In the Spring of '14 we passed through and spent a night. The restaurant was open then as well, but they had a guest section and an owner section which was more roomy and pleasant. No one was in that section, and boaters were not allowed in. As a result the bar area was mobbed and well the food was not that great.
The pool was a salt water pool and was in need of repair. The water quality was suspect to say the least. I will say Chub was a scenic place that offered a break in a long run from Nassau to Bimini, but given CB's report nothing much has happened since '14 when we were there.
Having been to the Berry Island Club back in '10, we skipped that place in '14. The dock was in poor shape and the boat still has a chuck out of it from where it rubbed on a bolt sticking out of the dock. Definitely an "out island" experience.