Carry On Generator

rnbenton

Active member
Member
Joined
Apr 4, 2009
RO Number
31163
Messages
2,834
OK, My 28 Carver Voyager has a built in 7K BTU A/C but no gen. So, I only have air when on shore power. My ER is very tight and without pulling engines There's no way to install a gen. I'll probably do this at re-build or re-power time.

In the mean time, I want to consider a carry on gen to run my AC when on the hook at night. Naturally I want one as compact as possible but large enough to handle the load and not run out of gas every hour. (if possible)My flt bridge is open so I can put it up there and eliminate any CO problems. But, there is a detector in the salon just in case.

Any of you who have experience and recommendations about make/size/etc I'd love to hear it.

A/C is a Marine Air 7000 BTU
115 volt - 60 cycles
FLA - Cool 6.8
Fan - 1.9

Thanks
 
No brainer.. Honda EU2000i.. True sine wave inverter. It will handle the load, is extremely efficient AND quiet.. Not cheap at around $1,000 but well worth it. It should run around 8 hours on a gallon of gas. Weight is around 45 lbs.
 
I have always wondered why boat owners dont just add a 120V alternator or a bigger 12V alternator with an inverter to the main engine, especially for occasional use.
 
Well, if I stop for the night on the hook would I not have to run the main engine all night? Or do I not understand the product?

quote:

Originally posted by pdecat

I have always wondered why boat owners dont just add a 120V alternator to the main engine, especially for occasional use.




 
I second the Honda EU 2000 ... works well ( but everyone here does not feel that way). My only suggestion is add at least 1 CO detector and do not run while sleeping.
 
Well, as I said above, I do have a Co detector and the gen would be up top on the fly bridge which is completely open, just a bimini top.

quote:

Originally posted by psalzer

I second the Honda EU 2000 ... works well ( but everyone here does not feel that way). My only suggestion is add at least 1 CO detector and do not run while sleeping.




 
quote:

Originally posted by pdecat

I have always wondered why boat owners dont just add a 120V alternator or a bigger 12V alternator with an inverter to the main engine, especially for occasional use.





The 120 volt alternator would be ok if someone needed power for just a few minutes. I would not want to run a 7.4L gas engine overnight. I would be more concerned about CO running the big boat engine versus a little portable generator. Inverters work fine for light loads. Even with light loads, 200-400 watts, additional batteries are required if the items needing power runs for hours and hours.
 
the other suggestion was for the 2kW honda. that too will produce CO but without the main engines better installation. In either case CO is a worry. The main engine would happily run for a zillion hours at low load without wearing out. Got to look into some numbers when I get a chance.
 
Thanks, one question; Yes, both engines will produce CO but it seems to me the small gen would produce a lot less than one of my main engines. Plus, the gen would be above everything on the fly bridge while the engine exhaust is low on the water and with a stern breeze it seems to me it would be much more likely to get into the salon and birth.

Or am I missing some consideration?

quote:

Originally posted by pdecat

the other suggestion was for the 2kW honda. that too will produce CO but without the main engines better installation. In either case CO is a worry. The main engine would happily run for a zillion hours at low load without wearing out. Got to look into some numbers when I get a chance.




 
dont know, it just seems a waste to add another engine
 
I don't want ANY gasoline engine running all night while I'm sleeping. What we do is run the A/C and get the cabin as cool as possible before going to bed, then shut dowm the Honda and use 12 V fans ... even here in Ga. it seems to stay cool enough with just the fans. Running the Honda on the bridge does not seem to be the best place ... we run it on the swim platform, some put it forward on the bow. Whatever yo do please be careful, and don't store it in any closed compartment when not in use.
 
I have an older Yamaha EF1000. The only time I use it is during the day. I would think it produces less CO than the boat engine; 7.4L (7400cc) verus 83cc. That is about 1/90th as small. Granted the little genny runs at 3600 rpm verus 700 rpm for the boat's engine. Although the boats exhast goes thru drive it bubbles up under the swim platform. It's too easy to have a stern wind blow the exhasut back onto the boat. Sleeping with any genertor, portable or marine, increases the risk of CO getting into the cabin.
 
OK, I'm not trying to be argumentative, but follow my thinking here;

1. If I put it on the swim platform it seems to me the exhaust is then down low and easier to cause a problem with a breeze on the stern blowing it forward and possibly into the salon. Plus, what about wakes? It seems easy to get a wake up over the swim platform and ruin the gen.

2. Putting it on the bow puts it right on top of the birth, next to the hatch, forward and below the fly bridge.

3. On the fly bridge puts it in the center of the boat and high above everything and completely open.

Number 3 seems to me to be the safest. But, you guys are the ones experienced with this so I'll listen to you. The only time I've used a gen in the past was my old boat which had the gen installed in the ER.

quote:

Originally posted by psalzer

I don't want ANY gasoline engine running all night while I'm sleeping. What we do is run the A/C and get the cabin as cool as possible before going to bed, then shut dowm the Honda and use 12 V fans ... even here in Ga. it seems to stay cool enough with just the fans. Running the Honda on the bridge does not seem to be the best place ... we run it on the swim platform, some put it forward on the bow. Whatever yo do please be careful, and don't store it in any closed compartment when not in use.




 
Hands down Honda EU 2000. A fraction of the Co that an on board genset produces.
Like anything else, you gotta use your head, Minimum of two CO detectors. Be aware of other boats nearby. No rafting with genset running at night etc. . .
 
hmmmm, there must be a way to work a powerpole and wake joke into this thread. <grin>
 
Get a digital Co detector. It will give you a display of what the levels are in your cabin wayyy before it reaches the danger zone. Experiment with it during the day.
I put my Honda in a plastic tub on the swim deck (cheapie from Dollar Store) no lid of course. Kept any errant waves from splashing the unit. If they get splashed the motor will continue to run, but the safety will trip the power output. My detector displays always read zero.
 
You're right. . . .there's gotta be a joke there somewhere
 
I truely thought about it but then thought better of it. Just some dogs need to be left to die. :D

(Man, this is one tough crowd)

Thanks for the input, Guys. I have a CO detector in the salon but it isn't digital. It will be changed immediately. Plus, for safety sake, I will put another one forward in the Master (and only) bedroom. :)

quote:

Originally posted by Bill D.

hmmmm, there must be a way to work a powerpole and wake joke into this thread. <grin>




 
You asked for recommendations and you got 'em. Now you have to decide what will work for you.
 
I know a lot of people who use them safely. But it just takes on time to have a bad night.
Having a CO detector close to where you lay your head and one just inside the door is your best bet.
I could never sleep down here at night without an a/c. It's over 100 in the day time and last night
it was 85 when I went to sleep. That is too hot for me.
 
Back
Top