Day Shapes

Sailboats are supposed to fly an inverted cone when under sail and power. Anyone ever see one do it?
 
quote:

Originally posted by Les Hall

Sailboats are supposed to fly an inverted cone when under sail and power. Anyone ever see one do it?






A sailboater was nice enought to waive me around while under both forms of power coming up the ICW. If they were flying the shape it would have made it easier.
 
In fact, it is just a sad commentary that most boaters do not actually know the Rules of the Road at all... I mean if I go by the rules I am supposed to honk x amount of times when approaching another vessel, they are supposed to honk back agreeing to my original honk, which I then acknowlege again??? Can you imaging how freaking noisy the bays would be if we all did this sort of thing??? I am always fearful when another boat is approaching, the vast majority of people have no clue as to what side they are to pass by on let alone what to fly at anchor...
A light at night? no question !!
By the way, my boat is still in the driveway so far this year due to .... RAIN !
 
That's why the Nav Regs clearly state that it is permitted to make passing agreements by radio telephone instead of honking. :) Makes the day a lot more pleasant. :)

quote:

Originally posted by Graeme2004

In fact, it is just a sad commentary that most boaters do not actually know the Rules of the Road at all... I mean if I go by the rules I am supposed to honk x amount of times when approaching another vessel, they are supposed to honk back agreeing to my original honk, which I then acknowlege again??? Can you imaging how freaking noisy the bays would be if we all did this sort of thing??? I am always fearful when another boat is approaching, the vast majority of people have no clue as to what side they are to pass by on let alone what to fly at anchor...
A light at night? no question !!
By the way, my boat is still in the driveway so far this year due to .... RAIN !




 
I believe I saw a sailboat with the shapes too. Like maybe ONE in 30 years of boating!

It's very rare to see a boat with day shapes displayed. And it simply is not enforced. The courts may rule on a case, but they certainly don't enforce the rules. Nor does any other US agency. There are lots of stupid rules on the books. If they aren't enforced, then people learn to ignore them. Fact of life. Day shapes fall into that category. The USCG should try to get the rules changed to reflect what people are actually doing out there... safely. It's very logical to display lights at night. But if another boater hits me when I'm anchored up during broad daylight, seems pretty obvious who is at fault. USCG should not require me to put anything on my boat when anchored in daylight. They should get rid of day shape rules for non-commercial traffic. Just about no one uses them, and it's a very antiquated rule. Like was said, the majority of boaters don't even know what they are when they do see one. So what good are they, then, for a recreational boater?

JB
 
"In fact, it is just a sad commentary that most boaters do not actually know the Rules of the Road at all... "
Well what do you expect... there's no REQUIREMENT that they learn them, so why bother???

L Keith you didn't answer my question... what size anchor ball must I order???

I wonder when the last time someone rammed an anchored boat in broad daylight in US waters and got away with it because the anchored boat was not showing the proper day shape???

Blue Dog please let us know the results of your "experiment"!
 
I saw a guy in a 30' + Searay(beat to crap) motoring out of Plumb Island sound with a big black ball flying over his helm.... yikes!
 
I don't want to challenge anyones obligation to follow the rules or laws but if someone has been cited for not following it and has decided to challenge the particular rule to whom would they make this challenge? The Coast Guard? the court system? Would they need a lawer?

Dictionary: dead letter
n.
1. An unclaimed or undelivered letter that after a period of time is destroyed or returned to the sender by the postal service.
2. A law, directive, or factor still formally in effect but no longer valid or enforced.

The problem with laws and ordinances that no longer serve the practical purposes for which thy were intended is that unless the legislative or governing body changes the law or ordinance they can languish ad infinitum on the books. Discarding obsolete laws and ordinances is usually achieved when someone challenges the statute after they have been cited for the offence, this usually happens when the person cited believes the law is being selectively enforced or is a “bad law“. As you can imagine changing or discarding obsolete laws and ordinances can be complicated and expensive therefore there are many still on the books. Some may never be challenged if they aren‘t enforced or if the person cited is not interested or wealthy enough to challenging the citation.
 
Wille, never seen your vessel, Bill posted the requirements above. You are the Master. Make your own shapes out of plywood, why pay retail?
 
One part of the problem with making changes to the rules is this: The RoR in the us has been/is in the process of being merged with the RoR of all other countries. The Rules now conform ( mostly ) to the Rules in all other countries. In many ways, this is a good thing. But one problem is that any change becomes a treaty to which all participating countries must ratify. As you can imagine, this is no simple thing...
 
The rules, including shapes requirements, are all very valid for commercial vessels. Tugs with a 10 barge load and tankers can't turn on a dime like most recreational vessels. The CG should probably just expand the exceptions to include smaller recreational vessels.
 
quote:

Originally posted by L. Keith

Wille, never seen your vessel, Bill posted the requirements above. You are the Master. Make your own shapes out of plywood, why pay retail?






I TOLD you it's 35'. I'm just asking YOU (the expert) what size my balls need to be. I probably need two, just in case I ever break down. I have lots of plywood.
 
Willie,

Based on the rules and extrapolating the ratio, the math dictates about 14".

In a former haze gray life, I did indeed see recreational boats displaying proper day shapes in the fjords off the coast of Norway. It's just another language to learn. Not that big a deal.
 
Willly, get a ruhm drink, it's too hot to act like that. You Florida invaders need to learn to slow down when the air temps go up. I have always had two nice sized balls and have never had a break down.
 
Exception for smaller recreational vessels sounds like a very good idea. So how do we go about getting this done?
 
quote:

Originally posted by jb2c

Exception for smaller recreational vessels sounds like a very good idea. So how do we go about getting this done?






These are less than a couple of bucks each. You can order them w/o printing. I like the fact that when not in use, they take very little storage room.

http://www.adlineind.com/inflatables/inflatables-p12.htm

About 1/2 way down the page.
 
Back
Top