Bilge Pump Surprise

MikeeH

Active member
Member
Joined
Oct 5, 2001
RO Number
6342
Messages
2,297
Some may recall that I purchased a 1988 Wellcraft 190 Classic last year. Boat had been in storage and with only 75 hours on the clock. We keep the boat in the water on our dock all season and did have one huge rain storm last season when the boat took on a bunch of water. Noticing that she was riding low that afternoon I opened the doghouse and saw about 6" of water in what is normally a bone dry bilge. Figured the bilge pump had one of those internal floats that decided not to float. Flipped on the bilge switch at the helm and it pumped just fine. So, all season I used the switch to manually operate the pump when necessary but it made me nervous. Plan was to replace the pump during layup. So, I pulled the pump this weekend and find that the damn thing doesn't have an float switch and is desiged to only work manually!! I've never seen any bilge pump that didn't have some sort of float switch for auto operation. STUPID!! Well, today I put an external float switch in the circuit and all is well... but I'm still baffled about the original pump installation. Dumb. Really dumb.

Rant over.
 
Yeah dumb that the pump didn't have a float, but why would you be on the water before checking operation of all of the bilge pumps andtheir float switches?
 
I was waiting for you to say that they did not have power to the pump when the battery switch is off. There are many boats out there designed this way. Never saw one without a switch, though.
 
My Sea Ray 175 bowrider was the same. I guess they start from an assumption that a trailer boater doesn't need an automatic pump, and if some people would leave the boat in full time, well it's on them. And I'm sure it saves $0.35 on the manufacturing line to cheap out.
 
It s also likely that someone changed the set up over the last 23 years!!!

There should be not one but TWO pumps anyway...

Always a good idea to learn a boat system and also to check all pumps and switches monthly. The smaller the boat the faster they sink...
 
Could it have been one of those pumps that automatically checks for water every few minutes, then pumps whatever water it finds until dry?
 
On smaller low priced boats, I bet that was very common, probably still is today. One of the first things I added to my old 88 FW was a Sure Bail switch to the pump.
 
First, (Keith)I did check the bilge pump before the boat was launched via the manual switch at the helm. In a small boat (19') with a suspected "internal float" bilge pump there is little opportunity for chaecking the operation on the float without flooding the bilge.

Second (Pascal), the boat is 23 years old but with the low hours and the location of the pump under the engine one would easily assume its the original pump. That was confirmed when I finally got the pump out but not its mounting bracket. The engine would need to be removed to get the bracket out. As for a second pump, ah, no, not in this boat without pulling the engine so it can be located where it would actually be able to serve a purpose. A second battery would be more logical at this point and then a second pump when (if) I ever have reason to pull the engine.
 
Consider a remote mounted pump as a backup. The screened suction hose can be easily placed where needed. It can be used with a float switch also.
 
Ironworks,

Are you suggesting a pump that does not need to be submerged? That's a good thought, thanks. I'll do some research and see where I can find a suitable unit. I'll also need to run a new hose to a new thru-hole. I'd prefer not to put a check-valve in the current outlet hose; just one more thing that can go bad when at the worst time.
 
You don't have a few inches of clearance between the front on the engine to add another pump?
 
I had an New 87 21'Bayliner that only had one pump and it was only manual. The first thing I did when I bought the boat was rewire it so it had a float switch and still worked in the manual mode as well. I only kept the boat 8 months but I had planned to put a second pump in over the winter. Ended up getting rid of the boat first.
 
Pascal, no, that's where I placed the float switch and with the existing pump and new float switch there isn't a heck of a lot of room left in the bilge under that little 4 banger. Maybe if the engine was out I could do something like that but not now. I like Iron's idea; that can be accomplished pretty easily.

Butch, yep, that's exactly what I did.
 
The smaller Rule pumps don't have to be flooded to test, simply remove them from the strainer and turn them upside down. Unless the float is stuck, the pump should come on. Can't speak for others.

However this won't find a waterlogged float, so the best way is still to flood the pump, either by putting water in the bilge or putting the pump in a bucket.

The backup pump could be located BESIDE the engine if you have room there. 2" of water under the engine isn't going to sink you. You'd want an alarm or indicator light on that pump, if it EVER comes on you want to know it, 'cause you have a problem.
 
My boat bilge pump did not have a float switch. So when the 2nd battery and battery switch were installed, I had a float switch installed to the pump and had it direct wired to batt #2. This was definitely a must if boat is stored in the water. Even when I put in the Air Dock, I was glad to have the float switch set up for when I was anchored out. I'd hate to wake up with my feet in an inch or more of water!!!!
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

It s also likely that someone changed the set up over the last 23 years!!!





That's what I am thinking.
 
Bottom Line: In life in general, and boating in particular, assume nothing!
 
I just ran into the same thing with my Sons 22 Maco rework. I installed (2) 31 series AGM house batteries and a start battery. When I had the cloth T top replaced with a hardtop I installed 95 watts of solar. The MorningStar duo smart solar charger that directs 90% to the house ,bank and 10% to the starting battery. I installed a 3700GPH crash pump and alarm. Problems solved.
Bill
 
Based on the similar findings by others here I'm thinking that manufacturer's put these non-auto bilge pumps in boats that they think would likely be trailered their whole life in order to save a few bucks on each unit.
 
Back
Top