how did the EPIRB end up in a scupper? Why did the liferaft not hydro statically release?

Those are questions that can be learned from, not some lame attempt to correlate a prior break down to the current incident and make wild accusations of doing stupid things.
 
""Just because they're commercial fishermen doesn't give them a free pass to do stupid things"."

Sorry, but I stand firmly by the above statement. I didn't say that on this particular day they were guilty of doing stupid things. I said they were responsible for not doing stupid things...

"I was not aware commercial fishermen were referred to as "boaters". "

No, but since you and I are posting here on BoaterEd, I assume that WE are boaters...

"They follow much tougher safety standards than recreational boaters like yourself. 4 guys with over 100 years combined experience in the industry die at sea, ok so the generator failed a month ago..."

Ummm, lets see, 4 guys with over 100 years combined experience have TWO major malfunctions within a month, one of which apparently costs them their lives. Yeah, I think its okay to raise an eyebrow over that. Yes I do...

"What if a USCG Helo had gone down looking for them? Would you be making accusations that the Helo crew was "unprepared", or "doing stupid things" on the SAR mission?"

No, I would have commented that a helo was lost chasing after a boat that was also lost under very suspect circumstances...

"Yes, there are things to be learned from this tragedy - for example - how did the EPIRB end up in a scupper? Why did the liferaft not hydro statically release?"

Yep, those sure are the most important questions. How about "Why did the damn boat sink???" Or am I the only one interested in such trivia...

Sorry to be so confrontational, guys, but some of you seem to have quite a holier-than-thou attitude here. You make it sound like these professionals are above reproach, while we lowly pleasureboaters are stupid and have no clue. Well in over 30 years of boating I've never had a significant injury to my boats or my passengers, and I thank God for that more than I do my boating skills, to be sure. But most of us here on BoaterEd are no slouches, either. We're pretty good at what we do on board our vessels. And I think we have a right to wonder what happened on board a boat that suffered two failures in a short period of time, the last of which cost the boat and the lives of its entire crew...
 
quote:

Ummm, lets see, 4 guys with over 100 years combined experience have TWO major malfunctions within a month, one of which apparently costs them their lives. Yeah, I think its okay to raise an eyebrow over that. Yes I do..





Did anyone consider that the "hands" may have been ordered out to sea by someone? Maybe they were too proud to take welfare?
A hundred years of working nets doesn't mean they know didly about engines, trannies and navigation. The captain knows some of these subjects but probably not well enough to handle all of the subjects expertly.
My brother was on a fish boat out of Seattle and they had a single. The tranny developed a leak. They pumped in gear oil not knowing anything and blew a seal. They did this because the captain told them to do it. They were fortunate to make it back. The gears were very, very hot when the finally arrived.
Some people drive genuine 'sh*t boxes' to work every day on the thruway no? Those folks risk not only their own lives but the lives of those around them in traffic. Who's worse? Ever seen a pile up in fog happen? Why? People have to work or other pressures drive them into it.
Under the circumstances of economic pressure people roll the dice because it's all they know. It's their only source of income. They've got to try with what they have available to them.

Some people are stuck with their "lot". It's called "making due with what you have" and I can pretty much guarantee some of the souls that went down wouldn't have JACK in this world if they didn't try fishing every chance they have.
Everyone is being pinched in this world and I think it's safe to say those poor souls were pinched to death.

We can wonder what caused their demise, but to accuse them of being careless or have little regard is harsh in my humble opinion because dang, they just might not have an alternative. They were just like the guy in the "beater" next to you on the Taconic. Just be careful when you pass him on the outside going around a corner. He might not make it.
 
Grady, since when has this become an "obiturary" forum??

Hopefully, we can all learn something from this tragedy, both boaters, and commercial fishermen, who according to you - are not "boaters"

If someone reported that they heard of alcohol involvement, it is perfectly appropriate to mention it.

You need to lighten up...
 
I can't speak for the Northeast fisheries but in a previous life as a commercial fisherman and merchant mariner I learned two things:

1: Commercial vessels are expected to turn a PROFIT. Expenses must be controlled. Therefore equipment that the yachties think nothing of may be too costly, and repairs may be put off, sometimes too long.

2: You are a PROFESSIONAL; you earn your living at this business and you have to eat, pay the mortgage and feed your wife and kids. You don't make money sitting in port. You went out last week; the weather was terrible but you got the job done, survived, and made money. So you go again out this week; hopefully you'll come home again.

Sometimes (1) and (2) combine and the results can be fatal (oops). We all take risks. How many are killed each year because they were driving a little too fast, or had one beer too many, or were simply in the wrong place in the wrong time??

'it happens.
 
Hogan, I only threw the word “obituary” up there to possibly make people think twice before posting false accusations, unsubstantiated, baseless, non-factual, rumor like gossip regarding the tragic loss of lives in an already tough business. And yes, I am sensitive to the subject. An “educational” comment, from another forum, suggested if their days at sea weren’t so restricted, perhaps they would have stayed east in the warmer air and waited for the sub-zero temps to break. A “speculative” comment, from another forum, suggested perhaps the second fishing vessel that went down last week got run down as it was close to being in the shipping lane. There’s a way to add to a thread, and not degrade the dignity of those lost, that’s all I was suggesting.

I was also under the impression this site was made up of “recreational boaters”. I don’t think it fair to compare the situations these guys face daily to that of one like “why didn’t they just stay at the yacht club that day”, as a “boater” like yourself may .

Now, a question for those throwing the negative comments in here, how come I didn’t see you jump in the Florida tornadoe thread and make the same type of “unprepared”, “didn’t follow safety procedures”, “stupid mistakes” comments that got posted here? Could some of those lives have been saved? Yes. Would those types of comments be proper? No, it would be tacky,disrespectful and classless- correct? My point.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Grady Wahoo

I was also under the impression this site was made up of “recreational boaters”. I don’t think it fair to compare the situations these guys face daily to that of one like “why didn’t they just stay at the yacht club that day”, as a “boater” like yourself may .






You really need to get over yourself. You sound like an ass with comments like that. How dare you infer one style of boating is more important then another. This is a Boater Education site. Discussing the possible events that caused an incident is what we do.
 
Back
Top