Engine Choices how to select?

RobertNJ

Member
exMember
Joined
Jan 10, 2007
RO Number
24819
Messages
53
Hello:

This is my fist time posting, so I hope my question doesn't sound to "fundamental" to some of you...

I am in the "research" stage of selecting my first boat. Although there have been other family members with boats ranging from 17 to 24 feet, I am planning to buy my first one in approximately two years. My "dream" is to complete at least two mayor trips, one taking me down the intercoastal waterway around Fla, go up the Mississippi to the lakes region and down the Erie canal to the Hudson, back home to NJ. I am in the process of reading to see if this is possible with a "sport cruiser" in the 28 to 35 feet range. The other trip would take me down to the caribbean, if I'm still afloat.

I am also in the early stages of taking CGA courses in boat safety and navigation, and I do plan to become Г«xperienced before undertaking such a trip.

My question is, in selecting the engine for a boat this size, manufacturers nor dealers seem to provide enough information to make the appropriate selection. For example, some manufacurers will list at least 10 possible engines for boats this size.

I am hoping that the more experienced people on this board will assist me in getting through the "newbie"stage I'm at.

Thanks

RobertNJ
 
I would opt for the largest displacement engine offered in the particular model your looking at. It will cost you a few more dollars at purchase but may actually be more efficient in the long run. I see people saving a few bucks (they think) on engine selection only to find out they are grossly underpowered later on. Are you talking I/O or inboard? If inboard, then Crusader hands down.
Greg
 
Hi Robert,
I am sort of in the same boat as you. I have been doing all the the northeast shows for 2 years now, looking at primarily at same size range as you are. Recently started considering 27's for their trailer-ability (not sure thats even a word).The one thing I am sure of is I will go for the highest HP/cubic inch motor available and it has to be attached to a ocean series drive (Volvo Penta). I will not even waste my time looking at a vessel that does not offer this combo. Sad thing is this 'No Boat Has It All' but for me Four Winns is pretty damn close, Doral would be a contender if the radar arch wouldn't be in the way of a good day of fishing!
Good Luck...Robert NY
 
With the distances you want to travel, you should be looking at diesels. Vovlo Penta makes a diesel/outdrive combo.

There is no replacement for displacement.
 
I agree, go Crusader's if inboard. Don't be cheap on the motors. Will cost you more overall if you try to save now.
 
first you need to decide whether you will take these dream trips right away or not... if the great loop or cruising the carib. is like 10 years away, get the boat you need now (or in 2 years) and when you are really ready for the long distance trip, sell and get the right boat.

usually the great loop is done the other way around... down the rivers and up the ICW since going up current is going to decrease your speed and increase fuel cost.

when you say Caribbean, do you mean Bahamas or the "real" Caribbean ? a 35 footer is fine for the bahamas but too small to cross between the turks n Caicos and DR/PR. it woudl also be a little small between the islands as well, some stretches of open water cna be a little rough.

another issue is fuel cost. while it's possible to do the loop with a gas powered boat, once you reach around 35', you'd be looking at significantly higher mileage with diesels an important consideration expecially for the Bahamas and Carib where fuel is expensive and range an issue.

you should also consider accomodations and livability... if you're going to spend months cruising the typical 28 to 35 express is quickly goign to feel very small... storage, water, etc... will be limited and you'll be stuck down the basement whenever you're inside... no view.

if the great loop and carib is still some years away, get some experience on a 30/35 gas express then when you're really ready, sell and get a larger diesel boat that will be better suited to long cruises. Otherwise, look into larger diesel boats right away, even used to stay within budget as needed.

re engine choices, it the manufacturer can't provide you with performance data (speed, fuel burn, etc...) ask here or search the web. boattest.com i think has that data...

i dont' necessarily agree that you need to go for the biggest engines available for a model. while you dont' want an underpowered boat, range is important too and the larger the engines, the shorter range will be.

last new boat i bought was a few years ago, a 37 inboard express. i looked at the nrs between the base 310hp and the option 380hp and chose the 310s. 20kts cruise was fine with me and range was 170NM vs 120NM with the larger engines at 25kts
 
Robert,

You probably are going to need to focus on the combination of range and engine size together. In the 28-35 foot size cruisers, you are going to find all kinds of combinations, and they may not all be intuitive. There is a stretch in the Gulf of Mexico from Clearwater to Carabelle (sp?) with no intracoastal, and not a lot of fuel. I think Cedar Key is the only stop.

At 30' and under, most of your cruisers are going to be I/O's. You need to do your homework and learn the pros and cons of inboards vs I/O's. If you decide that you want inboards, that is going to shorten your list of choices by quite a bit in the size range you are looking at.
 
Wow, really cool vision you have there!!! Can I come along? :)

As always everything is a tradeoff in a boat. Somehow you need to figure out the answers to what are probably some questions you still need to come up with. Chief in my mind is "speed". How fast do you "think" you want to go. Lets start here, over 20 knots or under 20 knots. With long distance, usually "efficiency" starts to become a major priority (especially if unlike coastal cruising, you will need to make some longer passages and still have fuel to toot around with such as your caribbean type plans). If you go for efficiency, then the speed usually comes way way down to say 8 knots. If you want a boat that can do both...try to list that as a key priority. While usually you never want a boat that is underpowered, if your goal is slow efficient cruising then that may result in a boat that you don't want to be "overpowered". At around 30ish feet, I'm thinking a diesel powered boat that will get "okay" efficiency, not trawler efficiency but still respectable and will be capable of 20 knot speeds, but you will hardly ever cruise at say 8 knots.

Anyway, that's my starting point. Speed. What do we imagine at this point the requirements are.

Good luck, awesome project. Also as Pascal noted the great loop is usually done the other way. Do a google search on "great loop" and you will get tons of information. Oooh another question....How much time do you plan to accomplish your trip? That will majorly help answer the speed question too!

bp
 
quote:

Originally posted by HOGAN

With the distances you want to travel, you should be looking at diesels. Vovlo Penta makes a diesel/outdrive combo.

There is no replacement for displacement.








Diesels are definitely in the equation, being that I'll be putting a LOT of miles.. However, some of the boats I've been looking at, like the Silverton 33 Convertible, does not offer that as an option. I think I just eliminated one of many boat choices!

BTW, is diesel cheaper at the marinas? I know most gas stations charge more for diesel than regular gas... that was not the case many years ago.

Thanks for your reply
RobertNJ
 
quote:

Originally posted by Ghost

Wow, really cool vision you have there!!! Can I come along? :)

As always everything is a tradeoff in a boat. Somehow you need to figure out the answers to what are probably some questions you still need to come up with. Chief in my mind is "speed". How fast do you "think" you want to go. Lets start here, over 20 knots or under 20 knots. With long distance, usually "efficiency" starts to become a major priority (especially if unlike coastal cruising, you will need to make some longer passages and still have fuel to toot around with such as your caribbean type plans). If you go for efficiency, then the speed usually comes way way down to say 8 knots. If you want a boat that can do both...try to list that as a key priority. While usually you never want a boat that is underpowered, if your goal is slow efficient cruising then that may result in a boat that you don't want to be "overpowered". At around 30ish feet, I'm thinking a diesel powered boat that will get "okay" efficiency, not trawler efficiency but still respectable and will be capable of 20 knot speeds, but you will hardly ever cruise at say 8 knots.

Anyway, that's my starting point. Speed. What do we imagine at this point the requirements are.

Good luck, awesome project. Also as Pascal noted the great loop is usually done the other way. Do a google search on "great loop" and you will get tons of information. Oooh another question....How much time do you plan to accomplish your trip? That will majorly help answer the speed question too!

bp






Ghost:
Thanks for the reply.

I've actually given some thought to the issue of speed. It seems that since most of the intercoastal trip will take place within protected waters, I'll be cruising at lower speeds. Fuel economy becomes more important than how fast I get there. Is my reasoning ok on this?

I will be retiring in four years, so my plan is to buy in about two years, become experienced in the next two in NJ/Del waters, and then make the first voyage around the "loop".

RobertNJ
 
Robert if your real plan when you get the boat is to take those long range trips right away I agree with pascal in that an express cruiser might not be the best boat for that especially as most of the express style boats in that size range are going to be gas. Given that I have seen some some of the late 1980's early 1990's Trojan express sometimes powered by Deisels.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

when you say Caribbean, do you mean Bahamas or the "real" Caribbean ? a 35 footer is fine for the bahamas but too small to cross between the turks n Caicos and DR/PR. it woudl also be a little small between the islands as well, some stretches of open water cna be a little rough.

you should also consider accomodations and livability... if you're going to spend months cruising the typical 28 to 35 express is quickly goign to feel very small... storage, water, etc... will be limited and you'll be stuck down the basement whenever you're inside... no view.

last new boat i bought was a few years ago, a 37 inboard express. i looked at the nrs between the base 310hp and the option 380hp and chose the 310s. 20kts cruise was fine with me and range was 170NM vs 120NM with the larger engines at 25kts






Pascal:

Regarding the caribean trip, I am somewhat inspired (or fooled) by this account I found searching for ICW info:

http://www.venture.to/carib/journey.html

Although I now don't seem to find the boat's length,I think I read somewhere it was a 35 footer.

Livability, as you call it, will be paramount, as the wife will be spending a LOT of time with me in these quarters! She will be attending the AC Boat Show with me at the end of the month to start looking at those little details that make a difference.

I am not familiar with the "nrs" acronym.. what do you mean by that?

Thanks again,
RobertNJ
 
Why only 30ish feet? Is this a cost issue or for other reasons? What's the real requirement here?
 
quote:

Originally posted by Ghost

Why only 30ish feet? Is this a cost issue or for other reasons? What's the real requirement here?






Good question.

I guess I am going by advice given to me at the NY Boat show regarding my ability to control the boat. I was told that anything bigger than that would require more than one hand on deck. Since my wife is rather petite, I am going by the premise that most of the work will be done by me. What do you think?

Robert in NJ
 
nrs ? i don't know... did i use that ? I used NM, nautical miles, about 10% longer than a land mile...

well, yes some 35ish footers could make the trip... tiaras for instance, i wonder if the boat in that story isn't a tiara... not sure... and other boats designed for offshore fishing. The typical cruiser may not be able to deal with open waters as well; not that it will sink but some hulls are designed to offer higher speed/better economy on flat water. others are deeper and better suited to offshore work.

an express styled boat, like the one in that story, is too small for most couples unless you're talking about a week long cruise which is not what you're looking for.

you're on the right track regarding fuel vs speed. trawlers are great for extended cruising but most will not be able to cruise are higher speed should you want / need to. of course, that capability comes at a price : larger engines (less space in the engine room), turboed (more maintenance), etc...

in case you haven't figured out, boats are collection of compromises :-)

in your shoes, i'd look at a used 42 to 45 footer, diesel, inboard, which will be better suited to your goals and cost the same as a new 30ish foot boat. either a convertible (the cockpit is great in the islands for swimming, etc...) like an older hatteras or bertram or maybe a "fast trawler". i love the Beneteau 42 fast Trawler...i also so a very nice Grand Bank 42 or 43 Europa yesterday at my dock. with larger engines both can cruise at 17 to 18 kts...
 
RobertNJ: Here is a very nice set up vessel that you might want to consider for your purposes. A PDQ 34 Power Catamaran. This boat has twin 4 cyl. diesel inboards which make it very economical to run. A friend of mine took his from the Great Lakes through the Great Circle route down the mighty Mississippi and to the Gulf and then up the Intra Coastal Waterway to the Hudson River and then the Erie Canal back to the Great Lakes. If you bought one new you could pick it up at the factory and then take your trip of a life time. This type of vessel is also in wide use in the Caribbean.
 
"I guess I am going by advice given to me at the NY Boat show regarding my ability to control the boat. I was told that anything bigger than that would require more than one hand on deck. Since my wife is rather petite, I am going by the premise that most of the work will be done by me. What do you think?"

don't count your wife out for being a good deck hand....we have a boat that is sometimes a handful to dock...my wife does quite well in getting us secured to the dock..I do the rest of the line adjusting only cuz I'm more anal about the lines than she is....but she's not the strongest creature on the planet and handles our 9500lbs boat.........second..imho...get as much as much boat as you can afford...ie the largest engines possible for the type of boating your going to do....learn every square inch of the boat...top to bottom...stem to stern....if your going to make these trips, your going to want to be able to make emergency repairs to get yourself to safety....
then finally...practice ...practice...practice....and never..ever approach the dock faster than your willing to bounce off of it...........
good dream to have....I want to go up into the pacnorwest in some of the most outstanding places to boat in....but that's probably a few yrs away......best of luck.....hope your dream comes true....be safe..
 
Here is a very good look at gas against diesel, but info is on Tiara Yachts web site for anyone to see.
Here are the figures Tiara 3600 Open

GAS Crusader 8.1L MPI (385 HP)
Acceleration: 5 seconds to 3500 RPM
Optimum Cruise: 27 MPH ** 3400 RPM / 29.5 MPH ** 3600 RPM
Range at Cruise: 296 / 281 statute miles

DIESEL Cummins QSB5.9 (425 HP)
Acceleration: 15 seconds to 30.6 mph / 23 seconds to 37.2 mph
Optimum Cruise: 29.7 mph ** 2400 RPM / 35.4 mph ** 2800 RPM
Range at Cruise: 409 / 360 statute miles

All Comments copied from BOC member post, but I think they make good sense.
Note how much quicker the gas engined boat is out of the hole. And if the HP of the gas engines was upped to the 425HP range of the Cummins, then it's top speed would be similar too.

The diesel does get 38% better fuel economy at cruise speed, and it will last longer too. But get this - that diesel option costs $92,000 more. That's on a $300k boat. I could fill the boat a few times for that, not mention that I could earn $5000 per year if I invested the difference, which would likely cover my fuel costs forever.
Stolen post placed by
John d
 
Robert, look for a book titled "Honey Lets Buy a Boat" Its about a couple whose dream was to do the Great Circle, took some Power
squadron Courses & researched the type of vessel they wanted. It's a great story about their trip with all the trials and tribulations.
 
I read all the posts. Here's a couple of thoughts.

1. I've heard the right size boat for the Great Loop is the smallest you're comfortable. Skipper Bob use to cite a couple who did it in a Rinker 27 footer. In thinking about our needs, I think a 28-34 sedan style would work fine for two people. All too often in the larger boats, you have an additional berth which is often wasted space.

2. Re. diesel, a new Bayliner 288 runs only 16k extra for a 250 hp diesel. My only concern about it would be that it's enough engine.

3. Finally, I agree about getting the largest engine possible. One reason....noise. For example, I have a 5.0 in my Regal 25 footer. Cruising speed of 30 mph is at 3800 rpm. Whereas on my previous boat, Maxum 2400 with 5.7, the same cruising speed was at 3200 rpms. Quite a bit difference in noise.
 
Back
Top