Battery Watering Systems

davida

Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2006
RO Number
20864
Messages
43
Does anybody uses one-point watering systems like Flow-Rite's Pro-Fill to keep the battery level filled?

My house batteries are numerous (12 x T-105s for a 24 volt, 660 amp house), and somewhat difficult to reach and such a system would be great for maintenance.

Thanks, David
 
I have 12 batteries also and don't have a self watering system.
This year I was in a friends boat who does and he showed it to me. It was awesome. He had it connected to a bottle of distilled water and he just pumped a bulb a couple of times and said "that's it.. all topped up".
 
Ok , I only have 3 but in a PITA place... This would be great... Where do I sign-up ?
 
Get AGMs and forget about watering the batteries forever.
I have 8 batteries all AGM not a single problem.
Bill
 
I've got a self watering system in my 5th wheel trailer. Push the button & the pump runs. I have 6X6V batterys which have some sort of floating device to see when they are up enough.

I really don't like it. I don't like wet cells period. Next year they most likely will come to the end of their useful life. They will be replaced with AGMs. No more levels to worry about.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Billylll

Get AGMs and forget about watering the batteries forever.
I have 8 batteries all AGM not a single problem.
Bill






The point is one Trojan 6V, 200 Amp AGM is around $300, one Trojan 6V, 220 Amp t-105 (wet) is around $140, one Costco 6V, 220 Amp GC (wet) is around $75. You do the math with 12 batteries, even with a life cycle of 2-3 years on the Costco's vs. 3-4 years on the t-105 vs. 4-5 years on the AGM's.

David
 
Our new boat came equipped with one for the house batteries. All other batteries are sealed. I can still make a mess only because I am a moron. The system came with the squeeze ball and it is set up so you don’t have to remove the battery box covers. Also, the house batteries are two sets with one on each side of the boat. The system is connected between both sets and you simply drop the draw tube into a bottle of distilled water, make up the quick connect, and squeeze the bulb until it gets stiff (one connection does the whole set). I usually knock over the bottle of water and drip water everywhere handling the squeeze ball. At least the mess isn’t with battery acid. I can’t count the number of times that I have ruined shirts or pants with small holes from battery acid.

I had never heard of it until our delivery captain demonstrated it to me.

I certainly recommend it.

Andy
 
Billyiii, while I agree that AGMs are great, down heya in da Sout, they are not good for all applications; AGMs have a problem with heat. Even the mfgrs will state that ( for example ) using an AGM in a under-front hood location in a car is a bad idea. The heat simply kills them.

So if your battery location is -not- in a high heat environment, they are likely fine. But avoid any area where it gets hot. In that application, flooded is a much better choice.

btw: the heat threshold for AGMs is fairly low, about 140 def F, if I am remembering correctly.
 
Andy, it sounds like adding water to your batteries is the least of your problems! Good luck.
[:-bonc01] [:-bonc01] [:-bonc01]
 
The systems I have looked at are twice the cost of a battery. That said, it is not that much more expensive to upgrade to AGM's.
 
I just replaced all my batteries last year and the guy gave me a quote for the watering system. It was not very much at all. I actually can't believe I didn't buy it... I think it was $100 or so extra.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Radioactive

Billyiii, while I agree that AGMs are great, down heya in da Sout, they are not good for all applications; AGMs have a problem with heat. Even the mfgrs will state that ( for example ) using an AGM in a under-front hood location in a car is a bad idea. The heat simply kills them.

So if your battery location is -not- in a high heat environment, they are likely fine. But avoid any area where it gets hot. In that application, flooded is a much better choice.

btw: the heat threshold for AGMs is fairly low, about 140 def F, if I am remembering correctly.





Bill they are all in cool places again I use the temperature probe, I do reaize it only measures the temp. of one battery. 3 years no problems at all. My marina tried to talk me out of them. I have by far the most electronics of any boat in the marina. The manager says I am the only boat he has seen with -0- battery problems. He now installs them as an recommended option. I have Lifeline's perhaps they are just a good manufacture? Bill
 
Taken from Battery website:

AGM, or Absorbed Glass Mat
It is true that AGM batteries are more expensive than Maintenance Free (Ca/Ca) batteries. AGM batteries offer the following advantages over conventional batteries:

* Safer. Due to the much lower production of hydrogen gas during charging.
* Maintenance-free. Sealed maintenance-free design means you never have to worry about checking water levels. You'll never have to check or add electrolyte again, unlike conventional batteries which require periodic fluid checks, do not require water.
* Sealed. Spill proof. They can be mounted in virtually any position (because they are sealed).
* No corrosion. Liquid-free AGM design will not leak or corrode on paint and chrome. It also eliminates corrosion around the battery terminals.
* They have less internal resistance that offers more CCA amperage than wet batteries.
* Heat & vibration resistant. By nature AGM batteries are more heat and vibration resistant than conventional batteries, both which contribute to the large majority of failures in motorcycle & competition auto applications.
* Slower self-discharge rate. Slower self-discharge rate (longer shelf life) means battery can sit for extended periods of time without constant monitoring. A wet battery discharges 15% a month, where our AGM batteries discharge only 2-3% a month. AGM batteries have less internal resistance which allows them to produce more discharge current (cold cranking amperage) vs. comparable conventional "wet" batteries, and AGM batteries also recharge faster
* Longer service life.
* Lower deep discharge failure.
* Higher bulk charge acceptance rate (which means up to a 15% shorter recharge time).
* Do not require special hazardous shipping and can be used near saltwater.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Jimmiere

Taken from Battery website:

AGM, or Absorbed Glass Mat
It is true that AGM batteries are more expensive than Maintenance Free (Ca/Ca) batteries. AGM batteries offer the following advantages over conventional batteries:

* Safer. Due to the much lower production of hydrogen gas during charging.
-- True, however, properly vented wet batteries are probably just as safe

* Maintenance-free. Sealed maintenance-free design means you never have to worry about checking water levels. You'll never have to check or add electrolyte again, unlike conventional batteries which require periodic fluid checks, do not require water.
-- True, thats why I inquired about the watering systems to make this part easy

* Sealed. Spill proof. They can be mounted in virtually any position (because they are sealed).
-- True. They are the only option for anything other than conventional mounting

* No corrosion. Liquid-free AGM design will not leak or corrode on paint and chrome. It also eliminates corrosion around the battery terminals.
-- True, however this is somewhat negligible with a proper battery box and vaseline aound the terminals

* They have less internal resistance that offers more CCA amperage than wet batteries.
-- True, can be offset with a larger battery bank with less expensive wet cells

* Heat & vibration resistant. By nature AGM batteries are more heat and vibration resistant than conventional batteries, both which contribute to the large majority of failures in motorcycle & competition auto applications.
-- True but I haven't heard of any batteries falling apart on a boat, cheap or expensive

* Slower self-discharge rate. Slower self-discharge rate (longer shelf life) means battery can sit for extended periods of time without constant monitoring. A wet battery discharges 15% a month, where our AGM batteries discharge only 2-3% a month. AGM batteries have less internal resistance which allows them to produce more discharge current (cold cranking amperage) vs. comparable conventional "wet" batteries, and AGM batteries also recharge faster
-- That is one advantage you can not compensate with wet cells

* Longer service life.
-- I doubt that. Any quality wet cell is probably just as durable. Some higher end wet cells (Rolls) have a much longer warranty and comparable in cost to AGMs.

* Lower deep discharge failure.
-- I don't know about that, any references?

* Higher bulk charge acceptance rate (which means up to a 15% shorter recharge time).
-- True, you have to charge 15% longer, 5 hours vs 5.75 hours for example

* Do not require special hazardous shipping and can be used near saltwater.
-- True, but many wet cells are specifically approved for marine use by their manufacturer.

Look, I am not disputing the advantages of AGM vs wet cells. The question is, in my case, am I willing or capable of paying $3,600 for AGMs vs $900 for wet cells for those advantages. I can install 4 new sets of Costco batteries for one set of AGMs.




 
Just disputing some myths about AGMs in the above discussion. Definitely more expensive, but I have had a set of Optima blue top starting batteries for eight years, just took them off after winterizing the boat. I keep them on a trickle charger in the garage over the winter. By the way, they are in the engine room (twin 7.4 mercs) less than a foot from the exhaust manifolds (express cruiser). It definitely gets hot in there while underway in the summer. And its a real pain to even squeeze yourself in there, much less check the water level of the batteries. I like set and forget. ;-)
 
Have two (2) AC Delco maintenance "FREE" Voyagers...one for each engine & split house needs. Get 5-6 years out of them & if you're a good shopper, can find for $125 each. Model M30HMF Marine, RC=180, CCA=625, CA=900, Wt.= 60.6 lbs., $124.95. Hope they never stop making. Best bang for the buck !
 
They are not for everyone because of the price. But if you have to change your batteries every 4 years and I get 8 years out of mine then I'm not sure the cost difference is all that great. But to each his own, meaning there is no wrong I just love AGM batteries for all of the above mentioned reasons Jimmiere pointed out. Bill
 
Back
Top