GPS Satellite Failures

I for one think this will be a good thing. The failure of the GPS system will once again keep all the amateurs close to shore. I'm talking the ones that just follow waypoints or a pointer on a chartplotter. If you cannot navigate (DR or Celestial) you shouldn't be offshore anyway. This should also relieve a lot of pressure on the fishing stock at deep reefs and wrecks.
 
Have to agree with Capt Bill1. Most of the world (not to mention the US Navy) probably navigates with GPS...

But it brings to mind the old DECCA system... If you wanted to use it you had to PAY...
 
quote:

Originally posted by L. Keith

I for one think this will be a good thing.





And EPIRBs with GPS won't be as accurate. People hiking won't be as safe. Those with PLB's in the middle of nowhere skiing or camping will be harder to find.

How is this a "good thing"?

My solution is to make GPS satellite usage free for US taxpayers. Everybody else can pay a fee. Why are we giving it away anyway?
 
quote:

Originally posted by stmbtwle

Have to agree with Capt Bill1. Most of the world (not to mention the US Navy) probably navigates with GPS...

But it brings to mind the old DECCA system... If you wanted to use it you had to PAY...






The navy (is supposed to ) still use celestial as a primary means of navigation for just the reasons cited in the article. Long before the civilian market had access to the satellites, a Canoe U bean counter wanted to delete celestial nav from the curriculum. Needless to say, the arsewhoopin' was not pretty.
 
Looks like I'll have to break out the old Loran C unit!
 
quote:

Originally posted by L. Keith

I for one think this will be a good thing. The failure of the GPS system will once again keep all the amateurs close to shore. I'm talking the ones that just follow waypoints or a pointer on a chartplotter. If you cannot navigate (DR or Celestial) you shouldn't be offshore anyway. This should also relieve a lot of pressure on the fishing stock at deep reefs and wrecks.





L Keith, I am surprized by your answer .. I usually find you answers to be right on target, but I can't agree here. I have been boating for more than 59 years, and yes, I can read a chart and plot a course. I can triangulate a position and do a pretty good job of DR navigation, but I love my GPS. I keep track of my position on a paper chart as well, but usually the GPS is primary.
 
Well if GPS goes away, I still won't stop and ask for directions, I am a man damit!!!

It will also save me money, my wife won't be able to find the mall!!
 
Ya’ll don’t get it. Only rich folks use GPS and the man uses it to track criminals on their cell phones so it don’t fit into the new priorities.
 
quote:

Originally posted by CurrentSea





The GPS system can not fail you want your cellphone to work? Satellite phones and many other GPS based systems? All cellular carriers get thier timing from GPS signals. There used to be something called a Rabidium standard that kept time but in the age of simalcast communications they will all fail if there was a major outage of GPS including most police department and federal agency's communications systems.
The military's communication systems require GPS to operate, not for nsavigation but percise timing.
Bill
 
When ever a government agency demands additional money they try to manipulate public sentiment by declaring the sky is falling. The money may actually be necessary in this case as they do need to upgrade the system to compete with the new GPS system that the Europeans will soon be putting into operation called the Galileo global positioning system which is said to have better technology, better accuracy, with new satellites.
 
Some USAF General's head and retirement should be on a platter. Trust me....Do that and the replacement birds will be up in a week.
 
adru has got it.

As for giving away GPS signals to foreigners. Because it benefits us. For instance, we have more airplanes crossing the North Atlantic every night (and my airline has the most planes). The traffic density on the North Atlantic would not be possible without high order navigation. The plan is to double the airways across the North Atlantic next year by reducing lateral separation from 60 nm to 30nm. GPS will be required to do this. By giving away the signal, we get all other world airlines to go along with this plan.

In the same way, the GPS RNAV approaches to facility limited third world airports such as Quito, Ecuador save US airlines 100s of millions of dollars a year. Our divert rate for that airport was 33% until GPS RNAV approach was enbaled. Now we are at about 2%.

So giving away the signal is pretty much in our own interest.
 
Hogan not only Loran but the Enhanced Loran was scrapped (so far) against DHS superiors wishes. In fact there is no budget to even keep the current Loran C system operational, barely. I wouldn't worry too many devices that the government and the public use depend on accurate timing that only GPS signals can provide. They will find the money even if it comes from private groups. The Russians are building their own GPS system GLONASS. I would bet my business this will get funding and back on schedule ASAP. After all the POTUS's Blackberry will not work without solid GPS timing for Verizon Wireless data. Position fixes are only a small part of the use for GPS.
Bill
 
OK, GeeBee, I get it. Thanks for the clarification. But at least I was right on the point that we're all safer with it.
 
A lot of fear mongering going on here. Go to the US naval observatory page and check out the status of the satellites. The latest series are behind launch schedule but last year: GPS IIR-19M (SVN48/PRN07) was launched on 15 MAR 2008 at 0610 UT from Cape Canaveral, Florida. I believe that there are 30 birds up there currently and there are plenty within their life span, so that even if one were to fail, there is plenty of back up. We thought that it was fantastic when Sat Nav came along and we could get a good fix (far better than celestial) every 6 hours.

The Russian system has been operational for some time. The European system is about to go no line. The Chinese have a sytem which is at least partly operational. There are plenty of other sources for the atomic clocks--and even the GPS satellites are occasionally interacted by ground systems.

Don't fear--GPS is still here! But the government needs to be aware of the potential problems--which I am sure that they are. What it takes to sell magazines and newspapers these days!
 
The GPS system will not be allowed to fail. Of that you can be sure.

Most of the discussion so far on this thread has concerned navigation. Navigation of airplanes, ships, vehicles, etc. is certainly one of the top priorities of the system, however, it is not the only top priority. Many of our modern weapon systems also depend on GPS accuracy. If the GPS system was to fail then some bombs would not be able to hit their targets.

Rightly or wrongly the US must maintain the GPS system to the fullest accuracy until a better system is developed.

G
 
interesting story. How long would you have your job if you told your boss that something would cost X amount of money and it actually cost more than twice as much.
 
Back
Top