There seem to be as many arguments for leaving empty vs. leaving full. I know in the gas world, volvo recommends empty and mercruiser recommends full. So without a mythbusters episode, I'm not sure there's a right answer from a science standpoint. And both approaches seem to work out fine come spring.
But from an economic perspective it's another story. Like playing in the futures market. Will it be cheaper now or in the spring when you go for the first fill-up. I go empty in the fall and fill in the spring. Each year for the past 3 I've been burned with higher prices in the spring then in the Fall. It seems like with summer driving season coming, prices start heading up. I may need to start hedging my fuel position each fall like Southwest Airlines!