Cold water survival

Radioactive

Well-known member
Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
3238
Messages
4,831
Just saw an article about an Alaskan cruise boat passenger presumed to have gone overboard. The article mentions that the water temp is 57deg F. I immediately assumed that if the actually went overboard, then she has already taken "her final voyage". Sad.

But, what it made me think about was, "What is the 'LD50' of water temp?"

Or put into other terms, is there a chart illustrating expected survivability times based on time and temp?
 
Yes there is, have seen it, but don't remember where. Let me do some checking.
 
I found this reference while preparing a lecture for the BSA.

timegraph.gif
 
Something like a 50 year old in 50 degree water with 50 minutes of survival...before hypothermia sets in.
 
So, at 57 deg F ( or roughly 14 deg C ) I was perhaps a bit pessimistic, as she may have as much as 9 hours to be found ( per chart, 2 to 9 hrs ). Perhaps she will be one of the lucky ones...

--

A reminder to us all that while a PFD ( highly recommended, imho ) is an important safety device, we also need to keep sea temp in mind when we go out. The Sea is not "out to get you", but is certainly can be unforgiving if ( when ) we make errors.
 
There you go. Best to be a slow cooler though. (lots of fat for insulation)
 
While it might sound a bit ridiculous my wife and I purchased Gumby suits at the Atlantic City boat show. We put plastic bags in the legs because a few members on the board said this would make donning them easier. This assumes we would have the time to put them on as in we had to abandon ship and could get in the life raft. We obviously don't wear them when boating but the are under one of the bridge/helm seats next to the EPIRB and about 10 steps to the life raft. We boat into December in the northeast. Neither of us can imagine dying by hypothermia. Bill
 
It is a subject that, locally, is often disregarded, as SST is often > 75 deg F. In fact, it is not uncommon to see it rise into the 90's. But winter temps, especially inshore in the La swamp can fall dramatically. And no one seems to understand that a risk exists. We lose a few boaters every year due to hypothermia, likely because of the assumption that the water is "warm". Not always the case.

The warm season temps do, however, reduce the hypothermia risks to near zero. The other associated survival risks ( dehydration, heat issues, extreme sunburn ) are much more common at that time. And local boaters are much more familiar with those risks and how to deal with them.

You do encounter thermal "oddities": the spring runoff from the Mississippi River can be downright cold. And while running out to go deep sea fishing, you can encounter dramatic thermal changes while going from river run-off into the warm GoMex loop current.
 
I can run the CESM, also known as the 'Canadian Model', when I get back to work - but I have no idea when that will be - sometime this week, though.

Just need sea temp, air temp, exposure (I assume immersed to neck), clothing, height and weight ,etc.
 
Fifty percent of the people will die in fifty minutes in fifty degree water. While a survival suit is a nice thing to have, I would also have a 3", diesel powered, portable pump with suction hose and strainer. With that setup you can keep the boat afloat so you do not have to get into that little rubber raft and suit. But pumps don't look as cool as suits.
 
57 Degrees had to be way down in Southeast somewhere. Either that, or the boat was on the edge of the Japanes current.

Did it say where the passenger went missing?
 
We spent June/July in SE Alaska--and the highest water temp we saw was 55 degrees, down to as low as 41 degrees. More in the mid 40's and rarely over 50.
 
quote:

Originally posted by L. Keith

Fifty percent of the people will die in fifty minutes in fifty degree water. While a survival suit is a nice thing to have, I would also have a 3", diesel powered, portable pump with suction hose and strainer. With that setup you can keep the boat afloat so you do not have to get into that little rubber raft and suit. But pumps don't look as cool as suits.






With what size hole, where, in what size compartment, on what size boat, with what compartment plan, of what displacement, in what weather, with what other damage, with what ancillary casualties? A 3" pickup with what throughput? 50GPM or 500GPM? And what's plan Z when that pump sinks out from under your toes?

People, THEN property. Which, admittedly, is seldom a black and white differential in such a sitution, when extenuating factors are considered. But in ANY event, the survival suits come first, then the damage control. You -can- run a pump while wearing a gumby suit.
 
Just a caveat for gumby owners. If you've never put one on, & praticed donning for time seasonally at the very least (and carefully maintained suit zippers and bag snaps), they probably won't do you much good. Think night , rough seas, sole awash, boat rocking & going down. I have 5 and usually carry 2 or 3, but really wonder what the likelihood of getting into one is in a serious situation on a small (27') boat when donning the gumby might be the second choice to trying to stop the sinking & hailing the USCG or any other responding station. I can't imagine getting into the bilge to even just close a seacock in a gumby and all-in all I'd rather be in a floating boat than in the water in a gumby. I expect that's often not a clear choice and the 2nd "option" may disappear before the 1st is extinguished. FWIW I do have a Cat 1 EPIRP attached to the tower console and generally take an offshore raft on offshore forays.

I suspect more folks who fall into water in the low 50's or lower may succumb to the effects of excruciating bent-leg cramps and panic from water in the lungs before actual low body temp hypothermia fully takes it's toll.
 
Here is a link to the source article.

Location given as, "...reported missing by a friend Monday at 10 a.m. when the ship Zaandam was in Glacier Bay National Park about 75 miles northwest of Juneau."
 
I am sorry to post that she has been found, but did not survive. May she rest in peace.
 
To sandy, point. When we got our gumby suits I was shocked at how little dexterity one has once your hands are in the lobster claws. There is no way that one could put out a may-day or activate and EPIRB in the suit. For this reason I would think that once all hope of not going in the water is lost. The May-Day is out, the epirb activated, the raft inflated. Then one would get into the suit and high tail it for the raft. I have often wondered if it is even possible to get into the raft wearing the suit? Secondarily I have always stated that your best chance of getting into the raft is jumping from the boat onto the canopy of the raft. If that fails chance of survival are much lower I would think.

I am also told that new suits have removable claws; I think this winter we will surely upgrade; save the traditional gumbys as extras but have the mitten suite for the crew that is on the boat most often.
 
Mike if I had the ability to predict all of those factors I would be hanging out by a roulette table, not struggling for a living down on the waterfront. A decent 3" (suction and discharge), diesel powered, trash pump will have a flow rate of about 400 gpm at 0 head. That flow rate will take care of the water ingress from most fractures or openings in the boats most people on this forum operate. If you tear the bottom out of your boat, no the pump will not help you. Neither will a suit, raft and epirb stowed below in a locker. If your inspected and serviced raft is mounted in a free float rack with a hydrostatic release and clear release pathway you may have a chance. How many small yachts have that set up. Same with the epirb If you read my post, you will see that I said "I would also have" the pump. People tend to put too much faith in all that gear. I'd rather just keep the boat floating.
 
"That flow rate will take care of the water ingress from most fractures or openings in the boats most people on this forum operate"

Good point. Didn't really consider that. In that cold of water, I generally already have the drysuit on, so I've never really put much thought into the feasability of damage control work with a gumby on.

Saw an interesting one this year - a raft not just stowed in a secured locker, but in a padlocked locker, and the container itself lashed tightly with some ratty old three strand.
 
Those charts and 50-50 rules are for hypothermia. In cold water, you'd be lucky to survive long enough to get hypothermia. First is the gasp reflex, if that occurs when your mouth is underwater, you've got a new problem. The next thing that happens is blood is shunted from your extremities to keep your core warm. You quickly lose fingers, hands, arms, and the ability to do anything to self-rescue. If you don't drown from gasping, and you're wearing a life jacket, and there's someone there to pull you back aboard, you MIGHT live long enough to test out those survivability charts, which by the way assume a young, fit person.
 
Back
Top