auto-inflate PFD's

STEELA

Member
exMember
Joined
Jun 23, 2005
RO Number
17957
Messages
435
I have all manual inflate PFD's and I personally wear a conventional PFD. I know people who wear the auto-inflates that also have them for their kids. Something bugs me about these things. That's alot of faith in
technology since the need for that technology
would come into play during a potential life or death scenario. I would assume the need for the PFD would be during a tragic and scary over-board situation. If the auto doesn't auto, and a back-up manual inflate is required, only certain people would be capable of getting it done.

Would you wear an auto deploy parachute?
 
Would you wear an auto deploy parachute?
Of course I would, as do many other skydivers. The auto deploy mechanism is there in case you "forget" to manually deploy.
 
I guess you could take the other side as well. What if you get hit..say with the boom on a sailboat or something else and you go overboard unconcious? Wouldn't you like to put your faith in the automatic inflation? I sail and that is why mine are automated inflatable...they also have the manual inflate as back up. So in essence, I have yours, plus something additional. I am ok with it that way.
 
You have to be clear in what you mean by "auto" - do you mean that it will automatically trigger the inflate when it hits the water or the mere fact that it does inflate.

We have the inflateable ones because they are really much more comfortable to wear BUT we chose the ones where the user has to pull a tab to inflate them. I don't believe the others are un-reliable but I did not want one to inflate at the wrong time and also, we could teach the kids (and ourselves) the standard procedure rather than what to do if the thing DID NOT deploy, if you know what I mean. ALWAYS pull the tab to get it inflated.

As for them actually failing to inflate - we have discarded that as a non-material possibility. I realize that it could happen that the user is incapable of deploying the vest but have likewise decided that the risk is nominal - for us in any case.

Having said the above, our youngest (10) still wears the old regular vest and will graduate to an inflatable when she's old enough to make these descisions on the fly in a panic situation.
 
That's my issue with them.... If they don't inflate the "type" of person the wearer is should certainly be a consideration.
 
what is you get "boomed" overboard and you're out cold... And the sucker doesn't "auto" inflate?
 
quote:

Originally posted by STEELA

the auto-inflates that also have them for their kids.






Personnaly my concern with kids and auto-inflate PFD's would be unanticipated inflation. What happens when it inflates while they are roughhousing, in the cabin, etc?
 
Boat had autos for all aboard. Here's the deal:

First, if you are anticipating heavy conditions, wear a standard Type 1. The reason people do not wear them all the time is that they are bulky, interfere with what you are doing and are often uncomfortable.

No that we have established that you will likely not be wearing a type 1 at all times, what do you do? Wear an inflatable.

Inflatables are generally more comfortable that a standard PFD. There are problems, though compromises are a better term. They require maintenance. They are unsuitable for non swimmers and juveniles ( I would assume geriatrics as well ). They must be manually inflated for use.

The alternate is to wear auto-inflate vests. They will inflate ( to the best of my knowledge, no well maintained auto vest has failed in use ) when the user gets immersed. Which is the advantage, and the problem. If you get splashed they could inflate. So they are not good for wear on the dinghy, or certain times when sailing. But they are wonderful for wear 80% of the time. I even wore mine while working on the boat while at the dock ( a hazardous time period, loading the boat and slipping. Head hits are common )

SO, there is a PFD for the task, but no one PFD for all tasks. Know which is which, wear the one that is appropriate.

Note that auto inflate vests require regular maintenance. Mine had their inflate bobbins changed every 6 mo, the cylinder every year.
 
We have Mustang 3183 auto-inflating. These are hydrostatic therefore will not inflate if merely splashed. The mechanism must be underwater 4-inches to inflate. it also is good for 5 years before rearming.

It is a very comfortable vest as well.

As with every other decision in life, there is no one-size-fits-all. Heck even night-shirts now come labeled one-size fits-most.
 
I have the auto-inflate sold to auxiliarists. It has the canister type auto inflate AND a maual pull to inflate AND the manual blow it up yourself. I figure one of those three will work 99.9% of the time!

During my training, I jumped into the deep end of a swimming pool with my auto inflatable on. Usually when I jump feet first into 25 ft of water, my feet will touch bottom and I can push off to the top. This PFD inflated so fast my head was out of the water before I realized the thing had inflated! It was amazingly responsive. I found it uncomfortable to swim with it inflated because it rubbed into my chin and sholders. By releasing some of the air, I was able to swim to the other end of the pool. But it definately kept my head and face out of the water!

BTW----I believe these use the same technology as air bags in cars and that technology has been around for about 25 yrs. The reliability is there as long as you maintain it per instructions.

On board I keep a floatation jacket, a "regular" PFD and the inflatable PFD----all for me. I also have those orange thingys for guests......
 
What Bill said.

Sherry, I have the same ones you do. They WILL inflate in a damp storage locker. Found out the hard way. We store them inside now.
 
Yes... great insight... I wear a conventional PFD all the time. Always really have so it really doen't bug me too much. What would your opinion be with an 11 yr old boy, say 105 lbs and very knowledable and aware?
 
I'm not sure if the CG has approved them for kids yet. If you can buy a CG Approved one that fits him correctly, try it. Do NOT put him into an adult sized one! Let us know what you find out/do.
 
My first response would be to use a standard PFD.

But, having said that, you may feel differently. There are a few reasons for the "Inappropriate" statement.

1) A non-swimmer will likely panic if suddenly overboard and then again, when they yank the cord and this blasted balloon blows up and squeezes their chest and neck. Talk about panic attack.

2) The same problem -might- occur in juveniles. Your call. Properly trained, many 11 yr olds would be just fine with an inflatable; others could easily get into trouble.

3) One of the important aspects of an inflatable is how they fit, and how they are worn. If done wrong, "stuff happens". An improperly worn inflatable can be dangerous.

4) Size. Keep in mind that these vests are almost always sized for adults, and that juveniles "come in different sizes". My suggestion would be to inflate one ( manually; cheaper! ) and check out the correct fit. If the vest is too large, definitely not.

Again, you are the captain, your call. 11 YO is a "middlin" age, and it would be a judgement call in each individual case. Be sure to practice with the equipment ( each individual that might wear one! ). They are simple devices, but some training is needed.
 
quote:

Originally posted by STEELA

what is you get "boomed" overboard and you're out cold... And the sucker doesn't "auto" inflate?






The primary tool, there (on a sailboat), is a harness, possibly used in conjunction with an auto-inflate, or other, pfd.
 
Just one more important safety tip.
Absolutely NEVER wear an inflatable PFD under any type of outerwear, such as jacket or windbreaker.
It could completely immobilize you, or possibly even kill you.
 
I have one simple rule on my boat, when it leaves the dock everyone on board has a PFD on. As long as we are away from dock they keep the PFD on. To make things easier I have 18 inflatable and 9 standard PFD's. I have fanny packs for the adults which have a pull cord to inflate. The kids get vests that are auto inflate with the option of pulling the cord to inflate or blow to inflate. They also have partial buoyancy as worn. The fanny packs are so light i often forget i am wearing and wear on shore.
John d
2005 Meridian 411 SB
 
One, auto inflation is not rocket science. Two it has been around for almost 80 years. When has it ever failed? Three, if you get boomed, knocked out and your auto vest fails to inflate it's just not your day and it is your time.
 
I've had a well-maintained auto-inflater fail but it was one of the original SOS's and has been improved since then . I hugely prefer the Mustang bomber "flote-coats" for regular use and so do my guests by a long shot as long as it is not tooo hot out. Yes , I do also have more than a full complement of the best type-1's and 4 immersion suits onboard and often a 4man offshore valise raft but the flote-coats are something almost everyone actually likes to wear while running without feeling uncomfortable or forgive me , a little dorky but safe.
 
quote:

Originally posted by charlie826

What Bill said.

Sherry, I have the same ones you do. They WILL inflate in a damp storage locker. Found out the hard way. We store them inside now.






Yikes - thanks for that tip. Always good to learn from someone else's experience.

Speaking if children ... Michelle will be 16 next month and got one of the 3183's last fall. Previously she wore a ski-type PFD but had started asking about my SOSpenders and tried them out a couple times. She's a very mature young lady and is quite tall so the sizing wasn't a problem.

Since it was also time to inflate and rearm the SOSpenders, she volunteered to wear it while we stuck the autoinflate button in a glass of water. It was pretty fun way to have her feel how the inflate felt as well as test the vest.

10-22MC2Mustang.jpg
 
Back
Top