Coast Guard donation request?

marathon man

Member
exMember
Joined
Sep 15, 2006
RO Number
23428
Messages
404
In the mail Friday I received a request for a donation to the Coast Guard. First time I have received one of those. November Charlie,or other guardsmen, is this request legit?
I thought that all branches of the service were funded by tax dollars.
This request did not mention any specific funds like the one for the plane/copter crash last month.
Just wondering.
 
Read it carefully, I got one to, but it was from the "Coast Guard Foundation".
 
In some ways, an offer of a trip for a crew that assists you may be a better deal. Visit the patrol and offer either to take interested crewmembers on a fishing trip, or, if possible or more appropriate, offer to make a few trips where the crew can take their SO/kids. This allows them to enjoy the water and really, truly be "off duty".
 
You must be joking. Take the CG crew on your boat with their SO/kids? If the coast guard helps you or saves you, some sincerly expressed gratutude is more than sufficient. If you want to do such as thing no problem by me but it simply is not necessary. Also, the CG and US Military shouild not be asking for donations, though it is doubtful that this actaully came from the USCG.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Maycpa

quote:

Originally posted by JohnH

Mine went right in the garbage.






Some day you will need them.








Might need the Marines someday too but I don't see them out begging for contributions.

it all seems a bit dodgey to me.

Bob
 
I give plenty to the Disabled American Veterans, the Eastern Paralyzed Veterans, Diabetes, Breast Cancer and a few more too. I didn't consider this a valid donation request and I do not like the fact that they used the Coast Guard name in their solicitation.
 
Thanks for the suggestion.....I have no problem taking a serviceman and his SO/family for an outing on the water.

That said, I do believe I'd prefer take them fishing......
 
"You must be joking. Take the CG crew on your boat with their SO/kids? If the coast guard helps you or saves you, some sincerly expressed gratutude is more than sufficient. If you want to do such as thing no problem by me but it simply is not necessary. Also, the CG and US Military shouild not be asking for donations, though it is doubtful that this actaully came from the USCG" -- TurboWarp

No joking. Also, if you don't feel like it, don't do it.

If I wish to "do something nice" for a group of persons who "just did their duty" then, imho, dumping off some pocket change to some obscure organization I've never heard of just doesn't seem right. On The Other Hand, Theses people likely joined the USCG because they "like the water", but the spend their entire work day -working-, not "jes fishin". If I feel the need to "do something nice" for those who pulled my ( oversize ) rump out of a bind, then it seems like a bit of water recreation is appropriate. It would be my pleasure to take a few of them out on a fishing trip. I know tht when I was in the service, an offered fishing trip would have interested me. For me it is an enjoyable way to offer a sincere "thank you" directly to those who were involved.

YMMV. Sometimes, a simple note that says only "Thank you" is enough. And even that is never "required". Do what you are comfortable with ( which includes, doing nothing special ).

--

I agree that it is irritating to receive requests for "help" form organizations who claim, but do not actually have, an affiliation to the group stated.

In the case of the USCG, I am sure that a simple call to the local PAO will get you the name of a properly affiliated organization. ( ie: USO )
 
Every donation request is just someone who thinks they should be spending your money and not you. I have a hard time believing any of them. 72 percent can go to the collector and the other 28 percent actually go to the cause and it is still considered legit. I had someone in my business once collecting money for missing children. I went off on the guy. If you don't know where the kids are, how do you get the money to them?
EVERYTHING IS A SCAM! And if you know for sure otherwise, than open your wallet.
 
quote:

Originally posted by billybokay

72 percent can go to the collector and the other 28 percent actually go to the cause and it is still considered legit.





From the looks of the web site listed above by Sandy, the performance of this particular organization is considerably worse than that.

http://www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm?bay=search.summary&orgid=6489

Program expense 61.8%
Admin, Expense 20.8%
Fundraising Exp 17.3%

Total 99.9%

Just exactly what is left for the actual charity?

Bob
 
I would like to see tha mail you received. I think someone is trying to scam you here.
 
quote:

Originally posted by rnbenton

quote:

Originally posted by billybokay

72 percent can go to the collector and the other 28 percent actually go to the cause and it is still considered legit.





From the looks of the web site listed above by Sandy, the performance of this particular organization is considerably worse than that.

http://www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm?bay=search.summary&orgid=6489

Program expense 61.8%
Admin, Expense 20.8%
Fundraising Exp 17.3%

Total 99.9%

Just exactly what is left for the actual charity?

Bob








Looks like 1/10 of 1%.
 
I think you guys are misreading the information. That says that 61.8% of what they collect is used directly for what you are donating for.
quote:


Program Expenses < 33.3%:
Our data shows that 7 out of 10 charities we've evaluated spend at least 75% of their budget on the programs and services they exist to provide. And 9 out of 10 spend at least 65%. We believe that those spending less than a third of their budget on program expenses are simply not living up to their missions. Charities demonstrating such gross inefficiency receive zero points for their overall organizational efficiency score.




 
quote:

Originally posted by rnbenton

quote:

Originally posted by Maycpa

quote:

Originally posted by JohnH

Mine went right in the garbage.






Some day you will need them.








Might need the Marines someday too but I don't see them out begging for contributions.

it all seems a bit dodgey to me.

Bob










They call it the USO
 
As Hogan stated above, this request was in fact from the "Coast Guard Foundation" based in Stonington, CT. On the return form where you state the donation amount, it says "Yes, I will support the courageous men and women of the United States Coast Guard". It also mentions a boat donation program that they can send you information about.
In the solicitation letter they state that they have,for the last forty years, "supported hundreds of thousands of Coast Guard personnel by providing programs that promote the health, training, welfare, morale and education of, as well as awarding educational grants to, enlisted personnel so they can complete their college education, as well as supporting families who have lost a loved one in the line of duty.
They provide libraries for cutters on extended missions, they provide phone calling cards and they furnish performance and fitness equipment.
The president of this foundation is Anne B Brengle.
Donations are said to be tax deductible.
Thanks for the replies above.
 
Back
Top