Fuel burn gauges???

jdshep

Member
exMember
Joined
Jan 26, 2006
RO Number
20051
Messages
241
Does anyone know what it takes to add fuel burn guages to a Meridian 411 2005 with Cummin's 370's?
John d
 
If anything about my boat was cheap i would be shocked. I take that back I just bought two $1.50 screen door rollers for $17.00.
John d
 
Floscan makes fuel monitoring gauges that should work for your engines. They are fairly expensive and more complicated to install for diesels than for gas engines because the fuel returned to the tanks by the engines needs to be accounted for also.
 
It's quite a job to install a fuel flow monitoring system, especially on FI engines. How mechanically inclined are you? You have to install sensors in the fuel supply and return lines, install the gauge and all the wiring.
 
Projects that could result in something that works now not working make me very nervous. I was hoping for something simple, maybe something you splice into a fuel line and it sends to a remote gauge, hopefully a wireless sending unit. Just wishful thinking I guess. Do not want any big projects or anything that keep me off the water.
John D

quote:

Originally posted by Ron

It's quite a job to install a fuel flow monitoring system, especially on FI engines. How mechanically inclined are you? You have to install sensors in the fuel supply and return lines, install the gauge and all the wiring.




 
The Floscan gauge does all the calculating but you do have to install one sensor in each supply line and one in each return. Check the Floscan site. The last time I looked, the setup price was $1000++ and fuel was still US$0.85 per gallon. Floscan is down, fuel is up.

I am likely to add the equipment to my 408 this summer before heading to FL from NJ.
 
I opted for the Lowrence fuel flow gauge because of the NMEA 2000 integration. It is connected to my GPS for real MPG readings. You can connect about all your electronics, sensors and displays that are NMEA 2000 compatible. Running the cable wasn't hard.
 
I went to Floscan and watched the movie, I guess i would not want to take this on, but I might be willing to have it done. Looks fairly easy, but it also looks like something I could screw up without much effort (from movie warning, air bubbles etc) so i will pass if I can't get pro's to do it for me.
John d
2005 Meridian 411 SB (2) cummin's 370hp
 
I had floscans put in on my Volvo TAMD74P's this past summer. By profession, I have a very technical job, but there is no way I could have done THAT job. Pay a pro to do it... about $5,000. Glad I have them though. Main use is for fine tuning the "sweet spot" I also like having a firm grip on total fuel on board.
 
John, a fuel flow monitor is a great tool for determining optimum cruise speed and can actually add life to your engines by finding the proper operating range where they aren't being stressed from excessive loading by incorrect props or improper operating speed. That's especially important for diesel engines.

I installed my FloScan and it took pretty much an entire weekend. Sensor placement is critical and that's where you can get it wrong and have problems with accuracy. There's not much to installing the gauge itself, other than running all the wiring. My neighbor installed a FloScan himself on his 47 Searay and he's an ER surgeon. I was pretty impressed. I didn't know that surgeons could handle a wrench, but wasn't too surprised that he could use a hole saw. Again, it depends on your mechanical competency.
 
They seem like a waste of money when you look at the test results of your model boat.Your worst and best cruising speeds for optimum mpg are within .1 mpg at cruise. It varies from .8 to .9 mpg on the test results.1800=13mph 2400=22mph.9mpg. I see no payoff for 20,000 miles.Thats at 5000 dollar cost.
 
Ironworks....

I like the way you broke it down and sounds like a waste of money unless the boat already came with it....although if one were runnings gassers it should have a better payoff

Mark
 
Floscans range from $500-2,000 per engine (diesels and FI engines require two systems) depending on which series instrument you desire. The basic 6500 at street price of about $500 ($1k for twin diesels) will tell you everything you need to know. The pay back varies on how well your boat was set up by the factory, or what condition it is currently in. The installation of my Floscan quickly showed that my props were not correctly pitched and that my fuel burn was high due to the overload on the engines. I knocked fuel consumption down by a total of six GPH (3 per engine) after getting the props tuned properly and finding the right engine speed. More importantly, it added life to my engines by doing so. Overloading gas engines is stressful and inefficient but downright death for diesels. I was also surprised to find that my efficiency (mpg) increased at a slightly higher cruising speed than what I had been running. The payback for my system was in the first year. That was six years ago and probably around 8,000 gallons of fuel burned. At an efficiency gain of 6 gph, which equates to over 20%, at an average fuel cost over the past six years, that’s about $3k in reduced fuel consumption. Not a bad return on a $500 investment for my Twinscan.
 
I don't know where Ironworks got his data, but .1mgp between cruising speeds is not even remotely close on my boat. It can vary from about ? (.8) to 2.8+. That's a LOT of fuel on one trip between those ranges. At $2000 per fill up, I can earn the cost back pretty quick.

Information is power.

bp
 
I got my data from the site that tested that model boat with those engines. We are talking cruising speeds here,read my post again.Your numbers are flawed ghost they look like idle to wot speeds on your boat not the differenc in mpg at cruising speeds like I posted.
 
What are you calling cruising speed? I'm not quoting idle speed, but I may be quoting hull speed or very near it. "Cruising Speed" is another one of those ambiguous terms. Some mean it to be 80% of WOT speed. Others the speed the engine runs under the least strain. Others very often use it to mean the most "efficient" speed, which is often around WOT.

So...no, I don't think my numbers are wrong. In fact I know the higher efficient ones are correct becasue that's what I get. I'm not sure about the speeds closer to WOT because I don't operate my boat there (can't afford the fuel).

I do suspect you think the term cruising speed means something other than the most efficient speed, so a definition of otherwise ambiguous terms is probably needed. For a boat like mine, knowing the difference between near hull speed is huge and definately more than .1mpg difference, more like .5 to 1mpg difference for a 1-2knot speed difference in that area.

bp
 
Ghost There is nothing ambiguous about the cruising speeds .I posted them.The point of it is that the maximum fuel wasted at any speed between those two speeds amounts to .1mpg difference.Hardly a reason to install gauges at the price they charge.And fyi I do have fuel flow meters on my engines.No comparison to the cost and installation of the ones we are talking about in this thread.jdshep you can google for the boat test, it has a ton of info on your boats performance.
 
Ironworks,
I printed BoatTest.com test of my boat which shows a sweet spot at 2250 where the test boat got 1.09 mpg and like you said going up all the way to 3000 rpm only drops you too .89, however it seems the boat does not like 2000 rpm as there is a hole in the curve where you only get .63 mph. Flowscan would be great to have, but for $5000 I will just keep the engines above 2200 or below 1750 rpm (1.04 mph) and skip 2000 rpm area all together. I printed the test results and will keep a copy in my "Helm cheat sheet book" I am making. The 3000 rpm 30.1 mph is just about exactly what my boat has shown on GPS at WOT just over 3000 rpm.
Thanks for the info
John d
 
Back
Top