Checking WOT Tomorrow. What Load?

David M

Active member
Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2005
RO Number
16492
Messages
7,393
I am switching from 3 blade to 4 blade props. One of the things I need to get the prop shop is the WOT with the 3 blade props.

I have about 25 gallons per side now. I am getting fuel tomorrow to make the run and a lot came to mind. Should I test with full fuel (225 gallons) or less. I have 25 gallons of water on board. Should I fill up the tank full to 40 gallons? The holding tank is empty. Should I fill it up with water? That is another 28 gallons.

The problem with the setup I have is the engine is supposed to redline at 5300 RPM's. The V drive redlines at 5K. I am having the props tuned to allow the engine to turn the 5300 RPM's called for figuring I will never spend any time at that RPM anyhow. I am hoping having the props tuned for mac RPM will ease the strain I am experiencing in the cruising RPM range.

TIA.
 
Anything close it good to go, this is not a magic number. 4800-5200 would be fine, over 5200 on a marine engine is hard on it.
 
David, with all tanks like they are, you should be able to turn 5200+. After you add fuel, lets just say 100 gallons,you should still be able to pull 5200. Filling all the tanks full, you should be able to top 5100.

Face it, the throttle handle pulls back as easy as it pushes forward. I would rather be slightly under propped than over propped. Taking the drives a couple hundred above 5000 for a moment wont hurt anything.

Ken
 
quote:

Originally posted by JimPend

Anything close it good to go, this is not a magic number. 4800-5200 would be fine, over 5200 on a marine engine is hard on it.






Understand. The engine is a hi rev hi torque stroker.

The specs state that in an I/O setup the engine is to rev between 4800 and 5200 RPM's. In the inboard setup, the engine is to ref between 4600 and 5000 RPM. I have reviewed the specs on both engines. The only difference is the transmission. I investigated the transmission website. It accepts up to 5K RPM. That is a shortcoming of the setup. The original engines were 7.4's with a WOT of 4600 RPM's.

To accept the WOT at 4600 RPM is actually laboring the engine unnecessarily and cutting the overall life of the engine by overworking it. In addition, I am killing the potential reduction in fuel consumption by laboring the engines.
 
i'm not sure you're going to gain much if you are currently at the bottom of the acceptable range. turning rated RPM is more critical on a diesel than it is with a gas engine...

you shoudl test with full fuel and water, since you are liekly to have passengers on board when you run the boat.

what are you turning now for the engines to be under strain? make sure you trim tabs are working and that use them to get on plane, a lot of those Vee drive boats, especially with prop pockets need a lot of tab to get on plane and cruise in the lower range.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

i'm not sure you're going to gain much if you are currently at the bottom of the acceptable range. turning rated RPM is more critical on a diesel than it is with a gas engine...

you shoudl test with full fuel and water, since you are liekly to have passengers on board when you run the boat.

what are you turning now for the engines to be under strain? make sure you trim tabs are working and that use them to get on plane, a lot of those Vee drive boats, especially with prop pockets need a lot of tab to get on plane and cruise in the lower range.






One of the reasons I am testing is I honestly don't remember the WOT. I want to say it was about 4800-4900 by the dash tachs. In that the boat has not moved in 6 months, I am sure there is some slime on the bottom (fresh to slightly brackish water). Those are the figures I'll give the prop shop should the numbers on this run prove to be way off that mark.

The tabs worked fine when I slipped her last winter. I'll know if they still do shortly. Another problem with 330's of that vintage is that they are terribly arse heavy and they squat something fierce. They require full tab to get on plane and a lot of tab to stay there. Add to that the only place to store a good size cooler is on the platform and you end up looking like you are trying to launch a space shuttle rather than getting a boat on plane.

I called Bennett regarding this problem. Apparently I was not the first. They advised me to have a shop weld a plate on the tabs to increase the size from the current 22x9 to 22x15. The hydraulics are more than capable of handling it.
 
to answer your original question, you should test WOT rpm's with a full load and adjust your props according to your results with your max load. as others have noted it is better for engine life to run with too little pitch than too much.
 
+1 for testing at full fuel, full load. If the bottom is not clean when you do the test, its a waste of time.

While you may not destroy gas engines when overloaded as easily as diesel, you certainly are not getting extra efficiency. I once took an engine that was not hitting its WOT rpm, dropped an inch of pitch and actually gained speed at all rpm's. Try to figure the math on that one.
 
KiDa,
Test the boat the way you "normally" run it....fuel full, the amount of people on board, etc.

As far as a stern heavy boat, my 300 Express is the same way. Cruisers told me that with some of their "bigger" stern heavy boats that they will "pre-load" the trim tabs by putting a 3/4" starboard block in between the tab and the bracket on the ram. This pushes the tab down a little to start with and allows the tab to go deeper in the water. I have done this to my boat and it works great! The one thing you have to be careful is IF your boat gets lifted by a fork lift you want to make sure that they don't get in the way of the forks. Before I did this, I had tried putting 175#s of dumbells in my anchor locker that worked but I didn't want to leave it that way.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Type-A

KiDa,
Test the boat the way you "normally" run it....fuel full, the amount of people on board, etc.

As far as a stern heavy boat, my 300 Express is the same way. Cruisers told me that with some of their "bigger" stern heavy boats that they will "pre-load" the trim tabs by putting a 3/4" starboard block in between the tab and the bracket on the ram. This pushes the tab down a little to start with and allows the tab to go deeper in the water. I have done this to my boat and it works great! The one thing you have to be careful is IF your boat gets lifted by a fork lift you want to make sure that they don't get in the way of the forks. Before I did this, I had tried putting 175#s of dumbells in my anchor locker that worked but I didn't want to leave it that way.






I can see where pre loading the tabs would work, IF the tabs were close to big enough to start with. Bennett told me this is not the case with the 330. In their defense, Bennett also told me they informed Sea Ray that 22x9 tabs were not enough for the boat. Sea Ray was not willing to spring for the extra money for the larger tab. Bennett also told me to leave the outboard 90* down turn on the tab as it generates lift. I find that last statement odd as none of their newer tabs have this. Oh well....

WRT "I had tried putting 175#s of dumbells in my anchor locker that worked but I didn't want to leave it that way", I have an all chain rode and I don't think I could convince even the least intelligent of my friends to stuff his arse in the anchor locker! ;)
 
Best idea is to design the weight forward such as the mfg SHOULD have done. Can you move water tanks? What about batteries? Often these are located aft where its convenient for the builder, but if you have hollow cavities forward, it can be done.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Ghost

Best idea is to design the weight forward such as the mfg SHOULD have done. Can you move water tanks? What about batteries? Often these are located aft where its convenient for the builder, but if you have hollow cavities forward, it can be done.






To the best of my knowledge, all express cruisers with a mid cabin have rear mounted engines and V-drives. It's a tradeoff. If I were going to keep this boat longer than anticipated, I would move the batteries. There is plenty of space under the forward berth and IIRC, AGM's do not require an open space for gassing. However, you start pricing the wire out to make the move and all of a sudden, the AGM's look cheap.
 
David, another reason for testing with full fuel, full water and zero waste is that you can reproduce these conditions when you get the new props. If you do it with some stuff in each tank, you will probably not have the same weight next time.
 
Back
Top