Handheld GPS

dkjbama

Member
Member
Joined
Mar 27, 2007
RO Number
25654
Messages
231
I apologize if this has been covered before. I am a lake/river boater, and having spent my entire life on Wilson lake I have never seen the need for a GPS. However, this weekend I will be traveling upriver onto Wheeler lake and up the Elk River. These are new waters to me and I would feel much more comfortable with a handheld GPS. There is no way I can justify even a small-sized chartplotter/permanent GPS on a 21 ft bowrider. I'm thinking I'd like to keep my budget between $150-300. A color screen would be nice, but is definitely not a must-have.

I do have a chart of the lake along with a compass on board, and I feel reasonably comfortable navigating at night, but I just don't know this lake like I do Wilson.

Because of time constraints, I would need to purchase at a local place like walmart or bestbuy.

Any suggestions? Garmin, Magellan, Lowrance?

I'm not looking at going to Bimini or Block Island here, just about 25-30 mi upriver. A GPS would just make me feel a whole lot more comfortable here.

Thanks in advance.
 
If you're fairly new to navigating rivers, be aware that "charts" as we all know them are a bit vague for river use...unless the river is a major navigation way for shipping (ie: the Mississippi). And even then...it's a gamble.

Currents create constant shifting of the bottom and shoaling is common. If there are wing dams used in this river, they will be typically placed to the off channel sides...near the banks. They can extend a ways out and are usually submerged. The best chart made cannot account for wing dams and their placement.

Know where the channel is...it may not be necessarily right in the center. If the ACOE maintains the channel, it will be marked with buoys...stay to the channel. Buoys also drift off-station, so just because it's there...it may not be exactly where it was meant to be. When navigating a river you are not familiar with...even if you see other boats in off channel areas...you stay put. Rivers are great places for stump fields, submerged bridge pilings, etc.
 
Handheld Garmin GPS is all you need along with paper charts, and a Texaco road map. Have a nice trip.
 
I'm not sure a hand held GPS will have the detail that you need for inland waters. You would need a map card or some way to download the data to the gps, assuming the data is available electronically. So maybe your decision should be based on the maps available. Check the respective companies websites to see what they have available for download. Garmin has an Inland Lakes map available but it cost an additional $140. Not sure how detailed it is.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Msibley

If you're fairly new to navigating rivers, be aware that "charts" as we all know them are a bit vague for river use...unless the river is a major navigation way for shipping (ie: the Mississippi). And even then...it's a gamble.

Currents create constant shifting of the bottom and shoaling is common. If there are wing dams used in this river, they will be typically placed to the off channel sides...near the banks. They can extend a ways out and are usually submerged. The best chart made cannot account for wing dams and their placement.

Know where the channel is...it may not be necessarily right in the center. If the ACOE maintains the channel, it will be marked with buoys...stay to the channel. Buoys also drift off-station, so just because it's there...it may not be exactly where it was meant to be. When navigating a river you are not familiar with...even if you see other boats in off channel areas...you stay put. Rivers are great places for stump fields, submerged bridge pilings, etc.






Thanks for your concern. Depth is not an issue where I will be going on the Tenn. R. I will definitely keep your advice in mind though when I enter Elk River from Wheeler Lake. I only have to go about 7-8mi from the head of the Elk to get to my destination, and the river is navigable another 10 or so miles past that. I guess it does help that my boat only draws 22 in of water at rest.
 
Depth isn't so much of an issue here. Because of Wilson and Wheeler dams, the water is DEEP for pretty much my entire journey except for the 8 or so miles on the elk river. I don't need a chartplotter to tell me how deep it is. My main concern is to be able to know WTF I am if have to come back after dark and I get my bearings twisted around on Wheeler.

The Tennessee River, at least close to where I am, is different than the mississippi or ohio because of the dams. There is roughly a 100 ft drop in the riverbed in the 16 miles from wheeler to wilson dam. Current is pretty much nonexistent on Wilson unless you come up right below the turbines of wheeler dam. If the dams weren't there, i would be on a kayaking forum instead of a boating forum.

Has anyone had experience with the Garmin Etrex Vista HcX?
 
Garmin probably makes the best handheld device for this type of use. Garmin does have charts available for in-land lakes and waterways. You can go to their website and it will give you some detail about which ones are available.
 
quote:

I do have a chart of the lake along with a compass on board, and I feel reasonably comfortable navigating at night, but I just don't know this lake like I do Wilson.





Consider not traveling at night then. The thing you have to keep in mind, is that if the body of water you are traveling on is narrow, the gps may tell you that you are traveling over land due to errors. It happens, and it is real. Anyone who says and believes you can trust a gps 100% is a fool or lying.

That being said, it can give you a great indication of your position, and all things taken into consideration is a valued asset in your navigation kit.

At that price point, I would suggest a unit that gave you location, and that you plotted out your intended positions on paper, at various points using extrapolation.

So get your charts out and mark them up with positions. Calculate the lat/lon and mark them on the charts. Transfer the route to the gps and use it for nav input, but keep your eyes on the road.

And, go easy. If you are unsure, back off and go slow!

Getting used to unfamiliar water is a bit of a challenge. Particularly when the distances are great and perspective is new to you given the distances involved. It all opens up and you wonder where you are because the scale of distance shifts.

But it ain't all that bad, and as long as you go slowly and check your work, you will be safe and have a great time.
 
Thanks for all the advice guys. Widthwise, Wheeler dam is approx 6400ft and the lake stays wider than that the entire length of the Tenn R. part of the journey. Elk river would be pretty tough to get lost on, even on a moonless night. For safety's sake I never go above hull speed at night.

It's not really a huge journey or anything probably 30 miles each way. Maybe i'm making more out of it than it really is, I just want all my I's dotted and t's crossed. Then again, I guess I could always just haul it out and drag the trailer up there, but I would really like to be able to make the journey on water.
 
I've found that the handheld GPS units have maps that aren't very accurate. I use mine for the "breadcrumb" trail mostly. That is, I'll scout out a new area, and then save the trail for navigating later. For example, last year at Raystown, we wanted to go about 10 miles down the lake to watch the fireworks, and then navigate back to our campsite in the dark. I took a scouting run down to the fireworks site in the morning, and then I was able to follow my trail back in the dark without worring that I'd get lost in a cove or make a wrong turn up a creek or something.

When we were at the shore this year, I did the same thing. Funny enough, when I looked at my breadcrubm trail later, it showed that I had run right over the land in some instances (hmmmm, now I know where that dream came from!).

BTW, I have a Magellan Explorist 200 that I got at Sears for about $149 2 years ago.
 
BAMA, you didnt even offer to stop by and pick me up on your way to Wheeler. You just aint 'it' boy!

I have Garmin 72. I use it on Smith lake which is similar to Wheeler. (did you know Alabama has NO natural lakes? Not even one! The lakes and resivours are all dammed up streams)

Being in Alabama makes me just damn near illiterate, and the Garmin 72's instruction book verifies the fact.
It's so complex and confusing I've never really been able to use the book for anything.

I put in Way points by using the MOB feature. (Press and hold the MOB key, and it logs the place your wife fell out of the boat)
Then I just have to remember them by the MOB1, MOB2 etc. I know there's a way to re-name those waypoints, I just cant figure it out.

On Smith, before I knew my way around, I used the Track feature. It shows on a little dotted line your trail. It references the starting point.
So if you went around a corner, then around another corner and up into a large bay, you'd be lost without the 'bread crumb trail' to show you which way to go. You can have two waypoints, near each other, with a mountain in between them. The Bread crumb trail shows you how you wound up on the other side of the mountain.
I like the Speed feature and the distance from/to the last/next waypoint.

So....the Garmin 72 is a good GPS with a really BAD book. Another example of Digitally expert whiz kids left alone in a dark room with no adult supervision.
 
I have the Lowrance iFinder H2O. It is a HH GPS with both hiking and boating charts combined. I have used the same s/w [an additional cost] for the mountains where I liver and the navigable Delta where I boat. With the base s/w, your location will be waaay off! But I've found that the Map Create v7 s/w works really well with good accuracy.

One of the great things about the Lowrance is that, as long as the batteries do not go dead, it will automatically remember where you have been and with only turning the unit on, it automatically gives you a cookie crumb. I suggest you also get the cig lighter adapter for the unit will eat up those internal batteries [four AAs] very quickly!

Lowrance's User's Guide isn't any better then Thuddie's Garmin IMHO!
http://www.lowrance.com/en/Products/Outdoors/iFINDER-H2O/
 
"The thing you have to keep in mind, is that if the body of water you are traveling on is narrow, the gps may tell you that you are traveling over land due to errors."

P7291356.jpg
 
Oh yeah Bill, that'd confuse me!
I guess I've never been in that kind of a place before.
Liz is right about the Cigar lighter adaptor.
I have one, for the very reson Liz mentioned. Those HH's use batteries like a Wino going through Muscatel.
 
"The thing you have to keep in mind, is that if the body of water you are traveling on is narrow, the gps may tell you that you are traveling over land due to errors. It happens, and it is real. Anyone who says and believes you can trust a gps 100% is a fool or lying."

It is the underlying chart data that is the problem. The actual GPS calculated data will always be very accurate.

G
 
quote:

Originally posted by blouderback

quote:

Originally posted by gcolton

It is the underlying chart data that is the problem.






Didn't I say that like 2 days ago?








No. You did not specify where the error originated.

G
 
Well on a lighter note and this was something touched on by CaptBill1, here's a aerial view of the Big Su river between Anchorage and Talkeetna.
Imagine what your GPS might tell you about navigating this?
Matanuskariver600x400.jpg
 
Back
Top