Another Sad Ending

bajanbum

Member
exMember
Joined
Sep 13, 2005
RO Number
19016
Messages
290
Two Bodies Found After Boaters Reported Missing
Search began around 5 a.m.
Boat found around 7 a.m.


Police Have Found Two Bodies In The Area, But No Identifications Made

missingboat.jpg


MIAMI (CBS4) #8213; Monday evening Miami-Dade Police announced that they found the bodies of an adult man and a young girl in Biscayne Bay, but they have not confirmed if they are the bodies of the father and daughter who vanished after a day of boating.

Phil Burke, 49, and his 8-year old daughter, Kara Ann, took off in a 17-foot Key West pleasure craft from Black Point Marina in Cutler Bay around 4:20 p.m. Sunday afternoon, said George Pino, with the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission. Their plan was to return around dusk. At midnight, when they still hadn't returned, and a family member called the U.S. Coast Guard to report them missing.

At 5 a.m., Coast Guard search teams, along with personnel from the Miami-Dade police department, Miami-Dade Fire Rescue, National Park Service and the FWC searched a large grid by sea and by air.

Monday afternoon officials recovered the two floating bodies -- one of them in the area of Chicken Key. But they have not confirmed their identities.

Earlier, at about 7:30 a.m., Burke's boat was found in mangroves a few miles north of the marina, but there was no sign of him or his daughter.

Still, Leonard Pelzman with the Fish and Wildlife Commission hasn't lost hope.

"Unfortunately as you said time is not on our side. We have three helicopters up, we have several boats in the water and we're trying to locate these individuals and our hope is that we find them well and nothing happened," Pelzman said.

Boaters at the Black Point Marina said they are concerned about the missing father and daughter. "It's terrible to hear anyone goes out there and had this type of problem, it breaks my heart," said Leonard Pelzman.

Jesus Canteli and his son Randy echoed a similar feeling, "It's undescribable (sic), incredible to think someone is out there lost right now.

Anyone with information concerning the Burke's whereabouts is asked to call the Sector Miami Command Center at 305-535-4472.

(В© MMIX, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved.)
 
tragic

as i mentioned in the thread in the So Fl section, the weather was nice on sunday afternoon. We were out sailing a J24 and it was calm on the bay, 10 to 12kts. sunny, nice...

there was a tube tied to the stern of the boat. Doesn't mean they were tubing since tubes can also be used to float behind the boat at anchor. If they were tubing though, aren't you supposed to have a second person on the boat, a spotter, when towing?
 
I don't understand how they both ended up drowning? Even if they ran out of gas it doesn't sound like a storm knocked them over?? How sad though.
 
father falling overboard while towing? no kill switch... boat ran for a while then ran out of fuel and drifted to shore? who knows... that's the only explanation i can think of.
 
Hey Pascal, sorry I didn't realize you had posted in the SF forum. Actually, I only heard about this on my way to work this morning. I am pretty close to Black Point, and I recall hearing helicopters circling for quite a while yesterday.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

father falling overboard while towing? no kill switch... boat ran for a while then ran out of fuel and drifted to shore? who knows... that's the only explanation i can think of.






I was thinking the daughter may have fallen, perhaps while tubing, and he may have jumped in out of reaction...? Sad indeed.
 
Very Tragic.

We shouldn't speculate, but hopefully autopsies will tell.
He could of fallen in and she tried to save him.
I am curious why these bodies were found but not the other 3 guys in the gulf.
Don't bodies float when dead?
 
"Don't bodies float when dead?"

For a while. If they remain intact.
 
Bodies tend to refloat after they start to decompose as well. But the guys who died in the Gulf were all athletes as I recall. So they would tend to have a very high muscle to fat ratio, which would make them much more likely to sink right off the bat. Then once in the food chain in deep water, well.........I'm sure you get the idea.
 
quote:

Originally posted by CurrentSea

I am curious why these bodies were found but not the other 3 guys in the gulf.
Don't bodies float when dead?





The other 3 guy were like 100 miles offshore in the Gulf of Mexico, these 2 were in Biscayne Bay. Biscayne Bay is much smaller. It's only 9 or 10 miles across at the widest.
 
quote:

If they were tubing though, aren't you supposed to have a second person on the boat, a spotter, when towing?






That's a best practice, but many states, NC is one, only require a mirror when pulling a skier. Tragic that a father and daughter go out for an afternoon of fun and end up dead.
 
It's all conjecture, maybe the Dad had a heart attack, fell overboard and the daughter tried to save him.

Water temps in Biscayne shouldn't be too bad right now.

Back in the day we'd tow someone on the tube, they had a PFD on.

Could this have been preventable? Another PFD issue?

Truly sad.

RWS
 
Blacks have much lower ratio of Fat to Muscle too. They just dont float as easy as we fat White folks.
 
I think something is going to fail, maybe me, maybe the boat, I just would not get me in that position. Keep on top of the situation.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Thudpucker

Blacks have much lower ratio of Fat to Muscle too. They just dont float as easy as we fat White folks.






Is that really true, not the black thing, but that fatt people float better than those in shape?
 
Very sad ending. The admiral and I are in SoFL now, and plan to boat on Biscayne Bay area this Friday, Saturday, and Sunday. It will be hard to not think of this story.
 
quote:

Originally posted by walterv

quote:

Originally posted by Thudpucker

Blacks have much lower ratio of Fat to Muscle too. They just dont float as easy as we fat White folks.






Is that really true, not the black thing, but that fatt people float better than those in shape?







I read it in a Novel, then it came up in an Air Force survival course.
Also in the true story of the Whaler ship Essex, the blacks died first because they had very little body fat to use for fuel when the food ran out.
As far as Floaters, I think fat people, especially females do stay up longer and come back up sooner. Either that, or nobody takes the time to ditch the Blacks in the river.
 
quote:

Originally posted by walterv

quote:

Originally posted by Thudpucker

Blacks have much lower ratio of Fat to Muscle too. They just dont float as easy as we fat White folks.






Is that really true, not the black thing, but that fatt people float better than those in shape?








Walter if that's true I want you to come with me when we pick up my new boat!

If the boat goes down, I can float on you to shore! I will bring the paddle, you bring the KFC!
 
Back
Top