Diesel engine survey

HOLBROOKJ

Member
exMember
Joined
Jan 27, 2009
RO Number
31049
Messages
6
I am in the process of scheduling a survey and sea trial for a 2003 Carver 396 and I need to know what checks and tests that should be preformed on the Cummins 370 hp diesel engines that have 440 hours on them? The Cummins technician wants to spend all day pulling impellers and other checks with a bill of $1200. Can you tell me the tests that need to be preformed.
Thanks for your help.
 
$1200 to survey 2 diesels and probably a genny is pretty much in the ball park. Not sure about pulling impellers though... in doubt about their history, just replace them after closing, it's cheap.

a complete engine survey on a a pair of diesel is a full day affair, including sea trial during which the surveyor will take many measuremnts (temps, pressure, etc...)

this probably doens't even include compression checks, does it?

an oil analysis is a good precaution, although without a baseline it can be hard to tell what's really out of wack.
 
The price for survey is reasonable, welcome to diesels.

at that age the after coolers are ready for their first teardown and cleaning, at least in sea water, and the sea water pumps probably need to be rebuilt or at least the impellers changed. I would expect those engines to be in good shape. The most important spec being exceeding rated rpms by 50 -100 RPMs, with no excuses. If it wont dont accept the boat until the problem, over propping, is fixed. Don’t believe any baloney about always cruising at 200 RPM off the top.

As Pascal said oil sample test wont show much unless there is a big problem but that alone is reason to do it. Trannys too.
 
is this a prepurchase survey you are performing or are you trying to figure out what maintenance items need to be done on a boat you already own?

if it is pre purchase, i would let the surveyor do the sea trial and collect the oil samples. if the boat performs correctly at sea trial and no smoke or other performance issues i would probably stop there. unless you have all the engine maint records you are probably going to go thru the motors with p/m work anyway. if you suspect a problem(s) with the motor(s) then i would invest in having a cummins certified mechanic go thru the motors and tell you what is wrong or needing attention. 440 hours for an 03 boat is relatively low hours, if the previous owner did the annual p/m work they are probably in good shape as those are very reliable motors. (except the raw water pumps) sounds like 6BTA's
 
The life of the boat is in the cold waters of northern Michigan. All service records are complete.
 
if you were a knowledgeable diesel guy who could inspect the engines and do a dock side start run test before deciding on survey I would agree with vic but if you are not how much risk are you comfortable taking?
 
Cheap insurance.

You'll either be happy that they found nothing, or they will find something small that will allow for an adjustment in price or they will find something big and save you the heart break down the road.

My money is on them finding nothing big.
 
That model engine should have a WOT of 3050 to 3100 to be properly propped
 
quote:

Originally posted by HOLBROOKJ

Yes the $1200 does include compression checks.






Then you're getting a fair deal that could well save you 10x that amount.

I just had 2 12 cylinder MTUs surveyed last week. With bore scoping and compression tests but no running or sea trail tests.(Engines are partially dismantled) The bill came to $1700.
 
I'm in agreement with Bruce. The assumption of low hours and a good engine being enough in most sitations, is a HUGE one. Especially when the impacts of a bad decision can easily fall into the tens of thousands of dollars category, coupled with the fact that frequent engine failures among current day diesels is a well kept industry secret. Diesels lasting forever in current day boats is a huge myth and likely always was if we are not talking commercial vessels.

I'd be very concerned to make sure the engines CURRENTLY are set up properly and that they have been from the get go. If not, damage has likely already been done through repeated hoop stress heat cycles and I'd pass on the boat. The only way I know of to take repetive stress out of the pistons is to replace them. Not to mention that we have the red flag of a low hours boat. Low hours boats are owned by people who, well, don't boat that often and by extension of their minimal experience tend to make rookie mistakes. These are all too typical guys who go adding pitch to their props and other antics. You don't want to buy their boat until well proved in its history. I want to see a WELL documented maintenance log or a LARGE price deduction. Instead, I'm will to bet the broker sells the low hour scenario as an advantage. It isn't.

I've spent too much money fixing diesels after the fact to think even I could get away without a survey.
 
quote:

Low hours boats are owned by people who, well, don't boat that often and by extension of their minimal experience tend to make rookie mistakes.





No, 440 hours isn't not low hours for a boat in Northern Michigan! If we assume it was built in mid 2002, that's 440 divided by 6.5 SHORT seasons, or 67 hours per year.

(I'm in Southern Michigan, and I'm looking at fresh snow right now)

67 hours per season is well on the high side of average for a recreational boat in that region.
 
I am also in the process of having a pair of 435 Cat diesels surveyed with 750 hours in a 1998 50 Viking Sport Cruiser. I am paying a few hundred more than your quote but this includes both engines, both transmissions and the generator. It also includes oil samples for each but no compression test. Although it seems expensive aside from peace of mind I think it gives me a good baseline to monitor performance, temps, boost pressures etc. in the future. The Cats have been well maintained with complete service records at the regular intervals and I have been assured that they run at good operating temperatures and pressures. With the cost of a diesel rebuild and wanting to get good longevity, a good survey seems like the correct starting place.
 
quote:

Originally posted by HOLBROOKJ

Yes the $1200 does include compression checks.





Compression check?
Normally on a Diesel you just crack a fuel line at the injector and listen for a miss. I never knew of somebody pulling all the injectors to run a Compression test on a working Diesel.
 
Pretty standard procedure on a good thorough survey of diesels.

Of the pair of diesels I just had surveyed, the stbd one showed low compression in several cylinders but still seemed to run well, from what I understand, the last time it was up and running.
But based on the differences in compression from the high(400 psi)to low(290 psi)cylinders it's still going to need to be rebuild. The cylinders with low compression also showed exessive wear when bore scoped.

Left Bank Right Bank
PSI Metric BAR PSI Metric BAR
1) 390 26.896 1) 350 24.137
2) 395 27.241 2) 395 27.241
3) 400 27.586 3) 395 27.241
4) 400 27.586 4) 390 26.896
5) 290 19.999 5) 300 20.689
6) 300 20.689 6) 300 20.689
 
Maybe it is different for old Detroit 2 cycles, but a compression check is an essential measurement for them. A bad reading will trigger the need for an overhaul, as Bill describes. Certainly other measurements will indicate that a compression check is needed or not, but if I was having a survey done, I'd go ahead run the check anyway. It'll help give you an idea of how much life is left so you can budget accordingly. I think the engine/trans/generator survey I had done (which took almost two days) was some of the best money I've spent on the boat. I was lucky to have a surveyor who is a good communicator and teacher, who includes a training and orientation session to the engines as part of his fee.

George
Hatteras 56MY
 
Back
Top