back charged for insurance

bbright

Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2007
RO Number
25444
Messages
6
I hope someone can shed some light on my situation. I bought a boat for $17k in october of 06. My loan officer said that I needed to provide proof of insurance asap. I stored it in a garage which was insured for $50k I didn't even use the boat until i purchased insurance at $250 for one year for the boat itself on 1/02/07 and assumed my insurance company faxed the paper work to the bank. about a week later i received a letter from mountain west bank, stating that i haven't shown proof of insurance and they have provided it for me. It was $2,700 for one year, and it was applied to my loan already. So i went to the bank, showed proof of insurance and the money was taken off my loan and everything was ok... until a week after that i received another letter saying that since I didn't have insurance on the boat from October thru January they were charging me $700 for insurance and it was applied to my loan. I went back and asked how they could back charge me for insurance three months ago when I'm current on payments and they said they already paid out to their insurance company and it could not be refunded. And on top of that, the insurance they provided did not even cover the boat, it only covered the loan. So how can they charge me for insurance that covered only a loan when i have always been current on payments??? any info is welcome thanks
 
Banks are notoriously bureaucratic and inflexible. You signed a contract saying that you would insure the boat from that moment forward and they are holding you to it. I am sure if you read the loan agreement you will find this clause including the provision that if you don't insure the boat they will. Of course they do it at high rates and probably get a big revenue stream from it. The sad part is that if you had bought insurance from day one and included a lay-up period, you would have paid much less and saved yourself this hassle.

The fact that there was no loss is not going to satisfy the bank - they need all the boxes checked on their paperwork so that they can sell your loan and lots of others to third parties. Your only chance would be to contact the VP or higher in charge of boat loans, but I think you are going to be out of luck (and $700).
 
bbright

I'ts one more way for the banks to gouge money while protecting their collateral...in your loan papers you gave them the right to purchase insurance in your behalf. The loan officer gave you a hint as to what you signed when he told you to get insurance ASAP to cover the collateral even though it was “safe” in your garage. The good side is if your house had burned before you put insurance on the boat several months later, your loan would have been paid off….but only the loan…your equity would have been lost…banks only work for themselves
 
ah hell, i just found my insurance doc. and it's stated if i fail to show insurance within 10 days they can provide their own at my expense. But at the time they did that, i had current insurance. i coulden't find anything about "back charging" insurance. theres gotta be something i can do.... i was told to contact the stats banking commission, maybe they can shed more light. like you said, banks are not flexible but it won't hurt to try
 
Probably nothing you can do - it appears they got you on a technicality. Best thing you can do now is avoid doing future business with them and perhaps give them a little free 'publicity'.
 
i opened my first bank account there, my first car loan and now a boat loan... you'd think they would cut a little slack but your right "banks only work for themselves". If nothing works, i'm waiting 6 months and changing banks. currently at mountain west bank, and I don't love where I bank!!
 
i had a similar issue a few years ago on a car loan when the bank decided that $1000 deductible was too high and was trying to force me to lower the deductible. load doc didn't mention any max deduct and low deductible are a rip off... it took a lot of arguing to convince them that they had now grounds to force anything on me.
 
I think you are pretty lucky they only charged you $700.00, you were in violation of your obligation. They need to protect the loan. I haven't seen a collateral loan that doesn't have insurance coverage requirements and the consequences of not having it.
 
Sounds to me that you were in default of the agreement. You owe it and you only have to read the contract you didn't take the time or care to read initially to determine that fact.
 
Well, if the State Banking commission cant help you...
The BBB might be able to write a letter for you. That will force the Bank to layout all thier reasoning on paper which will make it easier for you to see who's wrong.

One more bully is a piticular lawyer.
You'll have to find a Lawyer that has beaten that bank in court several times. It might take a little searching, but it might work out this way.
If the Bank sees a letter from this piticular lawyer, they might just roll over backwards rather than risk a big-bucks fight over buying insurance for a time in the past when there was no loss.
 
I's Suggest that you talk to YOUR insurance person and see if they would be willing to back date coverage to the date of your loan. True it will still cost you some money but the pro=rate will be significantly less.

Almost there
 
Honestly I'm surprised you were even able to close on the loan without having insurance in place. Anytime I had a boat loan I needed proof of insurance before the loan was closed. They are enforcing the rules you agreed to.
 
I'm with the bank on this one.
You agreed in writing to provide them with proof of insurance for the full value of the loan within ten days. And the consequences of you failing to do so were well spelled out in the contract you signed.
Why would anyone expect a bank to loan money on an uninsured boat?
 
You could check with your home owners insurance, the boat may have been covered the entire time it was in your garage. Even if you were in default the bank is showing how much they value you as a customer. If the home owners insurance is a dead end call the bank customer service number and speak to a supervisor.
Rob
 
Thanks for the feedback from everyone. yes I should have asked more about insurance since it was never explained in detail. I set the loan up by phone and only met with loan officer to sign papers and take a pic of boat. Yes, they need to protect the loan but when they charged me, the loan was already protected with MY insurance! I talked to her about the $700 charge and she does agree with me, and thinks it should be refunded but the only one who can authorize it is the manager which said theres nothing they can do, also suggesting i shop around for a different bank. I would not have a problem paying insurance for previous months but at a reasonable price. At their rate i would be paying on the boat for the rest of my life. it sounds like they have me on a technicality and are not willing to work with me. a lawyer would probably cost more than what they charged me. sounds like a may have to bit the bullet on this one.
 
When you fail to proide the nessasary coverage , and the bank provides it for you, you can not expect the bank to go "price shopping" for you. Contracts are put in place for a reason, to protect the lender AND the borrower. If you didnt like the terms you shoul not have signed. No matter what is said, "standard contract" Etc. Read it ALL, and Understand, before you sign it.
 
I know I'm gonna get flamed for this, but I can't stay quiet any longer. Why is that people refuse to accept responsibility for their own actions (or inaction as the case may be)? Adrift seems to have hit the nail on the head -- you agreed to provide the bank proof of insurance within 10 days and further agreed that they could provide the insurance at your expense if you failed to do so. You failed to do so, right? You signed a binding contract to do so. Why should you expect that someone (except maybe your own lawyer) "explain in detail" to you something you were signing? Only you are responsible for understanding the things you sign. No one else. Not the bank, not your homeowner's insurance company, no one but you. As for having you on a technicality, that's what contracts are for, to spell out precisely who is responsible for what, in no ambiguous terms. Sounds to me like you found the part in the contract that addresses the issue and it doesn't sound like it was ambiguous -- you do this or else we'll do that. The bank just exercised their right under the contract to do exactly what they said they would do.

I'm sorry if this sounds like a rant, but when folks try to wriggle out of their responsibilities and then succeed, it only costs the rest of us $$$s, which really gets me going. Someone has to pay for the bank to be "good-natured" about it and I bet you it won't be them. They will pass on the cost of relieving you of the $700 burden to the rest of its customers in one form or another. Bite the bullet, admit you made a mistake, learn from that mistake, and move on. Ok, I'm done now so, Flame On!
 
No flame for here - right on Randy. If everyone kept their word (ie did what they were susposed to do) the world would be simpler, safer, cheaper and all around more pleasant.
 
When the bank asked for proof of insurance, you never provided it. You have stated to us that it is covered because it is stored in my garage. You never provided your home owners policy to the bank at which point they would have told you....get a boat policy to cover the boat/loan. How would the bank know you would never take your boat out of the garage, down the road on a trailer, or splash it in the water for just 5 minutes???????

You screwed yourself.....just forget it. Life lesson #361....learned.
 
Back
Top