A little about the list above:
quote:
FYI............from "Equipped to Survive" (equipped.com) The last bullet point below would dictate an EPIRB for me for any offshore activies. YMMV:
Q: How does a PLB compare to an EPIRB?
A: The following are the most noticeable and critical differences:
* An EPIRB is bulky and much larger; a PLB is "pocket-sized"
Translation, if you can afford it, each pfd can have its own.
quote:
* An EPIRB is designed to operate while floating with the antenna in a transmitting orientation; a PLB is not required to float. Some PLBs do float, but they do not maintain the antenna in a transmitting orientation, it is simply a means to prevent loss by sinking.
They may not float, but if you put a piece of velcro on the back of the pepirb and on the shoulder of your pfd they float as well as you do...and mark your
exact position
quote:
* An EPIRB is equipped with a strobe light; a PLB does not have a strobe light
True, but since mine is attached to my pfd, not only is there a strobe light within inches (on my other shoulder's velcro), but there are hand held flares in the pocket a few inches in the other direction... so not that big of a deal to me
quote:
* An EPIRB is equipped with a tether to attach it to the vessel or life raft; a PLB is not required to have a tether, though all have either a wrist strap or some sort of short tether.
see above first. Then forget the wrist strap. Water and antenna don't go well. Shoulder of life jacket is much better.
quote:
* Some EPIRBs are automatically deployed and activated if a vessel sinks (Category 1), others are manually deployed and activated (Category 2); a PLB can only be manually deployed and activated.
The automatic activation is triggered when the EPIRB is released from its bracket. Category I EPIRBs are housed in a special bracket equipped with a hydrostatic release. This mechanism releases the EPIRB at a water depth of 3-10 feet. The bouyant EPIRB then floats to the surface and begins transmitting. If you own a Category I EPIRB, it's very important that you mount it outside your vessel's cabin where it will be able to "float free" of the sinking vessel.
Great...if you have time or the ability to grab your free floating epirb. What if you are so busy gathering your family together that it separates (floats away) from you. Yeah, it will put rescues in the general area, but the pepirb on my shoulder will put them to me!
quote:
* An EPIRB is required to transmit a minimum of 48 hours at -40°C/F; a PLB is required to transmit a minimum of 24 hours at either -40°C/F (Class 1) or -20°C / -4°F (Class 2).
For a ship at sea, 48 hours might be a reasonable time to wait for rescue (I guess). For most of us near shore folks, I don't think thats a huge issue.
quote:
* An EPIRB has a 100 milliwatt 121.5 MHz homing signal; a PLB homer is 25 milliwatts. The practical difference is not significant since the 406 MHz based location information gets any searchers close enough that the lower-powered homing signal is perfectly adequate.
* An EPIRB is technically for use in a marine environment; a PLB can be used anywhere.
During the winter when I'm not using the boat, I keep my pfd in the back of my truck. If the worst should happen (run off road, badly injured no cell phone service or lost in forest stuck in snow like the guy from cnn) I can fire off my pepirb for help.
quote:
* An EPIRB alert is routed automatically to the Coast Guard; a PLB alert is routed first to the Air Force Rescue Coordination Center and it then routed depending upon location or other information and a marine alert may take up to 90 minutes, worse case, to be transferred to the Coast Guard. If there is a GPS location it will be routed directly to the Coast Guard by the computer and if other information from the Emergency Contacts indicates a marine alert it will be routed quicker. Authorities are working on a system to allow quicker response to PLB alerts in the marine environment.
Well I can state from personal experience that the CG version of the McMurdo pepirbs hit the sats and get position to the CG very very fast. I had a newer crewman on board my vessel this summer. As we were doing our pre-underway checklist we get to the "Test Crew PEPIRBs" line. I hit the button, get the red then green light, Mike hits the button, gets the red then green light, Sue pulls the tab and gets a Christmas tree. By the time my brain thawed enough to yell "holy %^*& get a screw driver and get the battery off" Sector had done a DSC query to my radio for a position (that was the other noise I didn't recognize) then called to ask how many crew are in the water.
I can't tell you the total time elapse because time stood still when I looked over and saw the fully deployed antenna instead of the green light and tone. But two minutes...tops? Needless to say we had some explaining to do later on.