quote:
Originally posted by Jimmiere
Taken from Battery website:
AGM, or Absorbed Glass Mat
It is true that AGM batteries are more expensive than Maintenance Free (Ca/Ca) batteries. AGM batteries offer the following advantages over conventional batteries:
* Safer. Due to the much lower production of hydrogen gas during charging.
-- True, however, properly vented wet batteries are probably just as safe
* Maintenance-free. Sealed maintenance-free design means you never have to worry about checking water levels. You'll never have to check or add electrolyte again, unlike conventional batteries which require periodic fluid checks, do not require water.
-- True, thats why I inquired about the watering systems to make this part easy
* Sealed. Spill proof. They can be mounted in virtually any position (because they are sealed).
-- True. They are the only option for anything other than conventional mounting
* No corrosion. Liquid-free AGM design will not leak or corrode on paint and chrome. It also eliminates corrosion around the battery terminals.
-- True, however this is somewhat negligible with a proper battery box and vaseline aound the terminals
* They have less internal resistance that offers more CCA amperage than wet batteries.
-- True, can be offset with a larger battery bank with less expensive wet cells
* Heat & vibration resistant. By nature AGM batteries are more heat and vibration resistant than conventional batteries, both which contribute to the large majority of failures in motorcycle & competition auto applications.
-- True but I haven't heard of any batteries falling apart on a boat, cheap or expensive
* Slower self-discharge rate. Slower self-discharge rate (longer shelf life) means battery can sit for extended periods of time without constant monitoring. A wet battery discharges 15% a month, where our AGM batteries discharge only 2-3% a month. AGM batteries have less internal resistance which allows them to produce more discharge current (cold cranking amperage) vs. comparable conventional "wet" batteries, and AGM batteries also recharge faster
-- That is one advantage you can not compensate with wet cells
* Longer service life.
-- I doubt that. Any quality wet cell is probably just as durable. Some higher end wet cells (Rolls) have a much longer warranty and comparable in cost to AGMs.
* Lower deep discharge failure.
-- I don't know about that, any references?
* Higher bulk charge acceptance rate (which means up to a 15% shorter recharge time).
-- True, you have to charge 15% longer, 5 hours vs 5.75 hours for example
* Do not require special hazardous shipping and can be used near saltwater.
-- True, but many wet cells are specifically approved for marine use by their manufacturer.
Look, I am not disputing the advantages of AGM vs wet cells. The question is, in my case, am I willing or capable of paying $3,600 for AGMs vs $900 for wet cells for those advantages. I can install 4 new sets of Costco batteries for one set of AGMs.