Help me with "Battery Math"

GonzoF1

Member
Joined
Jun 29, 2009
RO Number
31468
Messages
266
I have 4x 6v golf cart batteries rated at 105 reserve minutes as my house bank and I'm trying to convert it to amp-hours.

Conventional wisdom says that if it can deliver 25A for 105 minutes then it could do 210 at 12, 420 at 6 and 840 at 3... Solving the way I would THINK would be correct would be 25*105=2625 minutes. Then 2625/60=43.75 (converting to hours from minutes).

A Google search has many conflicting formulas to solve it. None of which bode well for me. I've see (RC/2)+16 (That solves to 68) and RC*0.4 (That solves to 42).

Is this right? If so, I had no idea it was so low. I thought (and have been told) those batteries are more like 210 Ah. They are wired in series/parallel for 12v so that will ONLY gives me less than 100 Ah on a 35' trawler. Not NEARLY enough.

Can someone check my math and/or confirm the amp-hours of these batteries (Wal-Mart). I want to start learning how to anchor out and that is hardly possible with this little bit of reserve power. Please help!

Thanks.
 
Install a generator LOL. I can't help you but I'm interested in seeing what answers you get.
 
I have just the battery for you, it can run my 5000lb Clarke electric forklift for 12 hours before recharging. The down side is its 36volts, measures 38x34x23 and weighs 3540lbs.
 
Generally golf cart batteries are around 220 amp hours at 6V. By putting them in Series you get 220AH at 12V, now with your second bank of 2 batteries , you should have about 440 AH, now you can run them down to 50% so that gives you 220 Amp hours of usable power. At 25 amps, you should get about 8-9 hours. You shoudl be abel to get your draw down much lower than that for longer duration.
 
How do you get that 220Ah number per 6v cell?

Are GC batteries able to run down further or is the 50% at the 10.5v floor? (yes... I have read Nigel's book) :)

Already have a genset... Thanks for asking, Chris. ;-)
 
10.5VDC is a fully discharged 12V battery bank or battery. 220AH per 6V battery or 2 in series gives you 12VDC at 220AH's. 2-6VDC Golfcart style battery banks (4-6VDC batteries) will give you 440AH's at 12VDC or at 50% discharged 220AH's of usable house power at 12VDC.
But 2 8D Lifeline AGM's will give you 510AH's of house current or 255AH's at 50% discharge.
Bill
 
Tom,

It's actually a guesstimate based on an informal survey of 6V golf cart offerings. I had energizers form Sams' club that were rates at 220, looking at the trojan lineup they vary from 189AH to 240AH, so maybe 200AH is a safer assumption if it is not marked on your batteries.

You may get a little more than 50% fromt the GC batteries but 10.5 V is about the limit. Not sure exactly how far down that is. My inverter woud lalarm and start cutting out at 10.7 V or so. The advantage of the GC batteries is that you can run them down and recharge them repeatedly without losing capacity or the ability to hold a charge.
 
Then there's the theory that we can take the bank down to 30% when we have to, but 50% should be the norm. However, getting to 100% recharge is hard, but 80% is easy (the last 20% takes a long time). Thus, we all have only about 35% of Ah available to us at any given time.

Tom, you've got a good house bank (especially with a genset). You just need to put a monitor on it (like a Xantrex LinkPro).
 
10.5VDC on a 12.6VDC system is considered fully discharged.
Speaking of time and available AH's that is whre AGM's shine. You need a charger and or alternotor and controller capable of putting out some serious current but they recover faster than conventional Wet Cell batteries. AGM's also recover from deeper discharges without as much damage.
Bill
 
quote:

Originally posted by gardnersf

I had energizers form Sams' club that were rates at 220,






See now... I have the EXACT same battery and all it says is 105 Min Reserve. I get all the math on series parallel and how that works, but my question is how we get from 105 mRC to 220Ah? I'm curious about the formula... if there IS one.

I'm not drilling you. I do trust what you are saying and hope it's correct. I have been worried about this for some time now and have never gotten a straight answer from anyone. It's holding me back from learning to anchor out.

In addition, is there a good meter that doesn't set me back $300?
 
OK, Here are the definitions.

Battery Storage Capacity Ratings

Two standard ratings are used to measure a battery's storage capacity.

Amp Hours

The Amp Hour rating tells you how much amperage is available when discharged evenly over a 20 hour period. The amp hour rating is cumulative, so in order to know how many constant amps the battery will output for 20 hours, you have to divide the amp hour rating by 20. Example: If a battery has an amp hour rating of 75, dividing by 20 = 3.75. Such a battery can carry a 3.75 amp load for 20 hours before dropping to 10.5 volts. (10.5 volts is the fully discharged level, at which point the battery needs to be recharged.) A battery with an amp hour rating of 55 will carry a 2.75 amp load for 20 hours before dropping to 10.5 volts.

Reserve Minutes

Reserve minutes is the number of minutes a battery will carry a 25 amp load before dropping to 10.5 volts. (10.5 volts is the fully discharged level, at which point the battery needs to be recharged.)

Now, I had 4 golf cart batteries on my 26 footer with an inverter and no generator. With the fridge, lights, radio, some lights, I could get 10-12 hours. I had to run the engines to get a recharge and as previously noted, alternators are not great deep cycle chargers so I would only get to about 80-85 % charge off the engines. When I got back to shore, the 3 stage charger that was part of the inverter would get the full charge.

Currently I have only two group 29 dual purpose batteries and I still can go many hours withotu killing them. However they are also my engine batteries so dead batteries really suck ;. I have a generator but I am still using the original battery charger from 1986. i plan on putting the invertercharger back in and adding 400-600 AH AGM house bank.
 
Gonz, the total available charge is dependent on several factors. One of the important factors is the rate of discharge. There is really no such thing as a "100A lead acid battery" unless you include other measurement conditions.

"Reserve minutes" is a common spec that is used, though a better one to use is the "20 hr discharge rate". One of the problems with "Reserve minutes" is tat it is not really standardized.

But back to your question: "how do you get from 105 rm to 220AH?"

Well, actually, you don't ;). 105 min ( 1.75 hrs ) at 25A/h rate to fully discharge a fully charged battery ( and I mean, fully! ). If you used a more common, more standardized rate of discharge either the 5A or 20A rate, you would get a much longer time. And it is not linear.

If you want the exact specs, I would suggest a bit of digging for the specs on your particular battery ( you did not specify the battery, so I cannot do said research for you... ). With a bit of luck you will find graphic, or tabular data that will give a better definition of "how much charge is available".

Here is the data table for Interstate Golf Batteries. Most golf cart batteries will have very nearly the same "numbers". Note that they have ratings ( 20 hr rate ) in the 220 to 250 AH range. Note also that the "reserve minutes" are calculated at -both- 25A and 75A rates!

After you find the "fully charged to fully dead" capacity, then assume that only 50% will be available ( ie: you will normally operate from 90% charged down to 40% charged ). And that is the number to firmly fix in your mind...

And if you think that is confusing, that was the "abbreviated, summary" explanation!
 
To further complicate or simplfy you need to add up all the devices and the time they will be in use this is called a AH load calculator. Only then can the battery bank can then be properly sized. I have a .XLS spreadsheet I used when designing my house system. There is a good rule of thumb the heavier the battery bank the longer it will last. If you can't go bigger even my boat is at it's battery limits weight wise add a few solar panels and this adds positive AH's to the equation when on the hook.
Bill
 
Thanks Bill & Bill & Scott & Bill & Kurt :)

They are Energizer EGC-2... From Sam's Club

When I look at that chart, Bill... No not YOU, Bill... the OTHER Bill :) When I look at the chart, while it shows the Ah of most of the 6v stock at 200-ish, it then shows the rates of them in Reserve Minutes under 25A load way upwards of 400-500RC. My batteries, that I must assume are also rated at 25A to determine reserve capacity, is a puny little 105RC. Why is THAT?
 
This is what my notes on the subject say:

Most marine/RV-deep cycle batteries are rated on a 20-hour discharge rate. Example: a 100 Ah battery can deliver 5 amps for 20 hours (amps x hours = Ah).

So Amp Hours are based on a 5 amp load. Reserve Minutes are based on a 25 amp load. All the more to confuse the end user! :-)
 
quote:

Originally posted by GonzoF1

In addition, is there a good meter that doesn't set me back $300?






Yes, a good digital volt meter will work just fine if all you want to do is keep track of the state of charge of your batteries.
 
I ve never bothered trying to convert reserve amp etc. It s good discussion in winter I guess.

All golfcart batteries I ve looked at are rated at about 220AH and 50% is about as far as you want to go. One limitation to using a voltmeter is that voltage will be lower under load. With an inverter for instance and the low voltage cut out set at about 50% discharge you will trigger that whne a fridge starts. Then you read the voltage on the remote and see well above 50% remaining because the inverter is off

Your four batteries will produce around 440ah total at 12v with around 220ah usable
 
Don't forget to oversize your battery cabling and use marine grade connectors. Less resistance + higher voltage = less current draw at the main DC panel.
I like to install "T" class high current fuses at each house battery bank at a minimum.
Bill
 
quote:

Originally posted by Billylll

Don't forget to oversize your battery cabling and use marine grade connectors. Less resistance + higher voltage = less current draw at the main DC panel.
I like to install "T" class high current fuses at each house battery bank at a minimum.
Bill






That's is certainly on the top of the list. My boat is an '86 and uses the old welding cable for the primary wires. The ends have started working loose and it's time to redo them. What gauge should I look for?
 
Back
Top