"The advantage of a gas powered motor over electric is that if you run out of gas, you can add more and get underway. Not so with electric."
True up to a point. If you're out of gas you're out of gas. You can carry a spare battery as easily as spare gas, though admittedly it'll weigh more. Even without the spare, a battery will give you plenty of warning to turn around and head for the dock. The main issue is getting comfortable with the rig and knowing what it will and won't do. For most short-range "dinghy" operations, the electric works just fine.
I use a group 24 in my dink, it has enough power to do what I need and it's a LOT easier to handle than a group 27. If I needed more range for the dink I'd just get a second group 24 rather than a bigger (heavier) battery.
However if you want speed, or LONG range, gas IS the only answer.