Epirb / PLB Advice

Capt. Art

Active member
exMember
Joined
Apr 17, 2007
RO Number
25924
Messages
1,538
I'm looking at buying the McMurdo Fastfind Plus 406 PLB with built in GPS. I'm told this is a quality unit? Any negatives about this unit?
 
I understand the McMurdo units are very good, I have the ACR ResQFix PLB unit (from boatFix) it seems to be good but until I use I can’t say ;-)
 
Andy, I hope you never need to use it. My son is bugging me to do some Canyon Fishing this season? I usually only fish off the menu. Fishing aboard does make a mess. With no SSB I figure the unit is a good extra safety measure. My dingy won't have the range to get home nor will the VHF.
 
I wonder if a SPOT unit might be better? It is more versatile that a PLB and can be used on land as well as on the sea. You might want to consider it, too. http://www.findmespot.com/en/

I bought two from Boatfix as Christmas presents.
 
FYI............from "Equipped to Survive" (equipped.com) The last bullet point below would dictate an EPIRB for me for any offshore activies. YMMV:

Q: How does a PLB compare to an EPIRB?
A: The following are the most noticeable and critical differences:

* An EPIRB is bulky and much larger; a PLB is "pocket-sized"

* An EPIRB is designed to operate while floating with the antenna in a transmitting orientation; a PLB is not required to float. Some PLBs do float, but they do not maintain the antenna in a transmitting orientation, it is simply a means to prevent loss by sinking.

* An EPIRB is equipped with a strobe light; a PLB does not have a strobe light

* An EPIRB is equipped with a tether to attach it to the vessel or life raft; a PLB is not required to have a tether, though all have either a wrist strap or some sort of short tether.

* Some EPIRBs are automatically deployed and activated if a vessel sinks (Category 1), others are manually deployed and activated (Category 2); a PLB can only be manually deployed and activated.

* An EPIRB is required to transmit a minimum of 48 hours at -40°C/F; a PLB is required to transmit a minimum of 24 hours at either -40°C/F (Class 1) or -20°C / -4°F (Class 2).

* An EPIRB has a 100 milliwatt 121.5 MHz homing signal; a PLB homer is 25 milliwatts. The practical difference is not significant since the 406 MHz based location information gets any searchers close enough that the lower-powered homing signal is perfectly adequate.

* An EPIRB is technically for use in a marine environment; a PLB can be used anywhere.

* An EPIRB alert is routed automatically to the Coast Guard; a PLB alert is routed first to the Air Force Rescue Coordination Center and it then routed depending upon location or other information and a marine alert may take up to 90 minutes, worse case, to be transferred to the Coast Guard. If there is a GPS location it will be routed directly to the Coast Guard by the computer and if other information from the Emergency Contacts indicates a marine alert it will be routed quicker. Authorities are working on a system to allow quicker response to PLB alerts in the marine environment.
 
It appears that the unit I inquired about does cover all the points (except it is manual operate not automatic) you listed to qualify as an EPIRB. I'm not 100% sure of what makes one an EPIRB verses a PLB? Maybe the technology has improved in this model to cover both areas?
 
I have 2 of the ACR 406 with internal GPS units and 2 of the ACR PLBs. Never had to use them just registered them with NOAA after I purchased them. Just checked today and updated some of the information. On the EPIRBS they send you a sticker and paperwork after registering them on the PLB's I think I just got paperwork only. I also think there is no reference to a vessel on the PLB paperwork. The stuff stays in the ships 3 ring log book binder. I have a complete library of all the electronic equipment on m boat for quick reference if there is a problem. If you want to get a SPOT that is ok but I would never trust my life on a private company that to be honest has been days away from bankruptcy since having problems with their telephone amplifiers on their satellites (GlobalStar). Evidently their data is the only thing that works properly but I question that because how would you really know if it took 20 minutes for your data message to get through? Bill
 
Up to 90 minutes with a PLB......as previously eluded to above.
 
quote:

Originally posted by V1rowT8

Up to 90 minutes with a PLB......as previously eluded to above.




No the Globalstar device (SPOT) is not really considered a PLB it is even worse I do not believe they are registered with NOAA someone correct me if I am wrong. I think they are only registered with a public company (Globalstar) that has it's NOC in Texas. Bill
 
SPOT Satellite Messenger Emergency FAQs

We have been able to test the newest product of Globalstar’s, the SPOT Satellite Messenger. This new device is a GPS satellite messenger that will send messages to friends and family to alert them that you are alright or that you are in need of assistance. Also, it has the capability to alert 911 when you are in a life threatening situation. After using the device for a couple of trips around our city we had some questions. Our main questions are about the 911 deployment. Here are the questions that we had and the answers that we have received so far.

Who and where is the 911 emergency call center that the 911 messages are routed to?

The call center that answers the emergency 911 messages that are sent from SPOT is located in Houston, TX. The name of the company is GEO’S. They are an international emergency call center.

How long does it take for 911 to be deployed after the button has been pressed?

After the first emergency message has been received at GEO’S they will attempt to contact your first and second contact people to confirm that there is an emergency. If this is confirmed or there is no answer by the time the second message is received (a message is sent every five minutes) GEO’S will use your latitude and longitude to alert the necessary emergency personnel to your location. SPOT is accurate up to a 20 ft radius.

If buried by an avalanche or caught in a mudslide what are the chances that SPOT will still transmit messages?

SPOT is a satellite messenger. It does need to have a clear view of the sky to transmit messages. Messages will probably still transmit through a light snow cover however underneath heavy mud or snow there is no guarantee that it messages will be sent.

What does GEOS stand for?

The name GEOS is derived from the ancient Greek "geos", which means "World" - GEOS is both an entire world of travel safety and travel security processes as well as being a travel safety and travel security program with worldwide scope (GEOS is the brand name of Travel Safety Group).

GEOS has also been appointed as the global 911 Responder for Globalstar SPOT (Satellite PersOnal Tracker). Please feel free to contact GEOS if you have any further queries.

Information Provided by the GEOS Contact Administrator
 
PLB or EPIRB?

PLBs were designed to give people in trouble a good chance of being rescued, whether they get lost or hurt in the backcountry, fall overboard, or their vessel sinks from under them. However, like all emergency equipment, they must be used correctly and within the limits of their performance.

A PLB is not a substitute for an EPIRB aboard an offshore vessel, largely because PLBs have a battery life in the neighborhood of only 24 hours. While your approximate location may be determined by the satellite-signaling 406Mhz beacon, it is the 121.5Mhz homing beacon that will bring a rescuer close to you. If you are well offshore, it could be far longer than 24 hours before a surface vessel can reach you. Furthermore, PLBs were designed to be carried by an individual; they lack the robust construction and permanent-mounting capability of a full-sized EPIRB.

For mariners, we believe that a PLB is a great device for two purposes.

First, its short-range 121.5Mhz homing signal is highly useful as an overboard recovery device — if have on board a radio direction finder that receives 121.5Mhz.

Second, a PLB can be a life-saver for near-shore fishermen, sea kayakers, and others who do not travel far from shore.

For offshore vessels, our strong advice is to stick to a rugged, vessel-mounted, long-lived EPIRB for the ultimate fall-back safety device for your vessel. Equip yourself and each crew member with a good auto-inflatable vest, a tether, and jacklines — and use them. If you want the additional security of a homing device for locating crew overboard, make sure your vessel is also equipped with a suitable RDF
 
I carry a SPOT all the time on the boat. I mainly use it for family and friends to track us on long trips. When offshore, I rent an EPIRB from BoatUS. If I ever have the need (and I really hope I don't), I will activate both of them and see who arrives first (private industry w/ whom I have a contract, or the US Gov't...hmmm)
 
A little about the list above:
quote:


FYI............from "Equipped to Survive" (equipped.com) The last bullet point below would dictate an EPIRB for me for any offshore activies. YMMV:

Q: How does a PLB compare to an EPIRB?
A: The following are the most noticeable and critical differences:

* An EPIRB is bulky and much larger; a PLB is "pocket-sized"





Translation, if you can afford it, each pfd can have its own.
quote:



* An EPIRB is designed to operate while floating with the antenna in a transmitting orientation; a PLB is not required to float. Some PLBs do float, but they do not maintain the antenna in a transmitting orientation, it is simply a means to prevent loss by sinking.





They may not float, but if you put a piece of velcro on the back of the pepirb and on the shoulder of your pfd they float as well as you do...and mark your exact position
quote:



* An EPIRB is equipped with a strobe light; a PLB does not have a strobe light





True, but since mine is attached to my pfd, not only is there a strobe light within inches (on my other shoulder's velcro), but there are hand held flares in the pocket a few inches in the other direction... so not that big of a deal to me
quote:



* An EPIRB is equipped with a tether to attach it to the vessel or life raft; a PLB is not required to have a tether, though all have either a wrist strap or some sort of short tether.





see above first. Then forget the wrist strap. Water and antenna don't go well. Shoulder of life jacket is much better.

quote:



* Some EPIRBs are automatically deployed and activated if a vessel sinks (Category 1), others are manually deployed and activated (Category 2); a PLB can only be manually deployed and activated.





The automatic activation is triggered when the EPIRB is released from its bracket. Category I EPIRBs are housed in a special bracket equipped with a hydrostatic release. This mechanism releases the EPIRB at a water depth of 3-10 feet. The bouyant EPIRB then floats to the surface and begins transmitting. If you own a Category I EPIRB, it's very important that you mount it outside your vessel's cabin where it will be able to "float free" of the sinking vessel.

Great...if you have time or the ability to grab your free floating epirb. What if you are so busy gathering your family together that it separates (floats away) from you. Yeah, it will put rescues in the general area, but the pepirb on my shoulder will put them to me!

quote:



* An EPIRB is required to transmit a minimum of 48 hours at -40°C/F; a PLB is required to transmit a minimum of 24 hours at either -40°C/F (Class 1) or -20°C / -4°F (Class 2).






For a ship at sea, 48 hours might be a reasonable time to wait for rescue (I guess). For most of us near shore folks, I don't think thats a huge issue.

quote:



* An EPIRB has a 100 milliwatt 121.5 MHz homing signal; a PLB homer is 25 milliwatts. The practical difference is not significant since the 406 MHz based location information gets any searchers close enough that the lower-powered homing signal is perfectly adequate.

* An EPIRB is technically for use in a marine environment; a PLB can be used anywhere.





During the winter when I'm not using the boat, I keep my pfd in the back of my truck. If the worst should happen (run off road, badly injured no cell phone service or lost in forest stuck in snow like the guy from cnn) I can fire off my pepirb for help.

quote:



* An EPIRB alert is routed automatically to the Coast Guard; a PLB alert is routed first to the Air Force Rescue Coordination Center and it then routed depending upon location or other information and a marine alert may take up to 90 minutes, worse case, to be transferred to the Coast Guard. If there is a GPS location it will be routed directly to the Coast Guard by the computer and if other information from the Emergency Contacts indicates a marine alert it will be routed quicker. Authorities are working on a system to allow quicker response to PLB alerts in the marine environment.





Well I can state from personal experience that the CG version of the McMurdo pepirbs hit the sats and get position to the CG very very fast. I had a newer crewman on board my vessel this summer. As we were doing our pre-underway checklist we get to the "Test Crew PEPIRBs" line. I hit the button, get the red then green light, Mike hits the button, gets the red then green light, Sue pulls the tab and gets a Christmas tree. By the time my brain thawed enough to yell "holy %^*& get a screw driver and get the battery off" Sector had done a DSC query to my radio for a position (that was the other noise I didn't recognize) then called to ask how many crew are in the water.

I can't tell you the total time elapse because time stood still when I looked over and saw the fully deployed antenna instead of the green light and tone. But two minutes...tops? Needless to say we had some explaining to do later on.
 
The McMurdo units are issued to the Coast Guard Auxiliary.
Scheduled battery replacement is every five years.
Batteries can be difficult to obtain if you have the unit longer then five years.
Just a thought to keep in mind.
 
Battery replacement for the Auxiliary is a snap. You give the OTO in your DirAux the old dated battery and he/she gives you a new one on the spot. Least that's the way it works here. Its a required piece of equipment owned by the CG. No Pepirb, no patrol.

BTW I don't think those are just for the Auxiliary. They look exactly like what the Active Boat Crews are carrying. Perhaps NC or one of our other resident Coasties can verify...
 
Be very careful replacing the battery. The cases on those units like to crack if you overtighten that screw the slightest bit. More to say on EPIRBS vs PLB's, but pressed for time right now. I'll be back to cut and paste from last time this was brought up. The 90 mins to get to a CG RCC vs an AF RCC is pure silliness. Look at the SARSAT site, at how the system works, how each step relates to the last.
 
Hey Mike,

I don't know that much about this subject, but I think what "equipped" is trying to say is that direct AF RCC notification is instantaneous with PLB's, but subsequent relaying through the marine sector could take UP TO 90 minutes, depending on the locale, and successive relays which must take place.

I would bet that the quoted time is a worse case scenario, and is more of a disclaimer than any reasonably typical scenario. In theory at least, the EPIRB would be faster, as it's straight to the marine authorities. Killing a fly with a sledge hammer.....that's for you to decide. For me, I'm just happy to talk this through, as I'm learning more as this thread progresses.

Truth be known, those of us who think these kind of things through are probably the people least likely to ever need them.
 
As far as the notification thing, there shouldn't be ANY relay from an AFRCC to a USCG RCC. Signal goes from device to satellite, either a LEOS or GEOS satellite in the COSPAS-SARSAT constellation. From there, it transmits the hex code embedded in the signal to a ground station the next time it's in view, if it can't do so immediately. From there, it goes to a local user terminal that bounces it right to USMCC in Suitland, Maryland (maybe this is where the confusion was created, as this may be an AF facility). From there, dependent on the positioning data, it goes to the appropriate RCC - be it a USCG RCC for maritime alerts, or an USAF RCC for inland alerts.

Few things above that struck me:

-The strobe light. Yes, an EPIRB has a built in strobe, which is of ENORMOUS benefit. However, I've yet to see a device with a strobe that I believe could be seen from more than a couple hundred yards. Whether you use a PLB or an EPIRB, you'd be BEST served with a REAL strobe. Aside from electronic position broadcasting devices, a strobe might be THE msot effective way of advertising your position inthe water on a dark night. A radio transmission usable by radio direction finding equipment, such as the 121.5MHz 'screamer' on an EPIRB/PLB, in conjunction with a =real= strobe light, and you'll stand out like Rosie O'Donnell at a salad bar.

-PLB registrations SHOULD have a sticker, as well. They won't last long in a PFD pocket without some packaging tape or contact paper over them.

-I've never heard before that PLB's only transmit the 121.5 at 1/4 of the power that the EPIRB's do. I'll have to look into that. Good thing to know, but again, the positioning data from a 406 is good enough to get you within DF range quickly enough - with a REAL STROBE that DF should put a VISIBLE "high intensity white light flashing at regular intervals from 50-70 times per minute" right off the bow.

-Philyteach's post above is almost dead on. VERY good information there, except that most automatically activated EPIRB's activate by electrical continuity between two screws on the case. A good soaking will sometimes activate these devices (I've had a call on the VHF asking me to check my EPIRB within 5 minutes of the first time it could have got wet - not too bad at all), and one laying in bilge water with a broken off antenna will STILL hit the satellite and cause three guys to miss a really, REALLY good lunch searching through a mooring field for it.

-Velcro idea is a good one. Next time you see a CG boat passing by, take a look at their vests and helmets. Good reasons for those little velcro patches. (Strobes, originally, but now PLB's, or P-EPIRBS, as well.)
 
Back
Top