Cabbage Key hamburger report

RonF

Member
exMember
Joined
Jul 8, 2004
RO Number
14220
Messages
55
The beginning of this story is in the Florida west coast cruising question thread.

We stopped at Cabbage Key last Friday, on the trip from Tween Waters to Palm Island marina. It was a gray and windy day, few people at Cabbage key. We walked the trails in a sprinkle, then went into the restaurant.

I noticed that the menu stated that all burgers are cooked to medium. This is usually a show-stopper for me, but my wife and I pressed on in the name of research. Being a slow day, the waitress said she would ask the chef to make them medium rare. They still came with no pink in the center. However they tasted OK, and we liked the potato salad and cole slaw. There were some other things on the menu, but nothing we would go back for. I got a good picture of the "shower with a friend" sign, but I'm on a dial-up connection so maybe I will post it from the next place.

Monday we are having a stuck thermostat replaced on the stbd engine, then moving on up to Marina Jack in Sarasota.
 
In sarasota there are lots of opportunities for exercising the wife’s credit card at St. Armand’s circle. Just a cheap bus ride west any day except Sunday.
Ringling museum is worth a visit. Looks to me to be modeled on the Louvre same old pictures of old rich folks in fancy clothes too. Ringling was criticized for buying third rate art but, having been to both museums, it looks the same to me.
 
quote:

Originally posted by RonF

I noticed that the menu stated that all burgers are cooked to medium. This is usually a show-stopper for me, but my wife and I pressed on in the name of research. Being a slow day, the waitress said she would ask the chef to make them medium rare. They still came with no pink in the center.





Florida statutes require restaurants to cook hamburger to an internal temperature of 165 degrees.
 
Not being all that astute on the Least coast Geography, I thougt this thread was about some dish named Cabbage Key Hamburgers!
 
Thud:
Depending on your viewpoint Cabbage key is either a small , swampy, mosquito infested island with an old cracker shack held together by termites that serves bad beer and bad hamburgers OR number 307 on the list of official locations that Jimmy Buffet had in mind when he wrote cheeseburger in paradise. Your pick.
 
I can honestly say that the beer is good, my wife said they make some kind of good
tropical drink and the hamburgers are just o.k., I didn't care for the tater salad.
However, the late night dinners are great.
The views from the old wooden water tower are pretty good too.
The water at the shower shack is a little salty. Not fresh. What ever you do, do not
fill your water tank with water from Cabbage Key.
 
gripe about the food all you want, you could be stranded on a sandbar called north Texas waiting for this wind and cool front to blow on through.

I'll take a bad burger and watery beer at Cabbage Key any day over sitting here in my office in Plano.
 
The beer was not watered down, just expensive.
 
Strictly my own opinion, but after several weeks on a tug or service vessel, ANY cheeseburger IS Paradise.
 
Wille you need a better cook on that tug and don't let him/her buy that salt cow beef they sell in the local markets near boat docks. You are correct the phrase is "Cheese Burger is Paradise." On my boats, Friday nite is seafood night (Seafood Gumbo, Shrimp, Oysters, Soft Shells, sometimes boiled crabs, Baked, Grilled or Fried FRESH Fish), Saturday Lunch is charcoal grilled, hand pressed, 1/2 pound burgers, cheese if you like and Saturday nite is Steak Night (Hand Cut Rib-Eyes) we severe them rare.
 
Cabbage key is part of our cruise history now. We just arrived this afternoon at Marina Jack in sarasota.
 
Sorry Keith but I don't get to choose the cook... (salt beef would be heaven compared to some of the stuff the company puts aboard).

You guys should love Marina Jacks, but if you want to sleep get as far out in the anchorage as you can!
 
Cabbage key is a great tourist trap. But the atmosphere is great, nothing beats sitting on that hill drinking a cold beer watching folks pull up. Its a great stop especially if you have family or friends in town. Waiter had told me the reason why the burgers are only at medium is because when they get 200-300 folks show up at lunch they have to bang them out. We have rented cottages, rooms at the INN and always had a good experience. The Dinners have a limited menu but are great. The island has great history, nature walk, water tower with a great view. Dont let folks bitching about the food or price stop you from visiting
PS Jimmy Buffett did not write Cheesburger in Paradise about Cabbage Key
 
quote:


You guys should love Marina Jacks, but if you want to sleep get as far out in the anchorage as you can!






Good point. We're on the transient dock, three slips away from the lounge with live music. Nevertheless, we sleep pretty well on the boat.
 
Hey RonF,
Were you and your wife at Rum Bay Sunday morning for the Sunday Brunch? If so we chatted awhile about Tween Waters and Cabbage Key! Glad you made it to Marina Jacks!
O'learys has great fried egg bagals, and you can't go wrong with a burger at the Sports Page. I really like the Italian Deli just past the Sports Page on the left. You should be well protected from the n/w winds! Have a great trip!Oh by the way I agree with pdcat! Jimmy Buffett must of been at sea for quite awhile to be inspred by that burger! and the beer has always been worm and expensive! Aqua, Don't you believe in legends at sea? haha
 
You can only get to Cabbage Key by boat. It has a Marina/docks.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Tiki Time

Hey RonF,
Were you and your wife at Rum Bay Sunday morning for the Sunday Brunch? If so we chatted awhile about Tween Waters and Cabbage Key! Glad you made it to Marina Jacks!
O'learys has great fried egg bagals, and you can't go wrong with a burger at the Sports Page. I really like the Italian Deli just past the Sports Page on the left. You should be well protected from the n/w winds! Have a great trip!Oh by the way I agree with pdcat! Jimmy Buffett must of been at sea for quite awhile to be inspred by that burger! and the beer has always been worm and expensive! Aqua, Don't you believe in legends at sea? haha






Yes. Nice to meet you. Everywhere we go, we meet the nicest people. Later on, we rented a golf cart and went over to Stump Pass for shelling and swimming.

Today we walked up Main St in Sarasota. We don't eat out that much, mostly cook on-board. O'Learys menu looked like good bar food, we'll probably go there for dinner one day. Hard to pick from the huge array of restaurants, but we tend to keep it simple.

Friday we are moving to Bradenton Beach marina for a couple of days, then start the return trip.
 
Back
Top