It’s not just your credit score, or that you never missed a payment or paid late, it’s more about your perceived finical health. Other words, if you are carrying a lot of debt (regardless that you can afford it) that is a huge consideration today on weather to lend and the rate.
If you are a business owner that does not disclose your true income on your tax returns, this too will hurt you on rates and approval.
At the Norwalk boat show, I saw two vendors that were offering 5.75%, you may want to do a Google for that show and then bring up the vendors that were there.
The 4.99 and 5.99 rates you see for “new” boats, is either a rate that was bought down (points) or a special deal cut with that manufacture. Either way, those points are put on the “buy” price of the boat.