Calling Bill - WIFI Issue

Ghost

Active member
Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
689
Messages
2,417
Here's the deal, I think my wifi bridge is somehow burning up wireless routers attached to it.

My setup is that I have a 9db omni antenna on the outside of my flybridge. That connects to a Senao 600mw Engenius 2611 (formerly a 3220ext). The high power bridge then runs ethernet (POE) down to my aft cabin where it plugs directly into my boat PC.

In the current setup, I therefore don't have any access via wireless to my laptop without physically uplugging the ethernet out of the boat pc and plugging that into my laptop. It has been running this way about 4 months since my last wirelsss router died.

The wireless router setup is simple. I attach the ethernet cable from the high power bridge into the wireless router, ensure they are on different channels and that's that.

My last router was a netgear. It's symptoms was an excrutiatingly slow connection speed as measured by speedtest.net. It would "act" like it was being blocked. This would occur, even when no wireless devices were attached to it (just functioning like a non-wireless router). It was at that point that I realized that this failure was essentially identical to other wifi routers over the past 4 years. (Linksys, netgear, DLink and even the cradlepoint). The cradlepoint got so non-responsive you could not even connect to it. When I go buy a new wireless router, they all work perfectly at first. I'll usually get weeks to months out of them before I notice that my connection speeds are not what they were. At some point I troubleshoot down to removing the wireless router from the system and the hard wired speeds go right back to normal. Sometimes the router is just plain dead and sometimes you can play with the configuration, but just not get it going properly.

I did not "catch on" at first that the routers themselves may not be to blame, but after the last one, its clear that "something" I'm doing is burning these things up. The only thing that seems to be common is 1.) The Antenna and 2.) the location of the antenna/bridge/router.

If you go to www.mvghost.com you can see my external antenna on the side of the flybridge just above the "Y" in the "48 MY" in the lettering on the flybridge. The bridge is under the flybridge without any extension to the antenna pigtail. The ethernet runs a long distance until it terminates in the aft cabin. If you look at the forward window of the aft cabin, you could imagine the wifi router is about 2 foot below the window in a closet.

My best guess is somehow the antenna is radiating in a pattern to get picked up by the router. I'm fishing for agreement that his might be the cause before I go buy more hardware.

The antenna I bought YEARS ago before there were dedicated players in the marine wifi antenna business. I found a site on the web and ordered a 9db antenna. It arrived looked like a bit of a home job made of pvc pipe with a sticker on the side said something like "marinewifiantenna.com" or something to that effect (I can't find what looks like the same company any more). It was made to mount directly to a standard marine vhf mount (nice). All I can say is that the antenna seems to work. To this day I can hold a connection at around 3 miles or so, depending on what I'm connecting to. When not connected just through the bridge ethernet I have fast & stable speeds.

That's as concise as i can make it. Please tell me I have an obvious problem and hopefully a simple (to understand) answer on what to do about it!

Thanks in advance.
 
I need to read and digest what you have described. I will get back to you. Probably with questions first.
I will ask one question have you tried a hard memory reset on the routers inside the boat? It's possible there is a memory stack error on the routers.
Your really not ever going to get an antenna for you bridge unit (Engenius) that will not be picked up inside the boat by it's wireless router unless you do as I always advise get an 802.11A only wireless router that works on the 5.8GHz band unlike the bridge router (Engenius) that works on the 802.11B&G 2.4GHz band.
You might also try running the inside router in "bridge" mode instead of AP mode if you can find the settings.
Bill
 
Clear the the memory or cache in the Engenius as well. Be careful there because you might have to do that through the RS232 connection on the Engenius. This why I don't like the Engenius I gave away everyone I ever used (3) so far.
Ubiquiti is coming out with GPS timed Rocket 2's. I have ordered a few you can set one as the master then the other as a slave and they negotiate transmitting and recieving via GPS timing.
Bill
 
Wow, you can't get that kind of knowledge anywhere! Impressive Billy! Very impressive.
 
****lexicon: ("Bridge router" = Outside Engenius 2611 high power bridge, "inside wireless router" = the unit that distributes the wireless signal inside the boat)

Bill, the 3220 I had to hook up the null model cable (massive pain), while simultaneously needing to have 3G coverage on my phone so I could remember the archaic commands to reset it. The new one, they put a button on (big improvement) and the software is better.

But...I don't think its the bridge router. Why? Because its the downstream inside wireless routers (I hope my taxonomy is not too confusing) that are getting killed. The upstream bridge has been fine, and clearing/resetting the bridge never solved the problem. Neither did hitting the reset buttons on the inside routers.

Just to re-iterate, right now I don't have a functioning "inside" wireless router. Well, I may have it somewhere but I'm fairly certain its a dead unit. Meaning, even if I take it home and ran it all by itself, that it would not function right. So, for the inside wireles router, I could purchase anything at this point. I'm just leery of doing so until I figure out what is quite literally baking them. Another cradlepoint might be my choice as I'm thinking about trying a t-mobile data stick around my parts to see if its worth having on the water.

Anyhow, just to clarify, if I purchase a new inside router, I will get one that is on the A mode. (I wonder if trying the "damaged" old units on the A setting would work). It sounds as if I want a wireless A ONLY inside router to avoid hardware damage. My assumption is that the A/B/G combined units might still get damaged even when running in A mode.

Too bad the cradlepoints don't look to come in an "A" unit.
 
I'm still wondering if I should change out my antenna. Even though it clearly works, I just don't recall anyone else ever comlaining here that they had a problem baking inside wireless routers. Thus I'm unique and I must therefore have a problem other people don't (something is bad).
 
I'm not saying don't replace the outside antenna on the Engenius unit, I would.
I suggest clearing the memory on the old internal routers that you are using like an Access Point. Simply removing power is probably not enough on the inside router/AP's. I am almost certain your problem will be in the router memory log not resetting like it would normally do after it reached it's max it should rewrite over top of the old saved log files.
If you have an A,B&G router set it to A only it turns off the 2.4GHz (B&G) receiver and transmitter in the inside router/AP. Also look at your NAT settings.
Bill
 
I just got an idea can you take the non working routers home plug into the your cable modem or DSL modem and then tell me if they work? You are not telling me if the routers RF path is getting lost. I have a feeling that is not your problem or you wouldn't be able to access Speedtest.com at all?
What is the signal strength showing on your laptops built in WiFi card with the old non working router/AP's?
I'm trying to figure out if you have a network problem (I leaning in that direction) or an RF problem so far it's not clear to me.
Bill
 
Bill, Thanks!

I'll be up there tomorrow and will find at least one, maybe two of the old routers. I know for a fact that the laptop signal was like 4 or 5. I had no problem connecting at all, it just would not give me an internet connection at all, or the throughput would be VERY low (like 30 minutes to load the speedtest page and not even get a chance to actually run a test most of the time).

You may be right about the network problem. Here's the thing. Wouldn't the "reset" button correct that kind of error. I mean pulling power, hitting the reset buttons and setting them up from scratch never fixed them. The other thing is that after 4 years I now realize that problems I had over multiple mfg's was "the same" (I think). When I think about multiple mfg's having similar problems I have a hard time thinking that a "configuration" issue could be to blame, especially when they all seem to work initially and for a period of time. Not saying at all you are wrong, just trying to understand and let you know where my brain is going. That's why I think "hardware" failure instead of software configuration.

Can't thank you enough for helping me thing this through.
 
The reset button or a power cycle will probably not clear this type of problem. Now I'm wondering if you have a DNS issue? Either way my guess is you are going to need to do a firmware memory reset that can only be accomplished in the set up sub menu or using Linux (possibly even having the router flashed) if it isn't in the set up menu for the router/AP. Get me some router numbers and I will look at the software/firmware config files and give you some tips.
You really just proved to me you don't have a Radio problem from the local (inside) router/AP you have a network configuration problem. I want to see this through please keep me updated and I will reply. I check the board daily.
Still it would be advantagous to have the inside router's AP on the 802.11A band only you will see improved performance from the Engenius, you probably do when your plugged directly into the Engenious even when everything used to work at it's best.
Bill
 
One really simple thing to try use a reverse CAT5 between the Engenius Bridge unit's POE (LAN side) to the inside router AP. I really don't think it could be this simple.
A couple of quick checks does your laptop have a LAN port? If so does it work when directly connected to the Engenius? Do any of the old routers have LAN ports (I assume they do)? If so plug your laptop into the LAN port on the router what happens?
When doing these tests shut off the WiFi card in the laptop.
Also are you using WPA2 with a shared key between the router and the laptop?
I would for troubleshooting purposes disable any wireless protection on the router.
Bill
 
Partially Bill. I was up at the boat this weekend and found I still had two of the wireless routers and brought them home with me to troubleshoot them. I got a chance to play with one of them last night and started the second.

Cradlepoint:

1.) Plug in mbr900, connect ethernet cable to port3 and connect to my laptop.

2.) Mbr power green light is on, flashing green on #3, antenna light is off (radio button is on).

3.) 192.168.0.1 No response.

4.) Check ipv4 properties, all set to automatic.

5.) Reset lan connection on laptop.

6.) Adapter shows 0 bytes received.

7.) Hold cradlepoint reset button for 10 seconds, 15 seconds, 20 seconds. No change in light status.

8.) Repeat #3-6, no change. Can’t connect.

9.) Plug cradlepoint into fios modem, repeat steps 1-6. No change, Can’t connect.

Conclusion: FUBAR.

Netgear wnr2000 V2

I was able to connect to the Netgear, and it looks like it can still be configured. I did not get a chance to hook it up to the modem and test the performance.

So, thus far it looks like the cradlepoint looks like a dead unit, despite the fact that it comes on and little green lights flash.

I should have more time to play with the Netgear more tonight.

One point of clarification, the engenius on the boat is/has been working fine. I just have to hard wire it to the computers that use it via ethernet.
 
http://www.cradlepoint.com/files/uploads/CradlePoint_MBR900_QSG_sm.pdf Try this on the Cradlepoint MBR900 before you give up.
Also is your power (DC) I assume clean and free of voltage spikes on the boat? This could also be toasting your routers.
Bill
 
This might help with the Netgear I do not like that it is an N router you will create your own RF interference.
http://kb.netgear.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/12190

Here is the set up help guide.
ftp://downloads.netgear.com/files/products/WNR2000v2/Documentation/UM/WNR2000v2_UM_15JAN2010.pdf
Look at page 134 resetting the default on the Netgear PDF. I would start there.

Bill
 
ftp://downloads.netgear.com/files/products/WNR2000v2/Documentation/UM/WNR2000v2_UM_15JAN2010.pdf

This is where I think you are having the problem think of the Engenius as a remote computer.
Read this section carefully.
Bill
 
I went through the cradlepoint doc last night (thanks for sending). I've formally given upon that one.

The DC on the boat should be stable (though the POE is injected from an AC source). I say should as just about everything has beeen progressively renewed, wiring & components wise (that's another post, but I am rather proud of my automatic load shedding system).

I'll likely replace the N router (even if I get it to work), now that I understand that A is a better way to go in general. But I'll still see if I can make it go, just for the sake of troubleshooting and better understanding the problem statement.

More to come...
 
I am leaning towards this if you have a network issue.

Configuring NAT Filtering
Network Address Translation (NAT) determines how the router processes inbound traffic. Secured
NAT provides a secured firewall to protect the computers on the LAN from attacks from the
Internet, but might prevent some Internet games, point-to-point applications, or multimedia
applications from functioning. Open NAT provides a much less secured firewall, but allows almost
all Internet applications to function. For more information about NAT, see “How Your Computer
Accesses a Remote Computer through Your Router” on page 5-2.
To change the NAT option:
1. In the NAT Filtering area, select either the Secured or the Open radio button.
2. Click Apply to save the new configuration
 
Ghost, I haven't heard back but I think I have found the perfect Router for connecting units like the ROGUE and Engenius it is the CradlePoint MBR500. This is if you must have a Router that does 802.11B&G because you use gaming devices or SKYPE. Otherwise a 802.11A on 5GHz would be ideal. Here is what I like about the CradlePoint 500. It had 3 ports you can use it with a cellular data express card or a USB cellular 3G/4G modem. The WAN port is where you connect either your dockside DSL, Cable router or in our case WiFi Bridge unit, in my case the ROGUE. The unit can be programmed for low, medium or high power. The low and medium power don't affect the Bridge unit's ability to pick up distant AP's even when only seperated by 10 feet as they currently are in my shop. In the connection manager you can set the WAN port to be your primary connection, if you lose the connection within 30 seconds the failover circuit kicks in and forces your cellular modem on. Once you reestablish a WiFi connection it takes another 30 seconds (the shortest time you can program the router for) to reconnect to the Wireless Bridge unit. As I suspected there is a error log and you can clear it. Programming the CradlePoint MBR500 wasn't exactly easy but with some trial and error I had it doing everything I would ever want it to do in less than an hour. I am using the Verizon ULMS290 USB Modem for my cellular connection. It will also work with most of the Srint 3G & WiMAX dongles. They the EVDO store sells the modem with the latest software for the modems and offers free upgrades as new modems appear. I didn't get into it but it also appears a cellular Smartphone with a data plan can connect through the same USB that I am using a Modem on. So for the guy's and gal's looking for an inside Router that handles cellular and an external WiFi bridge type unit this is your dream come true. It also runs like the ROGUE on either 12VDC or 110VDC. It even gives a nice blue bar display indicating the cellular signal strength.
The negatives setting the Modem up was a real PIA. The instructions were almost of no use to me. Once I was able to get into the set up menu's then I had no problem tweaking the unit to do what I wanted it to do. It also has an auto negotiate WiFi channel feature so it looks to put itself on the quietest WiFi channel. If you order a CradlePoint MBR500 make sure it has firmwware 1.8.1 pre loaded.
I hope this helps you and others.
Bill
 
One thing I learned with a similar set up, was that the small indoor router cannot drive ethernet very far. I was lucky I got 25 feet out of it. While this does not sound like your problem if they start to act up and you have a long run down to the indoor router, try moving the indoor up close to the Engenius so you can shorten the cable.
I am using a noname Air802 AP-G300 driven by POE with an 8db antenna connected via short LMR400 to an 8 db wifi antenna on the arch. Down inside, I have a Linksys WBR-2310. Currently the AP-G300 runs as a wireless client, DHCP server, connected to a LAN (yes LAN) port on the WBR. I can run the AP-G300 in bridge mode, but then I need to connect via the WAN port on the WBR and I lose addressability since it is then outside the scope of the net defined to the WBR running as the DHCP server.
This has served us well for over 4 years.

Bill if you connect that CradlePoint (CP) to the Engenius via the CP WAN port, depending on who is the DHCP server how will it be addressed?
 
Back
Top