Autopilot Help - Raymarine

Crossroads

Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
2208
Messages
308
I have a Raymarine S1G corepack autopilot installed on a 1978 Mainship trawler. The autopilot works great in every function except when I'm attempting to have the autopilot follow a multi-waypoint Route instead instead of a fixed Course. When I attempt to enter the TRACK mode, the autopilot successfully comes on course to the first waypoint but then immediately alerts me that it has arrived and is waiting for me to OK turning to the next waypoint. I am using a Garmin 540 as the GPS/Chartplotter. I have corresponded with both Garmin and Raymarine. The NMEA circuitry is working correctly because I can read all the needed info on the autopilot display. Although helpful Raymarine suggests I send them my corepack for repair. However, I'm not sure any S1G corepack will successfully function in the TRACK mode. Before I remove my autopilot for repair, I would like to know if anyone has an S1G corepack interfaced to a Garmin Charplotter that can successfully navigate a Route when in the TRACK mode. Any help appreciated.
 
probably not, but I'll ask anyway.....how far away is the first waypoint, and how far do you have your arrival point set to be?
 
It doesn't matter if the first waypoint is 30 miles or two miles away, it signals arrival immediately. The Garmin does provide a distance to waypoint (DTW) word to the autopilot. What I'm looking for is someone else with an S1G corepack to find out if any of them will process NMEA for Routes. I don't think the S1G operating software will do it.
 
Yes same unit to a Garmin 2010, no problem, when it hits the arrival point I need to ack for next waypoint to route it and it steers to it without a problem. I do find it holds a better course when I manually set a course then following GPS.
 
what you're describing may sound like a flaw, but i'm not sure it is. if you can follow a multi point track with only having to accept the next way point at arrival my thinking is that is a good thing. every once in a while when transitioning to a way point from a magnetic course i find the auto pilot (same SG-1) will pick up a different waypoint. by my accepting it i verify that i'm going to the correct waypoint. i would not trust any autopilot to follow a multi point course without forcing me to verify the time/place of a change in course.

in fact when i set out to make a route i make individual waypoints and label them in sequence and navigate to each one so that i'm forced to verify my position at each point. it also makes it easier should i have to go off course to simply modify my heading to the next waypoint rather than having to return to the route.
 
Vic, I totally agree with you. My problem is the S1G signals arrival immediately before we have moved 100 yards. If I acknowledge and accept the new waypoint the AP heads to the new one without ever seeing the first one and immediately says we have arrived. In fact, I can go thru a 5 waypoint route (100 miles) in about 15 seconds. I guess I have some type of problem with the integration. Since Marlin20 says his works as advertised, I need to figure out why the AP thinks it has always arrived immediately. Beginning to think it may be a Garmin issue. Wish I had a spare S1G to slave in.
 
I doubt this the answer but I'll offer this information anyway. Many Garmins have their own proprietary NMEA and standard NMEA 0183. Raymarine only reads NMEA 0183 so you want to be sure which NMEA the garmin is putting out.

Have you tried hooking the Garmin up to a PC to determine what NMEA sentences it's sending? Perhaps you have to turn on specific sentences to make the Raymarine happy.
 
FWIW- I believe my Simrad AP 21 & 22 system has a programmed-in limit of 10* change of course to a next route WP it will accept & follow automatically before asking for confirmation & command to proceed with the route course change. Anything over that 10* and it will make sure that you are aware of, and choose, what could be a somewhat sudden turn that could endanger POB's and nearby vessels , and it forces the operator to be a bit more aware of whether that next route WP & course is the intended one ( for instance, it is certainlly not unheard of to have Route WP's entered in incorrect sequence.).

When entering the initial command to follow a route , make sure that route does not contain your present position (such as your slip) as a starting point or you will have to key in command to advance to the next route WP.
 
Crossroads, I think it works that way even if you have a raymarine charplotter. It wants you to acknowledge the turn.
 
Yes Garmin's interface wiring is different, but once I looked it up it, wired, worked fine. The ack function is by Raymarines design, not terrible, I'm just sitting there anyway.
 
If your not getting the DTW, then you are not sending the correct message from the 540. Go to the communication configuration and sellect more messages.
 
Back
Top