Cored hulls?

You make the point exactly. There is insufficient quality out there to trust a mas produced cored hull. It is not worth considering for the typical recreational boater. I have been told that that due to a lack of computerized engineering capabilities, solid hulls were over-engineered, since they could not take it to the material limits like they do today in many mass produced boats; so they can be quite sturdy. Regarding longevity of a boat, it would seem that the hull itself, when used within design limits and for the purposes intended, is unlikely to fail sans coring. The components within the hull are far more likely to fail than even the modern thinner hulls. Nothing wrong with an older or newer boat if the hull and structure are intact. Everything else is suspect and will ultimately fail.
 
"The components within the hull are far more likely to fail than even the modern thinner hulls. Nothing wrong with an older or newer boat if the hull and structure are intact. Everything else is suspect and will ultimately fail."

it depends but most systems can be rebuilt if the hull/structure is worth it... Engines, pumps, air cons, etc... all will need overhaul/replacement sooner or later. For the rest, we're going back original quality. Take tanks for instance, a handful of builders used fiberglass for tanks which will last as long as the boat (talking larger diesel boats here, obvioulsy not gas which is affected by ethanol). Same with wiring, plumbing, steering, etc...

as you said, early on builders didn't know how thin they coudl build... with time many started experimenting at the expense of the customers while customers demanded higher speeds. This is especially true with sportfishes and eventually you end up with the above results.
 
It is important to remember that the older hulls were built heavy with an abundance of resin. Later testing and engineering determined that it is the glass not the resin that provides strength and today’s fiberglass contains far less resin that the old solid glass structures. Old hulls were built thick copying wood construction and because there would be glass voids and a too much separation of glass fibers.
Modern methods are not just for cost savings, they produce a stronger lighter product. Just as steel beams are webbed and not solid so to will fiberglass be stronger and lighter if it is not solid. IMO, however, any wood is a poor modern choice for coring because it allows a failure mechanism not possible with foam core, wood can rot.

The caveat in all of this as has been said over and over, “with quality workmanship” that is the wild card in boats and everything else. IMO every failure I find in anything usually can be attributed to somebody not doing the proper job in the first place. It is impossible to know if a particular boat was actually built in conformance with specifications, the definition of quality. The hull failure pictured above surely resulted form poor quality of construction. Construction not done in accordance with specification.

Like it or not because of the economy engineering and development of boat manufacturing methods has probably mostly stopped and like the era of the luxury tax it will be a very long time before significant new development begins again.
The impact of economic conditions on quality probably wont be good as well.
 
Many of the failures of wood coring be it balsa or plywood above the waterline is poorly installed "add ons" such as railings, windows, hatches etc. Depending on the install most often the sealant used for the add on is depended on to keep the coring sealed - and it does for a while. In production boats proper installation of such things increases cost quite a bit. Again failure of the core material is due to poor boat construction - not a problem with the coring itself.

That Bert that self destructed is not going to help Ferretti sell any boats it is?? :)
 
quote:

Originally posted by pdecat

It is important to remember that the older hulls were built heavy with an abundance of resin. Later testing and engineering determined that it is the glass not the resin that provides strength and today’s fiberglass contains far less resin that the old solid glass structures. Old hulls were built thick copying wood construction and because there would be glass voids and a too much separation of glass fibers.





Older vs. Newer...

There are many balsa cored hulls built in the 80's that are as sound today as the day they were built (provided an idiot didn't compromise the hull installin a fitting or a transducer)

What was the turning point (decade wise) when engineering and design learned how to do lighter, better, stronger?

RWS
 
With the exception of Sea ray, what other builders have any history of manufacturing based cored hull failures? I’m sure there are some but no one comes to mind

I know of some well made cored hull boats that had failures because of the owner doing something they shouldn’t have done or something they didn’t do well. More often attaching ‘stuff’ to the hull poorly or just not doing routine maintenance on the stuff that was added
I drive a new car that is known for being well built, yet many of this brand owners ‘Mod’ their cars and a lot of these turn into crap over a short time.
 
Abalmuth, FYI .... Your cruisers sedan does not weigh 25 tons. That number is likely the Gross Tonnage as calculated for documentation. Gross Tonnage is a measure of volume, not weight. Manufacturers specs on your boat show a displacement of 16.96 tons
 
RWS: I dont think there is an answer to your question. makers have been trying to build better, lighter, cheaper boats since the earliest days of FG construction. Not every new method was successful and all makers and all models didn’t adopt change simultaneously.
 
quote:

Originally posted by boatpoker

Abalmuth, FYI .... Your cruisers sedan does not weigh 25 tons. That number is likely the Gross Tonnage as calculated for documentation. Gross Tonnage is a measure of volume, not weight. Manufacturers specs on your boat show a displacement of 16.96 tons





Actually the Gross Tonnage as calculated for documentation is 36 with the net being 29
Depending on the source of “Manufacturers specs” , this number could be all over the map
I personally have found a range of 38,000- 46,000lbs listed as the “Manufacturers specs” for my boat.
Regardless of the above, when the boat is fully loaded and wet(meaning full fuel, water, vodka etc.), it weights +-50K lbs in the slings which equals 25 short US tons
 
we push the limits in offshore racing this is the result its an aircraft that has marine propulsion sort of we are running T53 turbines out of the huey chopper our team came into the turn in keywest a bit to hot and barrelrolled twice landing upright other than damage to the engine hatch and water swallowed buy one turbine it survived to race the next day with a fresh pair of hairdryers its 50 foot long and easily exceeds 200 mph heres the hull http://www.mysticpowerboats.com/boat models/brochures/C5000 Brochure (2-23-08).pdf heres the boat running http://www.turbinemarine.com/video_AQM_KW.html
 
Back
Top