- Joined
- Nov 21, 2002
- RO Number
- 10785
- Messages
- 215
The State Journal
Thursday
December 28, 2006
Boaters want local tax relief
Comments By PAUL GLASSER
A member of the Kentucky Marina Association says that organization plans to push for legislation that will provide relief to boating enthusiasts who face collection of state property back taxes.
The state tax itself is reasonable and not an issue, says Bill Gary IV, vice-president of operations at Green Turtle Bay Marina. "But, additional local option taxes are being heaped upon property people have already paid sales tax on."
Gary said the issue is the local option taxes, which have been assessed Franklin County is one in addition to the state property tax. He said boaters are economic stimulants that already provide revenue through sales and room taxes.
"If you punish them for doing business with you, then theyre going to start their motors and go across the river," Gary said.
Green Turtle Bay is only 30 miles up the Cumberland River from Tennessee, and Gary says it would be easy for boaters to moor their watercraft there, because there are no state property taxes on boats there or in other states.
"Its a very viable option, because the local option taxes are only being affected in Kentucky," he told The State Journal.
The marina association will work with legislators and tourism experts to push for legislation that would eliminate the local option taxes, Gary said.
"To rectify it, we simply need to amend the state statute," he said. "Its a local issue, but affects boaters all across the state."
Jill Midkiff, spokesperson for the Kentucky Finance and Administration Cabinet, said the taxes affect boats that are registered and documented by the Coast Guard. Taxes are assessed against boats that are more than 25 feet long and weigh more than 5 tons. The state tax rate is 1.5 cents per $100 in value, and would only bring in about $45,000 to the department of revenue.
"The state portion is very small, and the majority goes to local options," Midkiff said.
She said the taxes have always been owed, but they have not been assessed because it has been difficult to identify and locate boat owners. Now, Midkiff said, the Coast Guard shares information with the state and has helped identify boat owners. In the past, some boaters have paid the taxes voluntarily, Midkiff said.
"Its not a new tax," she said.
The state has the right to collect taxes as far back as 2001, but the current tax bills only include last year. Midkiff said there has not been a decision on how many years the state will try and collect taxes.
She said there have already been numerous appeals and protests filed by boaters who say the state has over-estimated the assessed value of their watercraft. Other boaters have claimed they are exempt from the taxes because their boats are documented by the Coast Guard. Midkiff said that is a misinterpretation there is no exemption and that local option rates are set by the local fiscal court.
County Clerk Guy Zeigler said owners of documented boats receive a reduction on their state property tax, but must pay it. The normal rate is 45 cents per $100, and the reduced rate is 1.5 cents. However, he said Franklin County has a rate of about 95 cents per $100, in addition to the state tax.
The local option tax includes 52 cents per $100 in value for Franklin County schools, 4 cents for the Franklin County Health Department, 17 cents for the Paul Sawyier Public Library, and 2 cents for the county cooperative extension program. The tax rate for homes in Franklin County is approximately 93 cents per $100 in value.
Zeigler said the issue is not significant in Franklin County because there arent many documented boats on the Kentucky River.
"Its not a lot of money for Franklin County," he said. "Its not a significant cash flow."
The taxes are supposed to be included with a tangible personal property tax return. The returns are filed with the property value administrator, but Zeigler said he cannot recall any taxes being collected on documented boats in Franklin County recently.
"I think it sort of fell through the cracks," he said.
Rodney Simpson is vice-commodore of the Frankfort Boat Club and has been boating all his life. He said he is concerned that the taxes could deter people from boating in Kentucky.
"I think it will cause some people to question their hobby," Simpson said. "For some of the larger boats, I can only imagine what their tax bills will be."
The taxes could also force boaters out of Kentucky, because the taxes are assessed based on where the boats are moored. If they are moored in Indiana, Ohio or Tennessee, they wont pay any taxes. Some boaters might stay away after they leave because they dont want to travel all the way back to Cumberland Lake or the Kentucky River.
"That may be one option for local boaters," Simpson said.
Simpson has two boats, and has filed appeals on his state tax bills for 2005. In November, he received a notice of dues and penalties for approximately $450 on his 39 ft. Marinette cruiser. Simpson said he also owed about $250 on his 35 ft. Sea Ray cruiser.
"I was surprised to get the bill," Simpson said.
He said nobody likes taxes and he has filed an appeal contesting the value of his two boats. When he bought his boats several years ago, Simpson said the clerks at the courthouse told him documented boats were exempt from property taxes. The federal government can seize documented boats during an emergency.
"I assumed, under those circumstances, tax exemption is a reward," Simpson said. "We pay taxes until we die."
Thursday
December 28, 2006
Boaters want local tax relief
Comments By PAUL GLASSER
A member of the Kentucky Marina Association says that organization plans to push for legislation that will provide relief to boating enthusiasts who face collection of state property back taxes.
The state tax itself is reasonable and not an issue, says Bill Gary IV, vice-president of operations at Green Turtle Bay Marina. "But, additional local option taxes are being heaped upon property people have already paid sales tax on."
Gary said the issue is the local option taxes, which have been assessed Franklin County is one in addition to the state property tax. He said boaters are economic stimulants that already provide revenue through sales and room taxes.
"If you punish them for doing business with you, then theyre going to start their motors and go across the river," Gary said.
Green Turtle Bay is only 30 miles up the Cumberland River from Tennessee, and Gary says it would be easy for boaters to moor their watercraft there, because there are no state property taxes on boats there or in other states.
"Its a very viable option, because the local option taxes are only being affected in Kentucky," he told The State Journal.
The marina association will work with legislators and tourism experts to push for legislation that would eliminate the local option taxes, Gary said.
"To rectify it, we simply need to amend the state statute," he said. "Its a local issue, but affects boaters all across the state."
Jill Midkiff, spokesperson for the Kentucky Finance and Administration Cabinet, said the taxes affect boats that are registered and documented by the Coast Guard. Taxes are assessed against boats that are more than 25 feet long and weigh more than 5 tons. The state tax rate is 1.5 cents per $100 in value, and would only bring in about $45,000 to the department of revenue.
"The state portion is very small, and the majority goes to local options," Midkiff said.
She said the taxes have always been owed, but they have not been assessed because it has been difficult to identify and locate boat owners. Now, Midkiff said, the Coast Guard shares information with the state and has helped identify boat owners. In the past, some boaters have paid the taxes voluntarily, Midkiff said.
"Its not a new tax," she said.
The state has the right to collect taxes as far back as 2001, but the current tax bills only include last year. Midkiff said there has not been a decision on how many years the state will try and collect taxes.
She said there have already been numerous appeals and protests filed by boaters who say the state has over-estimated the assessed value of their watercraft. Other boaters have claimed they are exempt from the taxes because their boats are documented by the Coast Guard. Midkiff said that is a misinterpretation there is no exemption and that local option rates are set by the local fiscal court.
County Clerk Guy Zeigler said owners of documented boats receive a reduction on their state property tax, but must pay it. The normal rate is 45 cents per $100, and the reduced rate is 1.5 cents. However, he said Franklin County has a rate of about 95 cents per $100, in addition to the state tax.
The local option tax includes 52 cents per $100 in value for Franklin County schools, 4 cents for the Franklin County Health Department, 17 cents for the Paul Sawyier Public Library, and 2 cents for the county cooperative extension program. The tax rate for homes in Franklin County is approximately 93 cents per $100 in value.
Zeigler said the issue is not significant in Franklin County because there arent many documented boats on the Kentucky River.
"Its not a lot of money for Franklin County," he said. "Its not a significant cash flow."
The taxes are supposed to be included with a tangible personal property tax return. The returns are filed with the property value administrator, but Zeigler said he cannot recall any taxes being collected on documented boats in Franklin County recently.
"I think it sort of fell through the cracks," he said.
Rodney Simpson is vice-commodore of the Frankfort Boat Club and has been boating all his life. He said he is concerned that the taxes could deter people from boating in Kentucky.
"I think it will cause some people to question their hobby," Simpson said. "For some of the larger boats, I can only imagine what their tax bills will be."
The taxes could also force boaters out of Kentucky, because the taxes are assessed based on where the boats are moored. If they are moored in Indiana, Ohio or Tennessee, they wont pay any taxes. Some boaters might stay away after they leave because they dont want to travel all the way back to Cumberland Lake or the Kentucky River.
"That may be one option for local boaters," Simpson said.
Simpson has two boats, and has filed appeals on his state tax bills for 2005. In November, he received a notice of dues and penalties for approximately $450 on his 39 ft. Marinette cruiser. Simpson said he also owed about $250 on his 35 ft. Sea Ray cruiser.
"I was surprised to get the bill," Simpson said.
He said nobody likes taxes and he has filed an appeal contesting the value of his two boats. When he bought his boats several years ago, Simpson said the clerks at the courthouse told him documented boats were exempt from property taxes. The federal government can seize documented boats during an emergency.
"I assumed, under those circumstances, tax exemption is a reward," Simpson said. "We pay taxes until we die."