Canadian PFD's

Captstever

Member
exMember
Joined
Dec 13, 2004
RO Number
15892
Messages
36
I have a new client that just shipped his vessel from Canada flying a Canadian Flag and port of call. In doing a safety check, I found his PFD's are all Canadian CG approved but lack the head rest and look more like ski jackets then PFDs.
Anyone know if the Canadian PFD's are recognized in the US by the CG or do I need to preplace them with US Class PFD's? I probably will anyway just because these are not as safe by US standards.
 
Canadians are more buoyant than Americans, so we don't need a head rest. More air in the head I guess. :)
 
I know that is true for the ladies of canada. Their upper bodies definitely float better :))
But I digress.
I think it almost is more a question of if a Canadian boat is cruising, in this case, South Florida, do all the USCG rules apply to a Safety Inspections (PFD's, Fire Extinguishers, Placards, etc)?
 
Are they like this?

bab3_2.JPG
 
I have posed this question to 4 USCG Station Officers in charge to get a correct answer. I will post it as soon as I get a response...
 
I have a link to a USCG publication but it is not dated and it is in my home computer.
I too have been trying to get the reciprocal rules.
Transport Canada allows US boats to enter and cruise Canadian waters for up to 90 days under US safety equipment standards but nowhere can I find the opposite agreement.
Most standards are the same except
Canada does not require oil placards and all the other placards required on US boats
Canadian boats must carry more flares than comparable sized US boat. A single flare is 2 stars. So one of the old single star shells is only half a flare for counting purposes.
Horseshoe buoys and flotation cushions don't count for anything.
A life ring is required and 50 feet of floating line.
 
I received a short note from a USCG OIC: THe life jackets should pass the board team test if they look close to the USCG approved ones. Most of the equipment will get reciprocal approval. However the US rules for stuff like overboard discharge, etc, must be adhered to.

I'm waiting for word from some other OICs to see if they concur.
 
Here is some more info from the OIC:

Thanks Eric,

Another one to pick your brains: Is there a time limit that they can cruise US waters under a Canadian registration/documentation before they must get US registration (like the 90 days states give you before you must change to the new states registration)?

Paul,
as long as they are on a Passport/Visa, they can stay as long as it allows. Typically, they run for 30 days, but they can go back to the nearest Customs arrival point or Customs office and get stamped again...depending upon the reason for their stay. For documentation or registration...I would deduce that once that expires, they become "stateless" and must abide by US Regulations and Laws as far as carriage requirements and everything.
 
Thanks Paul... that brought up the next question on my mind.... Boat is trucked in from Canada, Reassembled in South Florida. Sounds like from your note that the boat can stay in the US as long as the owner has a Visa. I wonder how it works for all the Yachts from other contries we see here in South Florida that seem like they are here forever but the owners are rarely on board.
 
US Cruising permit for foreign vessels is for 1 year. It is issued instead of a customs sticker and allows the foreign pleasure craft to change ports without checking in with the USCG each time.
It cannot be renewed without leaving US waters.

This is a pretty good summary for all boaters, US nd foreign alike as it covers all the bases.

http://www.boatmiami.com/US_Customs_Arrivals_charter_boats.htm
 
quote:

Originally posted by Shadowcruzr

I have posed this question to 4 USCG Station Officers in charge to get a correct answer. I will post it as soon as I get a response...






There was also a similar question that came up here while I was on vacation. Went right to Bethesda from vacation, so I haven't had a chance to find a specific reference for an answer (I don't like to answer without a specific cite). Having trouble even seeing the letters on the screen right now (still blurry, and MAN did the eyes hurt last night!), but when I get back home/back to work, I'll find the reference and post it. Someone remind me if I seem to forget by late next week.
 
the following is a qoutes are from the florida dept of revenue as it pertains to sales/use tax.

A boat that remains in Florida for more than 90 consecutive days or more than 183 days in a one-year period is presumed taxable, unless it qualifies for another exemption.

Foreign Flagged Vessels
Boats flying a foreign flag are exempt from Florida use tax if they have a current license to cruise issued by the U.S. Customs Service. Licenses to cruise are available only to boats flagged in countries that have a treaty with the United States. The boat will remain exempt as long as the provisions of the license to cruise are not violated.
 
Interesting discussion. I have just been looking into this from the opposite direction. My boat originated in the U.S. and I bought it in Canada. It came with 12 USCG approved life jackets. I called Transport Canada, the government body responsible for that sort of thing here, and they tell me that I need Transport Canada approved lifejackets for all on board because the US standards are not the same as Canada's for life jackets. I can only assume that they are suggesting that they are not as stringent. I can't see being required to replace something that is already better. Hard to believe either nationality would have any difficulty floating in the lifejackets that came from my boat, but my neighbour just got a $250 fine for not having the right number and size of jacket for his boat just last weekend here in Sarnia, which is an international border location. Just for the record, it was the Canadian authourities that gave him the ticket.
 
They are made by a US company but say they are a model C3a, and approved by the Canadian CG. They are more like thick ski jackets.
 
Back
Top