Cored hulls?

Coring adds STIFFNESS not STRENGTH! The strength comes from the walls.
 
I understand the increased problems of puncture even with a well done core, and the concerns of delamination or absorption with a below the waterline core made marginal or not properly cared for, but what I dont understand is: the argument for light weight. Yes this is good for fuel economy but I really like the idea of having as much weight as low as possible. Above the waterline coring makes lots of sense, but in addition to compromising the hull integrity itself, there are major advantages in ultimate stability and righting moments as well as reduced roll in beam seas. Rather than improved stiffness and rigidity through coring, there are great advantages to achieving this with solid heavier, below the waterline, hull layups.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Silver Lining

I understand the increased problems of puncture even with a well done core, and the concerns of delamination or absorption with a below the waterline core made marginal or not properly cared for, but what I dont understand is: the argument for light weight. Yes this is good for fuel economy but I really like the idea of having as much weight as low as possible. Above the waterline coring makes lots of sense, but in addition to compromising the hull integrity itself, there are major advantages in ultimate stability and righting moments as well as reduced roll in beam seas. Rather than improved stiffness and rigidity through coring, there are great advantages to achieving this with solid heavier, below the waterline, hull layups.






Your catching on. All this engineering of materials is about building a less expensive boat, not a better one.
 
Let me put a slightly different slant on this. I have been studying cored hulls for some time--and we have non destructive testing instruments which can determine if a core is delaminated or wet, but the costs of the instrument, and the skills to use these instruments currently are beyond the average marine surveyors capability. In our study of cored hulls we cut up a number of hurricane damaged boats--and it was amazing how well cored boats faired (both balsa and foam) if they had adequate glass on both sides of the core. The problems came with boats which did not have adequate glass, and even with foam cored hulls, there was an impression left when the boat hit a piling, because of the lack of glass on the outside.

I have sailed many thousands of miles in a boat which was custom built with a technique where the hull is made by strip planks of balsa (2" x 2" planks, edge nailed and epoxy glued, using aluminum nails. After the hull was built over a male set of frames (basically a mold), it was covered with about 3/8" of glass (24 oz roving and 1 1/2 oz mat, alternate layers. Then the hull was turned over, and the frames were removed and the entire hull was glassed over with about 1/4" glass. Bulkheads were later put on the inside of the boat, along with stringers (all wooden) The core was removed in the bottom of the keell and this was 1 1/2" thick solid glass. That boat was always properly maintained, with any hole properly sealed and solid glass or epoxy and filler around any thru hulls. The boat has done 2 circumnavigations and over 150,000 miles during the last 30 years. Once the boat hit a low floating container, while going 8 knots in 8 foot seas. The crew did not realize that it had been hit, until almost 24 hours later, when the boat finished the race. There was an area of impact about 3" x 3"--and some delamination of the outer glass, a dent into the "core" and the inner hull pushed in and delaminated. The boat was sailed another 200 miles, and hauled. The water had not significantly migrated in the core, and the damage was easily repaired. The vast majority of fiberglass production boats would have been holed and sunk by this impact. At age 30, a complete redo of the boat was done, including some samples of the core--no damage and no water intrusion. The boat is still cruising. It is beyond the limited space in post to compare all of the core materials. In some places, the balsa still is a superior core material. In other places, foams or various composite cell structures are better. But don't completely dismiss cored hulls. Again--it has to be done right--and unfortunately, many boats are not built correctly--and $$$ are not always an indication of quality of construction. Yes, a good survey is very important.
 
quote:

Originally posted by jtybt15

Coring adds STIFFNESS not STRENGTH! The strength comes from the walls.






or Bulkheads as we like to call them
 
here are some pics i got, origin unverified, supposedly from a new Ferretti-Bertram 63 that experienced catastrophic delamination in palm beach... When i saw the first one i thought it was photoshop job, not so...

of course, speed is everything to the Sportfish guys so builders have to keep the weight low. me, i'll stick to solid bottoms.

bert1.jpg

bert2.jpg

bert3.jpg

bert4.jpg

bert5.jpg

bert6.jpg

bert7.jpg
 
I thought Bertram was better than that.
Makes you wonder what happened to the old craftsmanship they had.
 
Yikes! I can only imagine what the owner(s) were feeling as they went through the water looking at thier hull sides hanging off!
 
I dont think the current Bertram company has a lot in common with the original one, didn't they shut down in the early 90s until being purchased by Ferreti in the late 80s? you can be sure you won't see the above happening on an old bert!
 
King5899,

I can guarantee you there has never been a cored Aluminum Cruisers Marinette ever built. Above or Below waterline... The bad part is you may have to replace the power and repaint them after 20 or 30 years.
 
About 6 years ago we looked at a 32 foot, 1986 aluminum Marinette that we fell in love with. We were ready to make an offer but then I read an article about one that experienced "catastophic hull failure" because of an electrical leak and a zinc issue and sunk within minutes.

I just couldn't pull the trigger after reading that article. I knew that it was a huge over reaction but I just couldn't get past it.

Jim
 
I have seen a couple of laminate failures, but never as much as that Bertram's core. I suspect that a poor layup, plus improper catalyst.

Today I surveyed a 30 foot Motor Cat, which is cored with Airex. There was a "dent" about 4" in diameter, with some stress cracking, where the boat had hit a piling and the core had been compressed about 1/8 to 3/16" depth. This is above the waterlne, and most likely is cosmetic, I have seen several other boats, with this type of damage, but usually after a storm, and not in just ordinary use-and a "hard docking".
 
If anyone doubts whether coring works and can produce a superior, stronger and lighter structure then you better not ever fly on an airplane again. Just about everything on an airplane is cored to save weight. Why is coring not an issue on a plane that goes 500-600mph, sees temp variations from 100 degrees on the ground to freezing up in the air? The reason is testing and build standards. Boeing, Airbus, etc make test panels and do a multitude of tests such as peel strength, flex modulus, impact and so forth. Unfortunately, there really are no standards in the boating industry. Each manufacturer builds a cored hull anyway they want and hope the design is successful. If you take a look at Pascal's pics, you can see large areas of cleanly exposed coring. This is very bad. When the laminate is peeled from the core, you should see some of the laminate remaining bonded to the core or a thin layer of coring still bonded to the laminate. In other words, the laminate or core structure should fail before the bond line to the core fails. I think the boating industry should develop some standards so when we purchase a cored hull there is a high degree of confidence in the product.
 
Unless you have a specific need or application, there does not seem to be any reason to buy a cored hull, especially below the waterline. I just want to boat not worry. The potential of achieving long term results for the average weekend boater is not worth the risk in my estimation. An airplane is a specific application, costs a billion dollars to buy, and multiple millions to maintain over its lifespan, and failures are catastrophic. This is not rocket science it just recreational boating.

Cored hulls: forget it.
 
In our ultrasonic testing, we were working with one of the leading aerospace testing instrument producers. The standards we were comparing to were Mil Spec aerospace. Believe me, the difference between recreational boats and anything which flys or the military uses, are vastly different. There is no question that a cored structure can be an excellent material, but those in aerospace are very carefully tested in building and after they are in use. The short cuts used by boat builders could not be tolerated in airplanes.... You can develope standards, but economics dictate what the public buys. Much of what is sold is influenced by "glitz"--both for men and women....

If you ant that type of laminate in boats, then look at some of the ULBD or racing boats. But even these fail at an unacceptable rate.
 
quote:

Originally posted by TurboWarp

Unless you have a specific need or application, there does not seem to be any reason to buy a cored hull, especially below the waterline. I just want to boat not worry. The potential of achieving long term results for the average weekend boater is not worth the risk in my estimation. An airplane is a specific application, costs a billion dollars to buy, and multiple millions to maintain over its lifespan, and failures are catastrophic. This is not rocket science it just recreational boating.

Cored hulls: forget it.






Even if you don't buy a boat with a cored bottom or hull sides, you are almost guaranteed to have coring elsewhere in the boat. Decks, cabin tops, transoms, stringer grids. You name it, and they fail just as frequently as the hull bottoms we talk about. They are just not as visible often and don't get discovered until things have progressed significantly. Still the cause of failure is poor boat building techniques, inferior materials and often each of those in conjunction with each other.

My point here is that just because you buy a boat with a solid fiberglass bottom does not let you off the hook in regard to investigating and understanding quality build plans.

In fact, material costs have become significant enough that even in the case of the typical "solid hand laid fiberlass" hull of today, there are drawbacks. Nobody can afford to sell a boat with lots of material, so that "solid fiberglass" may be solid, but its likely not very thick. Oh, and its probably not hand laid either, more likely put together with a large portion of chopper gun use.

You just don't see the strength of glasswork that is in an older Tiara, Hatt, Bertram or in my case Tolly. I would give the manufacturers credit that the planning/engineering that goes into hulls of today is superior. It has to be. If you put less glass in, you simply have to know precisely how much strength is there. So in practice, often the newer hulls are not as strong, more consistent yes, but strong no. Strong enough? Probably, but if you really want to own a boat that will last for years and not have to worry about....it might very well not be a new boat you are looking for.

YMMV

bp
 
Back
Top