Electric Dinghy Motor

HarlenW

Member
Member
Joined
Mar 30, 2007
RO Number
25699
Messages
473
Would you please share with me any experience you have had with an electric outboard motor to power a dinghy? I have a 7.5 foot Livingston and am expecting to use it to get to shore and to explore a little while out cruising.

Thanks.
 
The salt water trolling motors cost more.
My 35 Lb thrust would last about 14 miles or about two hours on a Rubber inflatable with me and 200 lbs of gear.

Pretty slow going though. About 5 Mph.
Other than that I liked it.
 
I used to have a dinghy with an electric motor [until hauling the battery got to be too much for my aging body!]. It was a lot of fun and I loved the peacefulness of a nice quiet ride.

Though one time the motor quit and my BF tried to row us "upstream" and was hardly making any progress. A fellow boater came out in his PWC to give us a tow back to the slip!
 
We looked at buying an electric motor like minakota or the torqueedo. We decided against it due to cost and unreliability. I bought a 2hp Honda and love it. It is lighter, runs for over an hour on one tank of gas and has a centrifugal clutch so when it starts it does not surge into gear. I wanted to go electric but the benefits are not there yet.
 
I switched to a Minn-kota years ago and have never felt the need to go back to my old Evinrude. The battery is easier for me to handle than the gas outboard; and the trolling motor is not heavy enough to matter. No cranking involved and it ALWAYS starts. I charge the battery by simply plugging it into the boat's system.

I'd like something like a Torqueedo but IMO they're just too expensive. The minnkota AND battery run about $200.

On another vein I equipped an 18' canoe with a 40# Minnkota and two golf batteries a year ago. It cruises at 5 mph with two adults (a whole lot faster than we can paddle) and the batteries are good for AT LEAST 20 mi.
 
quote:

Originally posted by FireCracker

We looked at buying an electric motor like minakota or the torqueedo. We decided against it due to cost and unreliability. I bought a 2hp Honda and love it. It is lighter, runs for over an hour on one tank of gas and has a centrifugal clutch so when it starts it does not surge into gear. I wanted to go electric but the benefits are not there yet.






A friend of mine bought the Honda 2HP and loves it. I think it weighs 27 lb or so. And it's air cooled. Hardest part is buying it as Honda expects dealers to sell their motors as a package with and installed on a boat. Apparently, even the 2 HP ones.

The advantage of a gas powered motor over electric is that if you run out of gas, you can add more and get underway. Not so with electric.
 
"The advantage of a gas powered motor over electric is that if you run out of gas, you can add more and get underway. Not so with electric."

True up to a point. If you're out of gas you're out of gas. You can carry a spare battery as easily as spare gas, though admittedly it'll weigh more. Even without the spare, a battery will give you plenty of warning to turn around and head for the dock. The main issue is getting comfortable with the rig and knowing what it will and won't do. For most short-range "dinghy" operations, the electric works just fine.

I use a group 24 in my dink, it has enough power to do what I need and it's a LOT easier to handle than a group 27. If I needed more range for the dink I'd just get a second group 24 rather than a bigger (heavier) battery.

However if you want speed, or LONG range, gas IS the only answer.
 
quote:

Originally posted by stmbtwle

"The advantage of a gas powered motor over electric is that if you run out of gas, you can add more and get underway. Not so with electric."

True up to a point. If you're out of gas you're out of gas. You can carry a spare battery as easily as spare gas, though admittedly it'll weigh more.





But you can buy or beg gas, not electricity. There are plusses and minuses to each. With gas, you have to handle gas and that can be dangerous if dine carelessly.
 
We use a 43 lb thrust salt water series trolling motor on a 12 foot aluminum skiff. It is powered by two golf cart batteries and charged at home. I get 3 to 4 hours use at 3 to 4 knots (these batteries are too heavy for a dinghy). The problem with a trolling motor in the dinghy if you are cruising is charging the battery. If you have 110 volts available, and can charge overnight--then it will work. We have tried the trolling motors in small dinghies, but went back to gas--and keep the electric for "eco tours"_ sneeking up on alligators etc.
 
You can also hook 'em up to the "big" boat's electrical system and charge them with the alternator, genset, or whatever. Works for me.
 
Back
Top