Deck fills - lessons learned

ronp

Member
Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2006
RO Number
23477
Messages
758
I put some gas in the boat today using cans as I often do, but put some in the port tank which I usually don't do with cans, only at a gas dock (since it's the side away from the dock.) Was met with a gas smell in the saloon and cabin which obviouslt triggered an investigation. Turns out it was dripping down from the deck fill or hose (can't see up in there to tell which), so either the fill fitting has rusted through inside or the hose is shot. No boat ride today obviously, everything electrical is disconnected pending repairs.

I want to replace both fittings and both hoses. The hose I found on Boatfix, it looks like the 2 3/8 hose is it, since my for now somewhat crude measurement says it's 2 3/4 OD. But I don't see any deck fills like mine anywhere. The flange OD is 4 3/8 and it has to fit the 2 3/8 hose. Anyone know of a source, or at least a manufacturer? Smaller ones are not going to work with the hole that's already present in my deck, plus I don't want to change the pipe on the tank to work with smaller hose.

Also, what would one seal these fittings and hoses with? There seems to be some sort of hard black goop that's bulged out of the joints now which I can't identify.
 
I looked at your profile to see what type of boat you had but there isn't anything there. I had something similar happen to my Mainship 40 Sedan Bridge last year. The deck fill was a two piece pressed unit. It had a stress crack and the crack allowed the 2 pieces to seperate so I ended up with an open hose to my gas tank behind the microwave. Because of it's position in relation to my fume detectors no alarms took place. My wife was the first to smell it. I ended up having the marina replace the fitting and all is well. It really could have been an explosive moment had I warmed my coffee in the microwave that morning! Good luck and be very carefull. I will measure mine tomorrow I know my gas fill rubber pipe is large almost 3" but I will ask the marina what it was replaced with. As far as sealing it everything is double hose clamped and that is all.
Take care. Bill
 
ronp ( Popeil??)- You might want to pull the fill hose off at one end or the other to confirm I.D. before ordering , as deck fills to match up with 1 1/2" I.D. hose are the most common and the largest fills I've seen only accommodate 2" hose. That doesn't mean yours might not be larger.

Don't go by O.D of the old hose as newer hose or ones by diff. mfgrs. may have diff. wall thickness.

If the old hose is old enough it may be pre-"SAE 1527 Type A-1" or "A-2" and succumbed to inevitable alcohol rot. If that is the case BE SURE to carefully check all fuel vent and distribution hoses onboard to positively confirm they have been upgraded in the past to conform to present 'SAE J1527" alcohol-resistant specs and replace now if not. That and "Type A-1"(vent or distribution hose, w/ blue stripe?) or "A-2"( fill hose/ red stripe?) plus "USCG-Approved Alcohol-Resistant Hose" should be plainly visible as marked all along the length of the hoses.
 
Sandy, thanks. No, sorry, I am not the inventor of all those wonderful products. I could use some 'pocket fisherman' royalties about now. I am assuming the hose I have is original to a 1972 boat, so if it had any markings they have probably faded away. I haven't seen any but I have not taken it out yet. That is going to wait until the 90+ temperatures stop, this is not crawl around the bilge weather. Good point re the sizes, I do intend to get one of them removed before I order anything. But, I don't like the looks of the deck fill fittings so those are going to go regardless. The seal doesn't look great, and the chrome is long gone, and there's surface rust on the inside which implies it has let at least some moisture in. So that has to go.

Billy, I know how you feel - now. It was definitely a scary moment when I realized this was not just a residual smell from fueling. I was fortunate that not much gas spilled, not enough to get to the centerline where water collects. There wasn't even a sheen on the bilge water. The little bit there was pooled against a stringer and laid in the rough texture of the hull so I was able to sop it up with paper towels. Then again I only dropped in 10 gallons from cans, not a full tank worth.
 
Ronp...I just replaced my original hoses and deck fills on my 1976 Silveton. Let me tell you, it is NOT going to be easy getting those old hoses off. I had to cut mine with a sawzall and then pry it off the tank. That was the easy part. The same problem happened up at the fills. The hoses were there so long, they would not come off. Those I had to use a dremel tool with a grinding wheel to get off (already disconnected from the tanks). Luckily I was able to get at the clamps and hoses through the vents (had to remove them). If you are not handy, I would suggest you pay someone as there will be a lot of cursing involved. Boatfix definitely has the best price on new hose. I also bought my deck fills from Boatfix. They did not match what I had, but short of paying a small fortune to Silverton for matching fills, I filled in the old holes and just used new fills (the old deck fills were 2" and the new tank I had made was 1 1/2". Changed all fittings to 1 1/2 "). Be sure to DOUBLE clamp all hoses, and be sure to re-attach your ground wire. You do not have to add anything to the hoses themselves, just double clamps, but if you use new tank fittings, you can buy in any hardware store, plumbers dope, that is good for gasoline use. That will be the cheapest part of the whole job. Whatever you decide, GOOD LUCK.
 
Salty, I think I remember your prior thread, vaguely. Is there a reason you were confident that using a sawzall on that hose wouldn't blow you up? I have a Dremel, and this is right up it's alley, but I don't know. Cutting the rubber hose should make no sparks, but I believe it has wire embedded. And then cutting up against the pipe it's attached to sounds risky. Did you just score the surface and then attack it with hand tools? Or was your tank already rendered inert somehow?

I am "handy", but no one is very handy contorted at odd angles in a bilge, so I'll see how it goes.

I did find a Perko fitting with a 4 1/4 flange and a 2" hose attachment, so maybe I can make that work, either if I measured my hose wrong which is very possible considering the ruler/eyeball method I used, or if I change out the galvanized pipe fittings on top of my tank.
 
Yeah...my tanks were empty (not by my choice). But even empty, there are still fumes in the tank. I was just extremely careful. A hacksaw works just fine also, just takes a little elbow grease.
 
I managed to get the hose off the deck fitting last night. The Dremel was melting the rubber and didn't seem to be a safe approach. So I chopped at it (gently) with wire cutters and was able to loosen it enough to get the hose off that end. In theory that should work on the bottom end as well. I was lucky that there is a big side panel in my saloon that unscrews, so I had good access. The deck fill is a pipe thread type, and the pipe that was connecting that to the hose had rusted through. I may just need to replace that pipe. The hose is actually in good shape, though I'll replace it anyway.

The real fun is, the pipe rusted because the deck fill doesn't seem to have been bedded with much of anything, and water was seeping in. And of course the wood had not been cut back and sealed. And now the wood core in that area is mush. I'll have to do some forensics there but I will need to cut away some fiberglass and replace some wood from underneath. OTOH, the deck is not spongy at all, apparently it is a narrow enough area that the fiberglass is strong enough to support it.

It's just like the house, every job turns into 3 other jobs when you get into it.
 
Updating the subject since I have a different question now. Since I plan to reuse my deck fill fittings but replace the pipe that connects them to the hose.

I assume these fittings are chrome plated bronze. The chrome is mostly gone, they have sort of a dull nickel-like appearance. The inside of the fitting has a green tarnish like copper would get. And they are hard and heavy, not soft like brass. Am I correct that they are bronze? What else might they be?

And if so, given that I need some 2" pipe (2 3/8" OD actual) what kind of metal should be attached to this, that I am likely to find? Do I have dissimilar metal concerns in this application? Or I just want something that won't rust?
 
Probably chrome plated zinc or also known as zamac. If so replace with chrome plated brass or bronze
 
I've ordered all the parts, I'm going with the Perko fitting for 2" pipe and a bronze pipe to hose barb fitting. Then the 2 3/8" gas fill hose. With the chrome over bronze deck fill and bronze hose fitting, I should be in good shape re electrolysis.

For the possible benefit of anyone else who has a 1970's boat that may have a similar situation, I'm posting what I've learned about this. I believe Solar is correct. I think my old fitting was Zamak the more that I look at it. And I think what they mated it to was a galvanized pipe nipple. And that's bad.

deckfill.jpg


Would you want to pour gas through that? The holes got opened up as I carefully flicked the rust away before removing it, but you can see it was shot. It looked fine when you looked down the pipe from above, it was hanging together. The fuel hose (Aeroquip 2651 it says) was fine, so if ethanol is bothering it there is no visible evidence of that.

In researching my metal question, I learned that Zamak and galvanized can indeed create an electrolysis hazard, if some salt water is present. Like it would be when you have a fitting that was never sealed properly to the deck. See below link if interested, which mentions a sportfisher that had the same issue and blew up. (5th paragraph)

http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0BQK/is_1_11/ai_n16019438

Obviously I should have been pulling panels out and inspecting this sooner, and it's a mistake I won't repeat. Surely it took a long time to happen, but this goes on the spring-izing list of things to look at.
 
Galvanized is what I had on the tanks only. The deck fills were Zamak. It sure looked original, so I guess that at one time they actually used it. Do your arms hurt??? LOL..anyway, I'm glad you got them off.
 
"It's just like the house, every job turns into 3 other jobs when you get into it."

Don't forget to deal with all the fuel hoses now if they are not clearly marked as noted above indicating they have been replaced. The original hoses definitely would not be in compliance or safe for long exposure to the recently semi-mandated alcohol mix l. It's not a matter of "if" they will leak when exposed to gasohol but "when, if not already". You might not even notice it at first if it starts on the vacuum side leaning out the mix.
 
Sandy, all of the supply hoses for the engines were replaced when it was repowered by a prior owner in 93. It all says SAE J1527, USCG Type A1, and has brand name of either Flex-Acol or Fire-Acol. Whether they needed bigger lines to go from 220s to 270s and supply more gph, or they just thought it was a good idea, I'm not sure. A lot of it is stamped 1993 so I know it is not original.

Salty, everything hurts. Yikes, that fill hose is some tough stuff. You could make a decent tire out of it.
 
Back
Top