Calling all WiFi guru's

jrpar

Member
Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2003
RO Number
11343
Messages
374
Marina has provided free WiFi, but the location of my slip and other factors frequently lower the connection speed or drop completely.

I'm using the built-in NIC on my T60p and was wondering if there was any suggestions that would boost the reliablity of the connection. Antenna? Repeater? etc.

This will be a short term solution. Once the cashflow situation eases a bit, I'll turn back on the cable ISP and again have full broadband onboard.

John
 
Anything you can do to increase antenna size will be an improvement. Installing an external antenna outside of the boat will improve reception even more. Adding and amplifier to the mix further will increase your reception. I prefer a good 12dB marine grade antenna and a 1-watt amp. However, since you mention budget issues, you could start with something like these from Hawking Technologies:

http://www.hawkingtech.com/products/index.php?CatID=32&FamID=60

They should be priced starting around $40. Although, you'll have the best luck if you can get the antenna on the outside of your boat.
 
Don't expect too much. You're probably at the limit of the range of the access point. Adding an antenna won't help very much. The only real way to make your connection better is to boost the power of the transmitter. Adding an antenna to your end will allow slightly better reception from lower in the cabin, but wi-fi is a two-way street. You could try it, but don't expect amazing results.
 
Oh... BTW... Shakespeare makes 1" 14-thread marine wi-fi antennas. Boatfix sells them.
 
Do some testing with your laptop.
Does it work when you are outside the boat?
Does it work 1/2 way between the boat and the router? 1/4?, 1/8th?
If it doesn't work at 1/2 the distance then I doubt that
a standard usb wifi with an extension cord would work
Determining the distance will set the gain that any antenna might need to provide.
Look around and see if someone else has something that is working.
 
BiilyIII is the pro, wait for him to chime in, he sent me some equipment (actually a ton of equipment)just playing with what he sent me to see what best fits my needs.

External antenna is a must, booster is a must. I went from 1 or 2 bars of service to 6 bars.

Walter

Walter
 
I don't agree with Tom. Adding an external antenna and a booster will improve reception and transmission. We'll see if Bill backs me up, because as Walter said, Bill's the pro.
 
Bill is the pro, and yes Kurt, he will back you up because this is what he told me to do and gave me the equipment. Billy's company are the people that set up these WIFI hot spots for the major carriers.

Billy is really into it, and knows his sh$t, I say that a a technical person in a simalar industry.

Wait for Billy to chime in.
 
Adding a directional, external antenna is key. If this antenna is connected via a length of cable, then the gain of the antenna may be less than the loss of signal going thru the cable. In other words going with a 6db gain antenna and losing 8db thru the cable may not help things. Where it will help is when additional signal strength is gained by placing the external antenna at a better location. With a net loss of -2db going from the PC to the antenna, if the antenna is now at a location where it is receiving a signal +6db greater; the net gain will be 4db.
At 2.4 GHz the loss of signal thru cable is significant; even more so if small diameter cable is used. Keep cable runs as short as possible and use the biggest cable as practical.
 
Kurt you are 100% correct. I have tested every system. Walter has a version of the 5 mile WiFi it failed him like it failed me within 15 minutes of operation. Adding a good system which consists of an 10-12dbi omni along with at a minimum 400 mw's of power will do for most boaters. I prefer like Kurt 1 watt and then you can do miles. There are other APs sure when I bring up my WiFi Syrens roster list on my Syrens High Power unit I bring up no less than 30 AP's many open and many closed networks. I am able to access all but the 1 bar APs with decent speed. I also install only Syrens marina APs with 120 degree sector antennas when I combine my boats system with the marina's 5 to 6 miles is a walk in the park over water. Keep in mind the amplifiers are bi-directional meaning they increase receive performance. Now lets talk about directional antennas they can be very handy when you know where the AP is located but not practical unless your not moving and a pain in the butt when it's raining outside to change it's direction when the boat swings. The radome enclosed Yagi or directional panel antenna can give you gain and rejection from other unwanted sites but for me they are my least favorite antenna. The Marina Access Point should have a sectorized directional antenna with some down-tilt. Walter went from having barely usuable signals to solid signals with a very basic Syrens 600mw unit. Good equipment on a boat for WiFi requires a receiver that will pick up a signal at -93dbm minimum. My unit will go all the way to -110dbm and still have decent data rates. You might also want to see what channel your marina's WiFi is on. If it is on channel 6 have it changed. This is the default channel for most AP's. I run my AP's on channel 3 and 9 usually eliminating dealing with other annoying APs that can cause data collisions (commonly known as unnamed Liksys). Your best bet is to use a unit that identifies itself to the Acces Point and connects to the AP by MAC address. Now a bit about cable anything over 5 feet I recommend LMR400 OR possibly LMR340 if it is less than 12 feet. My set up is a 10dbi Omni on the hardtop 3 feet away under the hardtop is my Syrens 1 watt unit I do not use POE (Power over Ethernet) but a solid high current 12 volt DC directly to the unit. While my unit has a rebroadcast card I disable it and run a CAT5 to a switch in the boat. I can also hook up a low power 0dbm 1 mw AP/switch for distribution in the ship without ruining the main units receiver sensativity. Also program it at least 3 channels away from your main unit on the hardtop. I have been using this system for 2 years and I have never been in a situation where I have not had usable WiFi signal while on the Jersey ICW. My best distance at 11mbs was at 9 miles. Syrems 1 watt units were used at both ends. Unlike houses with WiFi on the water there is open line of site AP's house based units generally are 20dbm or 100mw and have the buildings attenuation to further degrade signals. I still find many of them open and you can access them. If you want a real unit I recommend the GeoSatSolutions (Syrens) 1 watt unit. The smaller lower end unit Walter has and does a good job as well. I just don't like that system because it needs to be mounted in a NEMA box (weather proofed) or you need to run thick LMR400 to the Omni. I also had Walter test a 12db gain small suction cup mount inside antenna on his Syrens Lite unit I think he had good results with that as well. So there is hope by the way the reason I like the Syrens unit so much is the interface program. Even a child or a person with almost no WiFi experiance can use it. By the way the older Engenius 400mw (3220) unit can have its firmware changed by Syrens to use the Syrens/Fire4You/GeoSatSolutions software.

Bill
 
Wow... Corrected, I am. (Yoda voice) However, Billy doesn't speak English. Pity. ;o)
 
quote:

Originally posted by mandm1200

Adding a directional, external antenna is key. If this antenna is connected via a length of cable, then the gain of the antenna may be less than the loss of signal going thru the cable. In other words going with a 6db gain antenna and losing 8db thru the cable may not help things. Where it will help is when additional signal strength is gained by placing the external antenna at a better location. With a net loss of -2db going from the PC to the antenna, if the antenna is now at a location where it is receiving a signal +6db greater; the net gain will be 4db.
At 2.4 GHz the loss of signal thru cable is significant; even more so if small diameter cable is used. Keep cable runs as short as possible and use the biggest cable as practical.






I agree with you on the cable loss, but I think an omni works better on a boat. Granted, point-to-point a directional is without a doubt better. But if you're going to go to the trouble to put a system on a boat, why install it for just one location. An omni will allow it to work at anchor or at another marina where the AP (access point) is 180 degrees different from one's home slip.

Again, not that you're wrong (you're not), it's just a matter of various applications.
 
Thanks to all who contributed.. Looks like I'm going to need to wait until I'm gainfully employed once again before putting in a good system (at which time I'll call upon y'all once again).

BTW.. Thanks Bill for confirming my opinion of the Syrens equipment. I'll just wait for a bit and do it right...
 
Billy,
I actually now understood every thing you posted, it is sinking in, great info, thanks.

Walter
 
Kurt

The reason I would suggest a directional is that the OP was refering to his marina and I assumed he was at a slip meaning he knew where the access point was and he could take advantage of a directional antenna. Omni's are fine when you have no idea where the signal is coming from. From known point to known point a directional antenna is another tool in the bag to get better reception.
 
A few years ago I used my 1-watt amp and 12dB antenna almost all the time to access hotspots. Now I barely ever use them (it helped that I did a major upgrade to my marina's wifi system - just like Bill said, sectional antennas with a slight down-angle). I'm now almost always using my cell phone booster and external antenna with my Windows Mobile phone. I purchased WMWifiRouter (a $35 program) and I convert the cellular data signal into wifi inside the boat. My laptop can connect as well as any other devices onboard (like the admiral's iPod Touch). I haven't found any place on the Chesapeake Bay this system can't find a Verizon tower. And I swear when we were in the Bahamas this spring (Abacos) I had signal at every place we went - even Great Sale Cay (it cost an extra $20 for me to roam data-wise there at GSM speeds). I can't remember the last time I used my wifi booster.

Thus, to the OP, do you have a data plan on your phone? If so, you might already have your answer. If not, you may have found a solution for $30/month that you can also use in your daily life.

Other than that, you can try some of the cheaper systems like I posted earlier (no harm if you buy from some place you can return). If it's just your home slip you're talking about for now, and you can get some signal, you probably just need a little bit of a boost (and anything is going to be better than a built-in laptop antenna).
 
One point about coaxial cable loss a 2.5ghz it is extremely high. Look at it this way and this is why I recommend your boats WiFi unit be mounted as close as possible to the antenna. 10dbi is my gain my measured cable loss is 1.3db so I have a net gain of 6.7db. So you say what are you talking about Bill? Something is wrong well 1st most consumer antennas are rated in dbi or over a perfect non existant antenna dbd is not the usaual method of rating antennas by marketing people. So an antenna rated in dbi (isotropic radiator) is -2db from the real world or dbd (gain over a dipole a real world antenna). Now that explains my above equation. Also adding cable loss between your amplifier and WiFi amplifier adds noise in the receiver called noise figure like cable loss you want this to be as low as possible.
Now I'm waiting for someone to ask about a 15dbi gain omni, don't do it the additional gain will be lost when the boat rocks. To get gain out of a vertical antenna the pattern, think of it as a dognut gets squashed so if the dognut is not round enough you can see wild swings in signal level in all but dead stable calm water.
Just more of my thoughts on the topic. I am starting to work on WiMax systems I will have more to say about WiMax once it becomes a viable service as in MIMO TDD. In my opinion WiMax should be the pipeline from a WiFi AP to the internet (not DSL/Cable) then you have an existing customer base and devices (with WiFi) that those devices can realize unreal speeds. We are still really years away with this because of the economy although Baltimore has a marginal WiMax footprint. In Europe and parts of Asia they are running WiMax but the US lags behind but then again we also have LTE. I wonder who will win in the end?
Bill
 
"Also adding cable loss between your amplifier and WiFi amplifier adds noise".
Just curious here. Amplifier specs are base on a certain input. One spec is noise. Hitting the amp with lower signal will mean the signal to noise ratio will be degradated versus the specs based on an assumed input. In other words you amplify the noise as much as the signal; you can not improve it. In fact once you hit the amplifier it will add noise. All amplifiers add noise. I come from a RF background, Cable TV, where noise is just one part. CTB, composite triple beat, was the other factor but does not play a part in wifi.. My question is "How does hitting the amp with more signal than specified by the manufacture" affect the quality of the signal?
I also like the analogy of the vertical gain to a doughnut. It flattens the pattern versus a directional antenna which points the pattern in certain area.
 
Most if not all systems you can not just think of as an amplifier although it needs to be addressed. There are 2 amplifiers in a WiFi bi-directional amplifier, one is for transmitter output or the signal back to the Access Point. I'll address that 1st all WiFi systems have power control and the amplifiers have what is known as the 1db compression point. The 1db compression point is how most class A (linear amplifier assemblies) get their power output rating. Not like linear amplifier's in CB's radios forget that linear. In fact most CB linears are Class AB1 or even worse class C. I am talking about reproducing the signal that is put into the transmit amplifier with no distortion. Then the AP when it's transmiting signal level tells your WiFi card or the packaged commercial systems what power level it wants to see back. You can never overdrive the amplifiers 1db compression point because of this alogorythm and the system design circuit called ALC aka auto level control. However if you did your data rate would go to crap because digital signals need to be amplified or increased in power with the same lack of disrortion as the card or chipset driving it. Now the receieve amplifiers usually have a typical system noise figure of 4 to 5 db and the receiver in a great system like the Syrens EC-AP-HP for example will do 11mbps with an input signal of -107dbm (a very low signal level) and at -111dbm it will only do 2mbps. Here is the beauty of a good system remember I said "system" and the bi-directional amplifier is only part of it. Good bi-directional amplifiers use a GaAsFet front end device which in itself at 2.5ghz probably has a noise figure of .5db to .9db. The added noise is in the switching and stages that proceed the 1st device but the lower the initial stage noise figure the receiver has the ability to pick out signals at a lower noise level. Now in front of your 1st receive device you have coaxial loss also this is noise which adds. To figure out noise figure it simply adds any losses and a good design uses a GasFet instead of a MIMIC (MIMIC NF at 2.5 depending on the device is 4 to 5db of noise. Most plug in or built in cards in laptops unfortunately use a chipset that is why they generally need -70 to -80 or better for 11mbps. Also consider the signal is amplified by the antenna before losing some to the amplifier. With a standard laptop your antenna has no real gain in fact it maybe negative. Yes there is a point of diminishing return with any digital communications due to C/I (a way to measure signal over noise) but the built in chipsets used for WiFi in laptops are so poor it is not hard for an engineer to cobble a system that will outperform any laptop. Also the laptop has the additional losses when used inside a boat due to structural attenuation. Attenuation is degredation of the signal or the difference from the signal at a high mounted omni with a short low loss coaxial run to a "commercial grade system" then the system converts the signal to data and is transmitted to the CAT5 connection on the computer or a switch for optimum results. Adding a small WiFi/router will be fine because properly set up the wired or wireless router will have the power set low and rebroadcast set 3 channels away. This will give your built in laptops WiFi chipset all the signal needed for an excellent quality which in turn means fast internet access. Think of it like being 10 feet away from a Access Point that is a 1/2 mile away. It is called a link budget in the commercial world.
For examples the smaller WiFi like Walter has the receiver specifications are -89dbm for 11mbps or -93 for 2mbps speed. His transmitter is 400mw but again because he uses an external antenna with gain it will outperform any WiFi chipset in a laptop.
The smaller commercial marine grade WiFi units while still considerably better do not have the additional receiver low noise figure receiver that the HP (high performance/high power) units do. They also because of the algorythm used for power control in the HP units can effectively generate 3 to 5db additional output power before the antenna adds it's gain. In essence the good marine WiFi units make up for the path losses on both the transmit and receive sides and are generally kept in balance by the 802.11b& or G protocal.

There is really a lot more to this but I am trying to simplify it.
Bill
 
I always knew if we built him up enough it would go to his head....

Just kidding. Bill, were you thinking of me when you made commend of the 3220? I finally finally got it working to my satisfaction not two weeks ago. Dropped the linksys for in boat wifi distribution and replaced with something else and now I don't have collisions anymore (again you were right about that being the problem). Took me close to 2 years to get the right configuration on the Senao, but now I can do a site survey without hard resetting the unit. So....I'm terrified to think of monkeying around with the firmware. But.....hmmmmmm......do tell more. Should I really do the upgrade?

Oh...and if you think you can't pull in a signal without having super hardware on both ends, that's just not true. I have routinely pulled in signals from shore 1.5-2 miles out, holding a connection and I know I'm only hitting the generic wireless routers found at any big box store. I hit 3 miles though on a marina's high power system. My unit the senao 3220 is external 9db antenna and 400mw power. I'd love the syrens and would 2nd Bill's recomendation instead of going through all the troubleshooting I did. But since it can be had for just over a hundred bucks and I already own it, I'll keep it for now.

Bill is the dude.

"There is realy a lot more to this but I am trying to simplify it." Aint that just a peach.
 
Back
Top