I walked to old inlet this past saturday, and in my opinion they should leave it open. the Bay is clear, yes you can actually see the bottom, not just green and brown water like the past 10 years. secondly, has anyone lobbying to close the inlet actually walked fire island from Smiths point to the inlet? there are NO DUNES. if you close the inlet at old inlet, the next storm will just open a new inlet somewhere else. before a project can begin to close the inlet, the dunes would have to be rebuilt otherwies it's pointless. you can stand at the edge of the ocean, and see Bellport with no dunes blocking your line of sight.
in my opinion, the money would be much better spent raising the bulkheads and backfilling them along the areas that are flooding, and not waisted filling in an inlet that will reopen again.
I feel very bad for the people along the shore that are dealing with water coming into their houses, but no one forced you to buy a house on the water, and for years I have heard that sea levels will rise due to the melting ice caps.
Hypothetically speaking if the inlet is closed, and the water levels do not lower, whats the next step?