ANYONE USING AIS

I just purchased the ACR Nauticast 2680. I decided to use a stand alone GPS antenna and stand alone AIS antenna both come with the ACR package. The Raymarine AIS5000 is now on their website but when I read the specifications the transmit switch and reciever combiner caused a 3.5db loss on both systems. Being that AIS Class B is only 2 watts to begin with lossing a little over half the power didn't seem like a comprmise I could tolerate. I also didn't want to have additional losses in either of the 2 VHF marine radios I have in the boat the Raymarine 240 and Uniden 625. I have plenty of room to place the antennas in the hardtop. Add 2 more antennas to the boat that already has plenty (to many) of antennas.
Bill
 
As a commercial mariner in the Puget Sound area involved with class A AIS, I have been waiting with trepidation for the day when class B AIS becomes common among recreational boaters. As I understand AIS, additional transmitters (from both A and B systems) in close proximity will degrade the performance of both systems. This is not a desirable scenario for a system that has enough drawbacks on its own. To include recreational boats that are required by Rule 10 of the COLREGS to stay clear of power driven vessels following a traffic lane anyway, doesn't make sense.

My recommendation for some years has been to encourage recreational boaters navigating in protected waters to install an AIS receiver so that they can see commercial vessels. This recommendation is still very appropriate. Save your money. If you are bound offshore, there are compelling reasons for you to be equipped with class A or B AIS.
 
Jay there is no scientific data to support your claims. I am an RF designer by trade I can not see how there would be any problems. Please provide a link so I can clear up what I believe is a myth. Please take no offense I need to get to the bottom of this. Class B and A AIS have coexisted in Europe for some time with no issues other than some of the really early class A units needing upgrading. I have read all the independent testing, FCC filings on the NPR and the USCG reports. I would recommend you read this first.
http://www.epn-online.com/page/new52472/class-b-ais-the-design-challenge.html

Thanks Bill
 
The AIS system is designed with active time-slice management in mind. All participating transceivers negotiate their transmission times with all other transceivers in the local area. Adding recreational boaters to the mix should not cause problems.

I have personnally used an airborne AIS receiver over New Orleans. I was able to receive over 1000 transceivers. We were at high altitude, were using a receive-only sytem and were listening to several different groups of ships which were managing their transmission slots. Even under these extreme conditions I was able to get good data from all the ships. Transceivers on the surface will obvviously not receive this many signals since they are limited by line of sight.

I don't think recreational boaters will cause a problem until there are thousands in a 20 mile area.

Mike
 
quote:

Originally posted by boatbum

Out of curiousity I found an article that points out some differences between class A and class B. It seems the class B transponders are not 100% compaitble with the older class A transponders. http://www.navagear.com/2008/11/uscg-issues-safety-alert-on-class-b-ais/
I like the idea of AIS for traveling in busy water but wonder about the value add otherwise. It was amusing (for about 5 minutes) to pick out the AIS ids being received while on a yacht recently but other than that I find it has little value for us.
Why?
Normally we travel in good weather and we are cognizant of the shipping channels we will be traversing or crossing. With good weather, which is one of our requirements for travel, most shipping of AIS worthy is clearly visable as are smaller craft. With all of the gimmickry available now, we can easily distract ourselves from our task of piloting. We don't have crew that can monitor all of these devices.
So why go for it?






Dan if you ever need to hail a commercial vessel while at sea if you can identify the ship via their AIS you can hail them by name. if you don't have the ship's name its not likely they will answer.
 
I just looked at our combo unit. It is a Furuno GVA-100 all in one antenna.

URL]
 
One problem I have observed is that I have yet to see a commercial radar set that can display more than 100 AIS targets at a time (which is really not that many). In heavy areas of traffic (pretty much any major port in the U.S.) this leads to an "AIS Max Target" alarm which, quite frankly, gets to be annoying. This causes most bridge officers/pilots to simply turn off the AIS overlay, effectively killing a very powerful navigation tool. The other way to do it, is to discriminate Class-B targets so as to only display the Class-A's, again leaving most recreational boaters off the picture.

Most likely, this is a software issue that can be addressed. But it currently is something to be considered if you have a Class B transceiver and "expect to be seen" by commercial vessels.

A well-integrated ECDIS can handle much higher numbers of AIS targets, but ECDIS is not yet required equipment and even if it is installed, an AIS interface is not mandatory.
 
We have had lots of AIS targets on our radar, but I don't think
we have ever hit 100 of them.
We usually set the radar range between 16 to 24 miles. We only
use it for collision avoidance. We are also right next to the
Mississippi River and Houston/Galveston shipping lanes. When
a ship is within 16 miles, they are normally an hour or so out.
 
AFAIK, the actual radar range in use has nothing to do with it. The targets that are being fed to the radar are all of the targets within range of the AIS receiver (regardless of range) and are then "stored" and presented onto the screen when appropriate. This allows you to "see" AIS targets that come into VHF range well beyond the normal radar horizon.

I do know that at least JRC has a model with a setting that will allow it to "ignore" AIS targets beyond a certain range, so as not to take up room in the memory unnecessarily.

And 100 targets is really not that many when you're in a busy port. Besides other ships, with all of the tugs, fishing boats and ferries tied up or underway, it adds up quickly. Keep in mind that the antenna height on a ship allows it to receive an AIS signal from targets more distant than the typical receiving range on a small boat.
 
This is why I would rather use a low gain low mounted AIS VHF antenna perhaps even a rubber ducky. This will effect the range of the AIS and limit overcrowding the plotter. I will be trying various AIS VHF antennas I will be glad to update the board on my findings. To be quite frank the on-line AIS shore based systems I have played with I have yet to see one with more than 50 ships even when I look at Philadelphia for instance.
Bill
 
I am about 60 miles offshore out of Southwest Pass.
Our AIS antenna's are about 115 ft. above the water.
On our AIS, radar range does have something to do with it. It only overlays
the boats within the range we have the radar set on. We cannot see anything
else it picks up farther than that.
Our antenna is a combo of GPS antenna and what looks like a metal car antenna for VHF.
Not the big long fiberglass VHF type. But I think the antenna height makes up
for the short antenna length.
We never get any error messages about too many ships. I just set the radar to
120 miles, but we only get AIS up to around 32 miles away. We cannot pick up
anthing farther than that with the AIS. I don't think we will have more than
100 ships within that 32 miles. But we do consistantly have about 50 or so.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Billylll

Jay there is no scientific data to support your claims. I am an RF designer by trade I can not see how there would be any problems. Please provide a link so I can clear up what I believe is a myth. Please take no offense I need to get to the bottom of this. Class B and A AIS have coexisted in Europe for some time with no issues other than some of the really early class A units needing upgrading. I have read all the independent testing, FCC filings on the NPR and the USCG reports. I would recommend you read this first.
http://www.epn-online.com/page/new52472/class-b-ais-the-design-challenge.htmlThanks Bill






Bill, I stand corrected. Since my involvement as a practicing waterway user in the implementation of class A AIS ended around 2004-05 (the local Class B designers were still at work at that time), the class B design considerations have apparently provided solutions for many challenges that were identified at that time. Regards, Jay
 
AIS was a lifesaver for me! I added a receiver to my PC based chart plotter before beginning the trek from Lauderdale to Michigan City, IN with my (new to me) Lazzara MY. Installed it myself, mine uses a simple splitter off the VHF antennae, and it works like a charm, on oceans, inland, and great lakes. Cost about $400 if I recall correctly. Plugs into usb port on cpu, comes with disk to set it up, fairly easy.

Leaving Norfolk in dense fog, I knew there were several large container ships anchored out, and several moving, and it was tough to differentiate which was which on radar. The AIS made it simple! My retired fishing captain buddy got one for his trawler (after being impressed with mine) before leaving for FL down the river route, and said all the tug/barges showed up, and made his journey a lot more comfortable and safer.

I highly recommend AIS. I'm thinking about adding the transceiver version next.

Tom Dogan
President, National Boating Federation
 
Kurt as far as the Big Brother the ACR has a silent run switch. This allows it to receive AIS targets but not transmit your information.
Bill
 
Back
Top