EPIRBs, Update- decision time

pdecat

Well-known member
Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
842
Messages
11,588
What EPIRBs do people prefer for near coastal use and why?
 
406 manually deployed without the GPS. Its the most economical so you are more likely to actually put one on your boat. And then, when the batteries get to "replacement age" (five years) you can buy another unit to add to the boat. Nothing says you can have only one. If the CG gets multiple signals tracing back to the same owner, they'll probably show more interest.

Rather than automatic deployment with a GPS signal also being transmitted, spend your time and money in developing a good ditching procedure and a good life raft or rescue pod.
 
I'd be interested in hearing from November Charlie but I believe that a signal with a location that shows a vessel offshore will receive a faster response and higher priority than one with no position information. The signal goes through several locations, from the main receiving unit down to the local station.
 
We had a case of this down here in So. FL on Sunday. CG Sector Miami sent out a Pan Pan, saying they had a 406 transmission, gave name, name of owner and type of boat (a center console), but no location, just "... all boaters keep a close look out..." on about the second or third time, someone radio'd them and asked if they had an idea where this was, and the response was "in the area of Bimini". The subsequent broadcasts still omitted that information. So, a whole lot of good that non GPS EPIRB did; I don't think it is a good place to scrimp if you are venturing off shore.

I am curious why they left off even the general location info. A huge area is covered by those broadcasts.

George
Hatteras 56MY
 
if you are on a budget the "find me spot" system is far more economical and i think a good solution for coastal cruising.
 
I have an Epirb for the 48 and in my liferaft but nothing on the center console. Looking at buying the SPOT now.

Gonna be in the Keys for 10 days with a 29 CC fishing out 25 miles from shore, this might come in handy.
 
The Spot is a very cool product and certainly better than nothing, but don't try float testing it, though it supposedly floats. By it's nature, it will take extra time for the appropriate rescue assets to be contacted and deployed. If you are just on lakes, rivers, and protected parts of the ICW, I suppose it would be ok, but I wouldn't stake my life on it.

George
 
The Spot does look cool & at the Boatfix price of $111 Its a steal

BUT the Basic Service is $100 a year –every year. And who can say if they will keep it at this cost
I bought a ResQFix 406 GPS PLB from BoatFix for a little over $500 last year, if I bought the spot I would have had $300 already spent on the unit and the 2 years of service.

So as time goes by the PLB/EPIRB becomes a cheaper better solution
 
I've had a SPOT for a year now. They are very cool. Take a look at our trip last year to the Abacos:

http://www.undock.com

All the waypoints shown came from the SPOT. Friends & family could track us in real-time. Very nice. However, I like redundancy, so I always rent an EPIRB too. Although I might buy one this spring from Les.
 
quote:

Originally posted by abalmuth

The Spot does look cool & at the Boatfix price of $111 Its a steal

BUT the Basic Service is $100 a year –every year. And who can say if they will keep it at this cost
I bought a ResQFix 406 GPS PLB from BoatFix for a little over $500 last year, if I bought the spot I would have had $300 already spent on the unit and the 2 years of service.

So as time goes by the PLB/EPIRB becomes a cheaper better solution






SPOTs are nice, cheap and better than nothing.

And while EPIRBs and GPIRBs are the way to go, with figuring the long term costs of them don't forget you have to replace the battery every 5 years. And that can be $200+.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Capt. Bill1

quote:

Originally posted by abalmuth

The Spot does look cool & at the Boatfix price of $111 Its a steal

BUT the Basic Service is $100 a year –every year. And who can say if they will keep it at this cost
I bought a ResQFix 406 GPS PLB from BoatFix for a little over $500 last year, if I bought the spot I would have had $300 already spent on the unit and the 2 years of service.

So as time goes by the PLB/EPIRB becomes a cheaper better solution






SPOTs are nice, cheap and better than nothing.

And while EPIRBs and GPIRBs are the way to go, with figuring the long term costs of them don't forget you have to replace the battery every 5 years. And that can be $200+.






I’m with you Bill, Spot is much better than nothing- and its neat have the tracks that Kurt posted- But Pascal did likewise on his trips with Google earth and no Spot
PLB-$500 to buy- $200 for Battery in five years- so cost for 10 years =$700.00
Cost for Spot for 10 years is: $111 to buy - $1000 for 10 years of Service =$1,111.00
 
To my wife and I they are like fire extinguishers you can never have enough and they need to be strategically installed. You also need to wear a GPS based PLB and have it attached to your type 1's as we do. With the new AIS Class B I think there is also an emergency button on the Nauticast we have and will be installing soon. One other point make sure your GPS is hooked to your permanent mount VHF radios with the proper MMSI programmed.

Bill
 
I have owned EPIRB's since 1975, and for the larger boats, crossing oceans we had two manually operated units. Currently we have two Personal Locator Beacons, GPS built in plus the interface to the ship's GPS. This allows a "hot" GPS location, without a cold start up--and less time. We each will wear the PLB, along with a waterproof hand held VHG and a strobe light on our persons (Life jackets have pockets and fasteners--all are tethered to us.

The PLB can be used on land, in the dinghy and Kayak. I highly recommend the GPS model--it gives location to at least 100 yards, and vastly narrows the search area. The GPS enabled unit will give you localization within 0.008 of a mile area. The position by triangulation with the 406 satellites--give about a 10 sq mile search area--this is a huge difference--and especially in cold water, can be the difference between life and death.

The PLB stays with the person--especially useful if you fall over board, or are separated from the boat.

SPOT: Good for tracking and telling friends and family you are OK. BUT--it does NOT have a homing beacon., which the PLB does have. One solution to this is getting one of the Standard Horizon 850 VHF, which has a built in strobe and DSC. Consider that the DSC range of a hand held in the water is only 5 or so miles. So although SPOT is nice, it is not a substitute for an EPIRB.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Les Hall

I'd be interested in hearing from November Charlie but I believe that a signal with a location that shows a vessel offshore will receive a faster response and higher priority than one with no position information. The signal goes through several locations, from the main receiving unit down to the local station.






It goes without saying that an alert within shore-based resource range, with no positioning data, will take longer than one with a resolved position - as there would be no way to know who to launch are where to send them. By the time the Motor Lifeboat Coxswain even hears about the alert, the position has already been resolved enough to get them underway.

As far as offshore alerts, I'm not 100% sure, but I have a colleague that is. Was a SAR Controller down south before he was a Lifeboat Coxswain, gave a big long spiel after a recent incident in the N. Shore area about EPIRB alerting and response times, so let me run it by him and get his take. He'll have far more and far better information than me. Last ten years, I've been the guy that goes out and gets cold and wet, but he's been the guy in the command center figuring out which station/boat gets to go get cold and wet. I'll e-mail this thread to him tomorrow morning.
 
A popular option is an EPIRB with a link to a GPS signal supplied by another instrument. IF that link is lost, what signal does the EPIRB transmit? Nothing? Or the last known position?

I have an EPIRB with such a link and I don't trust it. I recognize the triangulation by the satellites is less precise and more time consuming but I think the transmission of an incorrect GPS location would be worse.

I think the answer is to have not only the EPIRB but also a means of surviving 48+? hours.
 
Just received an e-mail this evening from NOAA for the every-2 yr. online registration renewals (free) . In a couple minutes I updated the owner /vessel/contact info for both my 406 EPIRB & PLB/(gps) and they will now send my renewed-registration decals to stick on the units so I will be all set for that part of the CGAUX Voluntary Inspection & occasional surprise CG safety inspections.
 
I ordered a SPOT today from Boatfix, already shipped out and I'll have it Monday. Thanks Mike and Les!

I like the fact that I can punch in fishing spots I go to and then see them and my entire fishing trip on Google Maps when I get home.

It will live on my center console this year when I go out fishing.
 
"... GPS signal supplied by another instrument. IF that link is lost, what signal does the EPIRB transmit? Nothing? Or the last known position?" -- rbmitchell

AFAIK, that type of EBIRB will transmit last known position, which, frankly, is a very valuable commodity. As NC has stated, when given a last known position, a likely current location guesstimate becomes possible. Anything that can reduce the size of the area that needs to be searched is valuable, and Last Known is a very important piece of the puzzle.

Obviously, a -current- position is even more valuable, but a solid, accurate last known ( with time ) is a very good thing. Much better than just a spouse report that states "he is 12 hours overdue, and his likely position is somewhere in a 600 sq mi ( or more ) area. ( btw: 25 mi x 25 mi = 625 sq mi ). It is very easy to have a good float plan, the still leaves a search area in excess of 1000 sq mi. SO, any location is better than none, old, vague info is better, last known is actually pretty good, and a current, accurate position may have you popped out of the water too quickly to finish your cigar... Don't forget: in the unlikely event that you actually end up in the water, there is a high probability that you may have been injured during the event. Rapid recovery sounds pretty good, even when I am just sitting at my desk, and I am sure that if I have broken or bleeding pieces/parts I would really, really want a quick recovery.

--

Almost, but not quite off topic:

If you do, in fact, get recovered by the USCG, please be sure to do something nice for them. At a minimum, send the SAR unit a written ( not just an e-mail ) thank you. If you are so inclined, and it is practical, -call- their unit commander and try to do something nice for the guys ( and gals ) ; the unit commander may have suggestions that are most suitable for the local crews. Yes. It "is their job" and they will do it as well as they possibly can without you lifting a finger, but they took risks to help you, so proper thanks are certainly appropriate.
 
Thanks Bill, I didn't know whether such GPSs transmitted the time of fix or not.

And supporting the USCG is never off topic. I have never had a less than very cordial boarding in six events. I rely on them to be there.

I just found out that a friend of mine for about six years, who is obviously a bit older, was in the USCG runing LCILs (landing craft) onto Okinawa way back when.
 
Back
Top