Charter recommendations - BVI

JBN

Member
exMember
Joined
May 17, 2006
RO Number
21300
Messages
51
Change of plans....

My wife and I were all set to take my folks to Ireland for Easter. Mom wanted to visit here cousins one more time before she and Dad got too old. Well, last month Mom passed away from a heart attack, completely unexpected. We siblings are all now in a different mode, keep the old guy busy as he gets through the next few months. Like his son, my Dad is not much for travel. In his 79 years I don't think he's been south of Los Angeles. Born in Fairbanks a long time ago, he has never once swim in the ocean. He allowed as how Ireland was more of a wish for Mom, he just as soon not go. I said we had to do something, how about a tropical trip? That got his attention. So I remembered a trip some friends of ours raved about, cruising the BVI's

My wife and I have been looking into booking a crewed charter on catamaran. Many of you have answered some concerns about safety so I think that is not much to worry about as we will not be hitting the bars at all hours of the night and anchoring up in what I would assume to be pretty tame areas. Anyway, our group will include 5: ages 10, 12, 40, 46 and 79. Dad is pretty good on his feet but struggles with big swells when we're fishing. Is this something you experienced sailors would recommend? Any do's or don'ts? Any recommendations for boat and/or outfit?

Thanks, Jim.
 
No. I am concerned about Dad. However, if you do I would only consider The Moorings. They cost more and the differences appear to be small. That is until there are issues and problems. There are always issues and problems and that is where they excel. Also, I would arrive a day early and unwind at their Tortola location. I think that pays off if you have traveled any distance.
 
Definitely The Moorings. Depending on your arrival time, spend the first night aboard in slip at their Marina in Tortola.

There will not be much in the way of swells in these waters except on the northern side of the islands in the winter months. Within the Sir Francis Drake Channel you are protected, the pass up to Jost Van Dyke ditto.

Sailing the BVI is very relaxing, but make sure Dad is up for it...he need to nothing more once aboard than enjoy the beautiful scenery.

DaveS
 
We recently did a power charter out of Nanny Cay on Tortola. We chartered a trawler (48 Tarquin). For the most part the water is calm on the south side of Tortola, and the only time you will see bad water is running to Spanish Town, coming back from Jost Van Dyke or going to Jost from Virgin Gorda. That is to say we went all the way around Tortola.
A cat will probably be a stable platform for everyone.

If your dad is healthy and active, why not I say? Talk to his doctor about it tho.

But read this part carefully. On a one week charter you are at the mercy of the weather. It may be good for that week it may not. If it is not the vacation is junk and you stay tied up somewhere. Are you ready to absorb this risk? I lectured my crew with regard to this aspect and told them if I did not like the weather since I was captain, we would not move. Fortunately for us hanging out in bars is ok. Not for you tho. We were exceptionally lucky the first week of Dec. and had great weather.

We arrived in Tortola a a day early and left a day late. It's the only way to go. Don't bother chartering in the USVI and then going over to the BVI with the boat. Get customs out of the way at the airport or ferry terminal if you fly into St. Thomas! You'll kill the charter on each end if you immigrate while on charter.

Presumably you have a wife and kids with your dad. When moving down there the dink is usually towed on a long line. When approaching mooring balls, you have to haul it in. Crew will have to do this and it is somewhat strenuous. As well, someone else has to be able to handle the boat when mooring or anchoring. If you and your crew are not experienced this can ruin a relationship. Believe me. We heard numerous marriages fall apart when it came to picking up a mooring pennant. Crying, shouting, cursing. Not fun for them. So unless you are VERY comfortable with the tasks of anchoring (mooring is the only way to go down here check me on that but I am correct) or mooring perhaps you should reconsider.

Otherwise, you will have the trip of a lifetime and go on knowing you made your dad happy if he has a good time snorkeling and or just looking at some of the best water this side of heaven.

Consider longer (2 day) stops at Marina Key, Saba Rock and Jost.
 
Second what Dan said. We also chartered a power cat and had a great week. I'd recc. getting one of the few boats there that has a GPS onboard. They tell you you don't need it, but it was a lifesaver for me. Tossed the anchor to snorkel with only one other boat there. Guess I got there early. Lunch and snorkeling around the little island, and by the time we snorkeled back to the boat, there must have been 20 boats anchored up in a tight area. Nasty storm blew in and the anchor started to drag (I snorkeled down and checked it, but just casually as we didn't plan to stay long, and only one other boat there... live and learn). Started raining so hard you couldn't see more than the boat right next to you. I decided to pull and leave rather than not know if I was dragging down on someone. Reef on one side and rock cliff on the other. Had to go between them, as that was the only way out. Without that GPS, I would have been in a pickle. Beyond that instance, as they told me, I didn't need the GPS. But I made the right call by insisting on it. And still nice to have aboard anyway. Guess I'm used to GPS and not charts. Although I bought and used the charts all week, just to brush up.

Also agree with the Moorings. Wouldn't call it first class, but they were helpful and the wait times were reasonable once you get to the marina. They come out to you if any problems. I partially lost steering and had to use the gears for steering for part of a day, but they came to the boat in a reasonable amount of time, and took care of it. I didn't have to lose a minute of vacation fixing it. Make sure you do a pre-sail check of the vessel. They typically have them in good shape, but I'd rather find out at the dock than on the mooring. Found that 2 of the 3 bilge pumps onboard weren't functioning. We had to sit for an hour while they got them fixed, but I thought they were quick about it. They do seem to want things all working for you. Just saying... don't assume. I think the pumps, then the steering, were the only issues we had with the boat. Which I thought was pretty reasonable. I'm sure previous charters never knew the bilge pumps weren't working. Steering was no big deal. And we only lost the one hour on the pumps as far as any down time.

We also went a day early. Went and got our own groceries, just so we had what we wanted. Gave us a chance to look around town again too. Decided on a condo instead of a night on the boat. It did help us unwind from traveling. Take a swim in the pool and a nice supper there at the docks. And after a week on the boat together, the condo was the right choice!

If you're going anywhere to cruise with your dad, I can't think of a better place. We also went around Tortola. Most areas are very protected and deep, calm waters. But like anywhere, it's weather dependent. Of course, we were north side, least protected, when the storm hit. That's the only 'rough' water we saw. It was really nothing, but the kids (we had a 6 and a 7 yr old along) started feeling quizzy. Even if it got too bad, you're never far from an island or point to duck behind. Easter should be a pretty good time to go too. I believe we went in May and the temps were perfect. Other than the one stormy day, great weather.

We didn't have to tow our dink. Was mounted on the swim platform, so simple for us to use. As far as picking up a mooring, if you and your wife are experienced boaters, this should be a piece of cake. No idea of your experience level. Just work out your hand signals beforehand and keep the talking to a minimum. Even if you've never done it, if you are comfortable handling a boat, it's very easy. Just don't get it in the props. The 10 and 12 year olds should be able to handle it, once they've done it a time or two. If you miss it the first try or two, no big deal. I'm always amazed at the people that have trouble with something this simple. But then, I suppose some people have trouble driving their cars too. Look over the various color mooring balls before you go.

We went with another couple, but I'd go with just my wife and 10 year old daughter and not think twice about it. We did have one labor intensive problem. Got a big piece of coral stuck on the anchor. We only anchored twice that week. During the aforementioned storm, then in White Bay. Met up with friends that live down there and anchored in White Bay. Nice sandy bottom, but wouldn't ya know, I found a lonely chunk of coral. Took a couple of ropes and some muscle to get that thing off. Glad to have another guy along at that point. I left White Bay late afternoon, as that was the day that was stormy and looked like another front rolling through. Pretty restriced anchorage in White Bay, and after the anchor dragging thing, I decided to go pick up a mooring in Cane Garden Bay, as that was better protected based on wind direction. Everybody else had the same idea, and it was crowded when I got there, but did get the last available ball.

Don't miss North Sound/Virgin Gorda. We moored there, snorkeled on an empty beach we knew of in the morning, then went up to the pool at Bitter End (cost a few bucks, but well worth it) for lunch and sunned/swam the rest of the day. Then supper and fed the fish at Saba Rock. Hang a different color light on your boat when you leave for supper. The Bitter End moorings can get crowded, and finding your white light/boat among the sea of white lights/boats after a few drinks at supper can be a challenge.

If your dad has never swam in the ocean, I'm guessing he's never snorkeled :) He'll have the trip of a lifetime for sure if you get him swimming with the fish! It's a great place for snorkeling. If he's concerned about it, just tie a lifevest to his bathing suit with a piece of 15-20' string (not rope, just twine), so he's always attached to a life vest. I do that for my wife, who's not a good swimmer at all. I also carry a knife along to cut the string. Just in case. She won't go snorkeling without it now. Gives them a chance to rest on the lifejacket when they get tired too. Inside the reef closest to Bitter End, behind Saba Rock, has some great snorkeling, but may be too rough and too deep for your dad. Research the forums for the better places to snorkel before you go. Virgin Anchorages is a good book to help with navigating, and has some snorkel recc. in it too.

Well, I'll stop my early morning ramblings. Hope some of this helps. I really enjoyed running the power cat. As Dan said, a very stable platform. Oh, be sure and take a few cheapo inflatable floats too. Takes little space, and nice to just float around tied to the boat with a drink after you get moored up. With a little pre-planning and some decent weather, your dad and family could have the trip of a lifetime. I say go for it. One of the best vacations I've ever had. Great snorkeling, normally calm waters, and the scenery certainly isn't the worst in the world either.

JB
 
We just returned from a cruise last month on a 47' Motorcat. Our fourth trip, we were very happy with Moorings out of Tortola.

It was two days down and two days back, so keep that in mind. We came real close to missing the shuttle from San Juan to Beef Island, due to a 45 minute delay in Chicago. Almost had to spend the night in San Juan, rather than at the Moorings base in Tortola where we had 3 rooms already purchased.

They now have first-rate accomodations at their base in Tortola. Expensive, but brand-spanking new!

Our crew of 8 included my 76yo FIL, and two kids, 9 and 11yo.

In addition to the great advice already given, I would caution you on the only complaint I had with Moorings. In order to be efficient, they checked me out with 2 other captains on another's similar boat.

It wasn't until the second night, then, that we realized we didn't have a key to the saloon door. We called them on the cell phone they provided (great idea) and they delivered a cable lock to us when we were at Soper's Hole. We also couldn't find a valve handle for the 4 fresh water tanks.

So insist on your individualized checkout!

Great GPS plotter on the 474 Powercat. In fact, all of the equipment was much better than prior charters out of USVI.

Seemed like the charter business is noticeably depressed. You might even be able to get some good deals.

Good luck.
 
Lots of recommendations for Moorings. They are a good outfit. I charter catamarans out of the Catamaran Company. They have both power and sail. I have yet to be on a boat over 2 years old. They are nicely maintained and the staff is quite good. I've also heard many good things about virgin traders if you decide to charter a power boat.

On catamarans, the dink is carried on davits, not towed behind. I think a catamaran is the best choice for your group. It is akin to sailing your living room and deck around. I recommend a 4 cabin cat, 40 feet or above. Your kids will love it! As for swells, the likelihood of swells depends on the time of year you go. They seldom last more than a couple of days, and seasoned captains can keep you in sheltered waters. Keep in mind you can sail very short hops, less than three hours per day, that will get you all around the islands. For specifics, try traveltalk online. That is also the best forum for BVI do's and dont's.

Good luck!

Brett
 
Jim. in your post you say a crewed cat. I run a crewed tri in the bvi and must say we have had from the wheelchair bound, People with recent knee surgery and those who are just too old to be able to walk far at all. Many suggestions about bare boating have been put up and all are valid if you bareboat. If you are at all concerned about your dad I would recommend a crewed charter for a couple of reasons. Firstly you get the local knowledge of a crew. They are not going to take you somewhere that isn't going to work on a particular day with that days weather/sea state. Second they are always at the ready to help you with the getting your dad on and off the boat. Thirdly and most importantly the crewed boats have larger dingys that are generally set up with handholds etc, and as they do this every day for a living you are not likely to have any sort of boarding mishaps.The comment above about the weather and being stuck somewhere for 2 days is not an issue with a crewed boat. In approximately 300 weeks of chartering here I have never had a single day when we have not been able to move or go to somewhere that was perfectly calm. Its that local knowledge thing.If you have any specific questions on the BVI ask away.
Bazza.
 
JBN,

Did you go? How did you like it? I'm looking at going around Thanksgiving & I'm looking at the Moorings - anyone have any other suggestions? I did sail a bunch of years back, but we're going power this time (Cat I think). Thanks.

Bob
 
We used Stewart Yacht Charters. Ellen Stewart books charters for privately owned yachts and has a huge selection of crewed and bareboat charters, sail, cats and power. Ellen was exceptional and provided very personal service. As was said before, if you use a crewed charter and go through someone like Stewart they can customize every facet of the cruise from the type of boat, provisioning of meals, activities, ports and even the choice of adult beverages to your specs. They usually have a crewmember on board who is an excellent cook and provide top service. We had some lousy weather on our cruise but never missed a port, always felt safe and secure and loved it!
 
Back
Top