Buy, Sell, Wait....

Greg Schoenberg

Member
exMember
Joined
Feb 19, 2006
RO Number
20280
Messages
444
We intend to buy a new or newer Ranger 25 foot tug this Fall. However, this purchase is conditioned on selling our 1982 30 foot Carver. 18 months ago, we paid $32,500 for it and through summer charter income, we were able to put thousands into it by way of repairs and upgrades. Our firm price is 35k for this turn key boat.

It's on Craigslist and so far, not a nibble, which doesn't surprise me. My questions are these. Should we wait until this Spring or even next year to get this price, enjoying it in the meantime? Will we ever get this price for a twin gasser? If we wait, is it likely that Ranger prices will rise, thus negating any profit by waiting. To those who have boated through all kinds of economic times, I humbly await your advice.

Thanks in advance.

-Greg
 
Supply and demand likely prevail. Any benefit dollar wise will probably not be in your favor by waiting for the market to come back if you're adding cash to the deal. It's a buyers market, recommend you take your losses on your current boat if it is what keeps you from moving up
 
The problem is that the market has softened considerably for used boats. If you paid $32,000 for it, just maintaining it and upgrading it still isn't going to bring $32,000 again 18 months later. It's a great time to buy a boat, but you take it in the shorts on the selling end. Do a search for similar boats online and that should give you a range. The lower end is usually the boats in Florida or down south where they boat year around and the sun takes it's toll. The upper end of the range represents the northern freshwater boats that are out of the sun 7 months of the year. In our neck of the woods, you can get the upper end if it's well kept, has new canvas, new engines or low hour engines and the upholstery and carpet are in good shape. Those assume it passes the survey with flying colors.

We bought our 30 foot Sea Ray last fall and paid almost $40,000 for it. There is a boat just like it in Hope, ID for $29,000. Both had trailers too.
 
Greg-you might try putting it on ebay, it may not sell right away but it will get a lot of exposure. The market is very soft right now. You may just want to keep the boat for a while.
 
We put our 1988 Carver 3257, another turn-key and well maintained boat, on the market in mid-summer 2005 for $40K. 18 months later it finally sold for $32K. Carvers are quite popular on the Chesapeake Bay, the market was not in the tank then and gas prices were not as bad as they are now. I say all this just as way of giving you our experience pricing an older boat. I wish you the best of luck selling your Carver but it appears you may have priced it in a manner that few, if anyone, will give it a look.
 
What are you basing your 35K firm price on? A quick scan of yachtworld would indicate that your price is high vis-a-vis the year and make. You do not indicate what the "thousands" of repairs and upgrades are, so it is tough to say what % you are looking to get back on those.

Are you disclosing that she was a former charter boat? One person's view on repairs and upgrades may translate to another's view of - 'charter boat that has been abused'.

Does your add indicate that your price is firm? If so, this may detract potential buyers. For example, they see a firm price on a boat already priced over market, usually indicates one thing - upside down seller.

Waiting will not net you the 35K, with each passing day, everything is aging and depreciating on that boat.

If you really want to sell it, price it accordingly against similar Carvers of that vintage on the market.
 
New fiberglass boat prices are not going to go down. FRP hulls are made from oil related products. High oil prices makes high plastics prices. Same with the copper and wood prices, they are going up, never falling.
I wouldn't list it only on one place.
On Ebay, you will get people from all over the world to see it.
On Craigs List, mostly people in your area will look at it.
 
FWIW--Had a new Rosborough RF246 on order. Had to sell the 1986 superberbly maintained and upgraded Searay 340 Sedan Bridge for about one half "blue book"price. At least this way we avoided the expense of possibly another year of winterizing,storage, spring commissioning, dockage and insurance.Sold on Craigslist.
Good luck,
Ron
 
I am not sure if your state has full disclosure laws on the sale of cars, boats and homes. The fact that the boat was in a charter fleet will further depreciate the value. Prices for used medium to large gassers have taken a large hit one that I don't think will ever recover.
Good luck.
Bill
 
I wouldn't expect to get any money spent on repairs back. Upgrades? That's a crapshoot. Your're asking top dollar for a boat that was chartered. REgardless of condition now, that would be a deal breaker for a lot of prospective buyers. When Hertz sells their cars, that don't sell for retail $.
 
I'd say try 1 more year of your asking price. Start advertising it early or just keep the ad going throughout. I had a 1982 29' Phoenix sportfish for sale 2 seasons ago. I started the ad a little late the first year, and it didn't sell. The next year I started the ad much earlier and got many more bites. It sold at the beginning of this season and I got just below my asking price so I was happy. With boats being a luxury/recreational item there's more of the emotional element to it. All it takes is 1 person who just happens to want the boat you have for sale. In my case, the guy knew the Phoenix sportfish, wanted it and there weren't many for sale in this area. If you can wait, I'd say try it for 1 more year. You never know.
 
Wow! What a thread full of intricate knowlege. I'm impressed.
I was going to say simply, that you'll never get all you want out of your boat.
Fuel prices are really not a factor if the buyer has the money for the boat.
If you are truely done with the Boat, if your sure, then the best idea, to my mind, is sell it for what you can get out of it and be done with it.
Be sure to advertise it in Alaska. They are still buying boats like yours for Charter up there.

Ernesto made a good speech on selling a boat. It's only two or three pages back on ATC. Find it, he has a lot of real good advice in that letter.
 
you never get your money back with upgrades... some if you're lucky like 0.25 on the dollars. but the bareboat charter history offsets that.

saying that fiberglass boats aren't going to go down in value because of oil prices is wishful thinking in my opinion... yes resin is going up, along with most supplies but boat building is still labor intensive diluting resin prices.

35k sounds on the high side for a 26 year old carver/30 footer.

did you post it here in the classifieds? with pictures? if you do, i'll mention it on the liveaboard forum, there are always people looking for cheap aft cabins in the PNW... who knows...
 
Wow. Excellent advice. I'm going to remove the part of charter income in the Craigslist ad, simply because it's not relevent. We're only talking about 4-6 weeks a year. There has been no damage or significant wear because of it. The charter company has high standards for it's fleet.
It's a better boat because of the charter.

I'll try E-Bay along with CraigsList. I'm not trying to recoup $$ for upgrades. The boat is truly in pristine condition and it's a fair price. Comparing it to old, poorly maintained Carvers is not a fair comparison. Furthermore, I'm in no hurry to sell it. We use it alot for winter cruising here in Puget Sound and I look forward to using it again this winter and spring, if the market dictates.

Pascal, please do mention it in the liveaboard. The cabin room is what we'll miss most about it. This model looks like a yacht....not a house on a hull, like some Carver models.

Thanks to all!

-Greg
 
This question was asked on another list--and I will respond here as I responded there. A yacht broker on that other list, gave the selling prices of 1980 thru 1982 30 foot Carvers (was not model specific) and there was only one which sold for $35K. The second on the list sold for $33K and was a boat which I had owned about 6 years go It was a diesel and had a 2.5 foot hull extension, instead of gas, and had been completely redone--new headliner, new carpets, new cabinet doors, new upholustary etc. The range of 30 foot Carvers was from $17K up. I suspect that the 17K were a different model. Greg's boat is an Aft Cabin--which is probably most most roomy boat in the 30 foot range. There are two staterooms, a stall shower, a nice main saloon, with lower helm, and separate galley down. It is a wonderful layout. But, the outside "living" area is somewhat restricted. A lot of boat for the money--also aluminum tanks, and a well built boat.

But that does not negate the problem with the market. This is a bad time of the year to sell, in the PNW. To sell, the price has to be spetacular or there is something which makes people really want that specific boat. The gas 30 Carvers are often run at displacement speeds because of the fuel consumption--and that is a problem in the current boating market. (We spent 2 months boating in Greg's area--and the general impression was that cruising was 50% or more down--less boats, and shorter trips.)

The economy has to improve before people will start buying boats again. Not sure how will the market will return for boats used for cruising.
 
Construction product prices go up, end product go up. It's a fact of life.
As much FRP as there is in boats, it has to bring the price up.
Same with labor. Oil prices go up, cost of living goes up, labor goes up(except maybe in some sweatshop countries).
New boats will not go down. Same boat next year may be a higher price.
The builders are not going to pay less for labor to cover the cost
of building products.
 
Boats in my area are selling 30-40% below asking prices if they can even get an offer. The market is extremely soft far older boats.
 
Fastest way to make a buck is let other guy make one too... I'd turn it over to broker and be willing to adjust the price until it sells. The price on the new boat will be going up; while your fighting seasonal issues and depreciation on your old boat. IMO you'll never see the money you put in it. Sell it, move on.
 
Back
Top