Boat brand generalizations are wrong

pdecat

Well-known member
Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
842
Messages
11,588
Boat brand generalizations are wrong or at least unsupportable. Too often we read Vikings are great Bayliners are bad type pontifications from somebody that is often not in a position to know facts. Over the years makers produce many models with different designs using different materials and manufacturing methods. Some of those changes later prove to be improvements some reverses but unless someone is intimately familiar with everything done by a maker over many years these generalizations are simply unsupportable.
I have been on many boats of different makes and styles and found their owners happily enjoying themselves blissfully unaware that some folks think their boat is trash for some reason or other.
I think it is reasonable to post specific information if you have experience to know for example that wood window frames proved to be problems or some models had stringer problems but pronouncing all XXX brands junk just indicates ignorance.
 
...Unless it's one of the crappy brands...
 
The best boat is always somebody else's, especially if you don't own one at the time & you are sitting on it.
 
quote:

The best boat is always somebody else's, especially if you don't own one at the time & you are sitting on it.





sooo true
 
Yeah but consistency in high quality is what makes for a trustworthy and relaible product, take Toyota for instance....
 
Maybe I'm from the old school but the vacuum bagged hulls scare me. I'd prefer a solid fiberglass hull anyday.
Bill
 
Many boat buyers/owners do not understand that some brands are "economy models" and are designed for careful usage under select conditions. Other models ( which often cost a great deal more ) are built to play in the raging surf all day long.

Mostly, imho, the quality of a brand gets besmirched simply because buyers have no knowledge of what they are actually buying.

Case in point: Bayliner has often been disparaged in public. But Bayliner does, in fact, produce a several models of very nice inexpensive boats for casual use. They have done a good job of providing a boat that is affordable my many boaters. But when those boats are used in a manner not envisioned by the designers, the boats exhibit problems. ( duh ) and those buyers then complain about the quality of the boat. Often, it is the quality of the buyer that is at fault, rather than the fault of the mfgr.

Yes. Some mfgrs are better at building boats. Yes, some models are duds. But for the most part, most boats will do exactly what they were designed to do.

If you want a "cocktail barge" then do not expect it to both a) be inexpensive and b) stay together when pounding day and night through rough offshore waters. It was built to be a stable platform for pouring martinis at the dock. If you want to go chase tuna, don't buy a "cocktail barge". ;)
 
Billy: you had better avoid any modern airplane then. :D
 
Its my opinion that most people who generalize a certain brand have never even been on one of the boats in question or they have been on one maybe 2 of them and "assume" that they are all the same. We all know what happens when people ass-u-me.

There is always a few duds that a manufacturer makes but they usually are not in the lineup very long and have low production numbers.
 
quote:

Originally posted by 370 Motoryacht

There is always a few duds that a manufacturer makes but they usually are not in the lineup very long and have low production numbers.






I have owned some of those boats.:)
 
quote:

Originally posted by Robski97

How about them BERTRAMS !!!

: )

Rob






You mean the ones that peel away fiberglass like an onion and makes you cry just as much watching it?
 
That argument is still on the table. I had not read that it actually hit the marker, and given the other one that had the hull sides peel away one has to wonder about the current regime controlling quality for that brand.
All brands run into quality issues when their management and economics are brought to bear. Hopefully they all learn from their mistakes and we wind up with a better product as a result.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Billylll

Maybe I'm from the old school but the vacuum bagged hulls scare me. I'd prefer a solid fiberglass hull anyday.
Bill






I'm not sure that I understand this. A vacuum bagged solid glass layup ensures no resin voids, right?
 
Nothing wrong with vacuum bagging, just depends on what you are bonding to. If you are vacuum bagging for the purpose of resin penetrion to the cloth, that can be a very good thing, or a very bad thing if done with incompetence. Equally so, if you are vacuum bagging to end cut balsa, well you got a whole 'nother can of worms to deal with. However, many fibers, such as Kelvar while very strong require vacuum bagging to attain proper resin penetration. If you don't believe me, just ask Boeing.

Just like most things, it is not what you do, but how you do it. The worst hand lay up is usually better than poor vacuum bagging. However done right, vacuum bagging is far superior to anything else.
 
Back
Top