Boat Previews

Here's a couple of versions of my list:

1. A list of things to look for:

Exterior -

-Bottom paint condition. Any flaking?
-Props/rudders/trim tabs condition.
-Swim platform and supports, any cracks or significant corrosion?
-Portholes, any corrosion in the stainless or rust stain on the surrounding fiberglass?
-Gelcoat condition, good shine?
-Extent of hairline cracks and location. Particular attention to top of gunwales, around fill cap fittings and side decks.
-Condition of radar arch and aluminum windshield frame and paint (paint tends to peel or blister in these Tiaras particularly around the base of the radar arch and around screws in the windshield).
-Cockpit upholstery, general condition, any visible tears or significant wear? (Including the padding around the gunwales).
-Cockpit sole nonskid condition, does it feel solid, not spongy, no cracks?
-Canvas top and isinglass: Mold? Isinglass cloudy? Zippers move?
-Helm gauges, visible condition of all controls/electronics.
-Sliding door condition and adjacent transparent panel (any cracks? Does it operate easily?).
-Foredeck - any hairline cracks around hatch or windlass? Any sign of damage on the railings?

Interior -

-Woodwork, overall condition, scratches and location of these.
-Portholes, any signs of leakage (streaks)?
-Hatches, any sign of leakage?
-Headliner condition. Is is taught? Any moisture staining or any loose areas?
-Galley cabinets, condition inside and out, pics of interior of cabinets would be great.
-Countertop/burner/fridge condition. Any rust on appliances? Stains on counters? Interior of fridge?
-Settee upholstery condition, stains, tears, etc.
-Condition of fiberglass on the head, and the head fixture itself.
-Forward berth, any mold on the mattress itself (lift the cover)?
-AC unit (I don't know the location), visual condition?
-Hot water heater (I don't know the location), visual condition?

Engine Room

-Overall cleanliness.
-Any visible cracks on stringers?
-Overall exterior condition of engines, condition of paint, any paint overspray?
-Visual condition of engine hoses.
-Engine mounts, how corroded?
-Risers, condition.
-Generator, overall condition. If it has a sound shield have it opened to look at genset.
-Are fuel, water and waste tanks visible? Look clean?

2. Here is one example where I asked someone to take specific pictures for me of a bunch of stuff. After getting a few boats previewed, I sort of developed a sense of which pictures really told the story better:

1- Some close ups of portholes from the outside.

2- Some close ups of the running gear (struts, propellers, rudders)

3- A close up of the anchor pulpit from above and below.

4- Shots around the perimeter of the swim platform and of the supports below.

5- Some close ups of through hulls and fill cap fittings, please note if any spider cracking is present.

6- A close up of the Tiara logos on both sides.

7- A good shot or two of the cockpit sole.

8- A shot for each side of the bolster padding, close enough to see condition.

9- As many close up shots all around the exterior of the windshield as you can, close enough to see the screws. (Please note and photograph blistering or chipping paint)

10- Shots of and through the isinglass, and a photo of the canvas top from above and below.

11- An individual shot of each seat in the cockpit, and of the wetbar.

12- A close up of each of the two arms that open the center windshield panel.

13- A couple of good clear shots of the cabin headliner.

14- A close up of the port holes and the hatch on the inside.

15- A good close up shot of the cabin sole.

16- A shot of the interior of the hanging closet.

17- A close up of each of the two the settee seats.

18- A shot of the water heater.

19- A good close up shot of the galley cabinets.

20- A shot of the interior or the fridge.

21- A real close up of the head showing the mounting fasteners.

22- A good general shot of each engine.

23- A shot of each side of each engine so I can see all four risers.

24- A close up of the fuel water separator.

25- A close up of each engine mount.
 
"Now what happens in future when somebody joins up to get previews of a bazillion cheap boats all over the country because it doesn’t cost him anything?"

Remember this is voluntary .. you are under no obligation to do it.
 
If this service is going to be for Anchored ROs, then can Les make a Boat Preview section in the forum where only Anchors can see? Then maybe move this thread there?

Shel
 
Shel,
Nice job on the template...

Ernesto, nice list...
 
Shel,

Got your email...good job...

Since everyone that has chimed in on this is anchored and we all seem to agree that it would be a good benefit for anchored RO's, anyone object to moving it to NBR for further discussion there?
 
Leave this thread here, but continue the discussion on a new anchored RO only section. That way nonanchored ROs who read this and want more info might consider coughing up the $20 for an anchor!
 
I personally think it is time for Les to chime in. Of course, he likes to watch the threads sometimes to get the pulse of the group. I vote for moving this to NBR, then deciding "if" and how to proceed.

Ken
 
Hello All,

I thought you might like a "non-anchored" perspective on this.

As I understood it, this site is for the education of and help for the boating community in general. If I was a daily viewer/contributor, I would buy an anchor.

If you don't want to offer help to non-anchored viewers, why don't you make the entire site by subscription only?

I can understand that you don't want a million people sending ro's around kicking tires, but I seriously doubt that would be the case. And I can't think of one other reason to exclude the majority of viewers from this tool. Not only that, but what would keep another casual browser from simply asking the question "Can someone in the area go take a look at a boat for me?". I would certainly do it for any boat in my area.

I'm not in the market for a new boat, so I have nothing to gain. It's just my opinion.

Rich
 
Rich, thanks for your valuable input! I hope you come to visit us more often........

Cheers and happy boating!
 
That’s a great list, even be useful as a check list to guide your surveyor but for a voluntary look at a boat it is pretty demanding. I am not saying it isn’t desirable but there is a lot more there than I expected. I think the idea of a local person having a look is great because from personal experience remote boats always sound great but I could usually tell while walking down the dock if I really wanted to get aboard for further look. Experienced folks can look over a boat open the hatches and point out visible deficiencies in a reasonable amount of time but following such a list would be a time consuming project.

Briefly looking at Erns new boat most experienced folks would see a quality well maintained vessel with in the first five minutes and that’s what he needed to know before proceeding with more discovery. Much more detail than that is merely to validate the initial conclusion and the purview of survey IMO.

I expected something along the lines of more general guidelines general such as:
Look at engine room and take pix from several positions and report on engines, transmissions, drive trains, stringers, mounts, general cleanliness, rust corrosion, unsupported wires, hoses batteries etc.
Look at top, sides and deck of all cabins and report any water stains, torn or stained fabric or damaged wood or other surfaces. Take pix of all sides and damages noted.
Check all windows etc etc ete
 
I personally have no opinion as to wether or not to move this to NBR although I will admit that it (to me) makes sense to do so for the reasons stated above.
I also can be put on the list to preview in the Syracuse New York area which would include the St. Lawrence Thousand Islands area....South Eastern Lake Ontario....and the Finger Lakes.
 
putting on my fire suit. before you decide that it is only for anchored RO's.

Ernesto, and others, how many non anchored ro's offered their service. I know I have offered other RO's to look at and or keep an eye open for tiara's that are available here at tiara's home town.
 
I don't think everyone who previewed a boat for me had an anchor, so that is something to keep in mind. I don't think this should be seen as a way to discriminate or force people into buying anchors. And it shouldn't preclude from someone asking on the ATC for a preview regardless of anchor status, and getting someone to look at a boat for them for free.

From what I read, the real question here is whether it's worth standardizing a more official service, with a commitment for a very thorough preview (my list as an example), in which case it may make sense to charge a small fee, and maybe offer a discount for anchored members? But as in anchored member, frankly I wouldn't care if such discount was not provided. That shouldn't be the main issue here. But if the service is made more official, you'd need to consider that some people have the knowledge, ability and technological savvy to deliver such a preview and it may be harder for others? So such a service would need to set some minimum standard, with sample preview provided and assurance that the person previewing the boat can deliver such quality... so that the person requesting it would expect more than someone just showing up and taking 20 casual pics of the boat, and in fact would know exactly what to expect.

It seems kind of tricky but I know many members feel shy about asking for a preview, I've had to encourage a couple of people to do so, and such a service would get rid of this issue.

I know for me it was the more thorough previews that provided incredible value, but I only felt comfortable for such detail after talking to people on the phone and making sure that they were more than happy to give it their best shot, in some cases from people like Eric (shepdog) whom I know personally.

Even on the boat I'm buying, which is NOT perfect by any means, the preview was invaluable, and I ended up negotiating about 2k more on value based on it (combining a reduction in price and asking for some things to be taken care of by seller prior to closing). In fact based on the preview I went and made an offer on another vessel, but then came back to this boat. The corrosion on the engines, mainly around the mounts was worse than I thought, and some other things were discovered that helped me get a good understanding of what parts of the boat were better maintained than others.

Shep - feel free to post link to your preview site as reference, so people can see that there's a lot to be learned in a preview, and the preview of my boat revealed many issues that I plan to deal with, but were VERY NICE TO KNOW before agreeing on a purchase price, as I was able to negotiate with the seller.
 
I think we should all understand that this would be a quick "first look", and not a survey, and there should be no charge. What I would be interested in is first impression, general appearance, a few photos if possible. This would be enough to let me know if I need to go and look for myself and then have a complete survey done.
 
Pete, from my experience, a "few" photos provided no value. You can get that from the broker if you tell them exactly what you want photographed. But I wasn't planning on traveling to see the boats, because I wasn't willing to spend a couple thousand bucks on each boat I considered just to go see and find out it was not in a condition I that would consider it.

In fact this boat was previewed so well I never traveled to see it.

For people in my position, only a very thorough preview like what several RO's did for me here could help me make a decision.

They did it for free, some of them have refused to send me their mailing address so that I don't send money (or as Eric has done, has asked for my return address to return "anything beyond a thank you note"), but I definitely am in a position where I want to thank them and give them SOMETHING in return for their wonderful help. Talking to some other RO's, some people feel naturally uncomfortable asking for such help. I know if I hadn't done a few previews before, maybe I would have felt the same way?
 
If your surveyor needs this list to check against then I'd say you need a new surveyor. They'd better be doing much more than this list.

This is not a survey and no where near it. A surveyor is a professional and you are paying for a professional service.

What this guide can give a previewer is a general guide of what to look at and what to take pictures of. They probably can't do it all, and some may even feel uncomfortable doing it all, but it does help them to know what to look at. In general I'm happy to have anyone look at a boat I am thinking of buying, and if they want to use this as a guide then great! If not, then whatever they provide I would be gratefully for. There is no obligation here in the realm of a free service.

If this has the possibility to become a real paid service, well that is a different story, and adhering to some general guidelines is a good thing.

Shel
 
"If this has the possibility to become a real paid service, well that is a different story, and adhering to some general guidelines is a good thing."

If this were to become a "paid service" I could see some of the legal issues mentioned earlier in this thread.
 
Back
Top